I wasn't sure what to expect from this book but came away from it grateful that Leah Williams and Carlos Gomez infused it with so much life and purpose. The Amazing Mary Jane has a strong identity and a crackerjack wit. It's a strong first issue on its own merits. Read Full Review

The Amazing Mary Jane #1 is a fun ride with one of the more endearing characters of the Spider-Canon. Read Full Review

Rather like MJ's acting career, this book has potential aplenty, and I look forward to the next issue. Lights, camera, ACTION! (in 30 days of course) Read Full Review

Mary Jane is an actress. Mysterio is a filmmaker. They have a mutual acquaintance. It makes sense that they would work together...kind of surprising that it hadnt happened earlier actually. Its a delicious set-up for a slightly off-center superhero comic. Given the right momentum, Williams and Gomez could really turn Mary Jane into a major leading lady. Read Full Review

This was a fun first issue. I thought the premise was strange, but Williams writes it in a way that takes away the seriousness without making it campy. I found the story enjoyable and the pace of the plot to be fun and light. Carlos Gomez complements that tone with some impressive and beautifully detailed art. A fun issue that makes me want to read what's next. Read Full Review

I don't know what I thought The Amazing Mary-Jane #1 would be, but it wasn't what I got. It's even better. The characterization of Mary Jane and Mysterio feels effortlessly compelling, and their dynamic is what makes the book work. On top of that, the Carlos Gomez art is entirely effective, though a little on the safe side. This series is, at least so far, not your traditional Marvel superhero fare. It may go that direction in the future, but if it continues to essentially be a weird indie book about an actress and a supervillain then I'll be perfectly happy. Read Full Review

The Amazing Mary Jane #1 (Williams, Gomez, Lopez) is a fun opening look on an overdue story. Williams does a great job crafting dialogue that showcases different sides of MJ: confidence, compassion, humor, with the artwork providing solid support. The first issues show that with this creative team Mary Jane has the star power to headline her own comic; and leaves me interested in seeing more. Read Full Review

Despite a far-fetched story, this issue has pretty much what I want in a comic. Really good art, for the most part, and a FUN story. Throw in a few nice easter eggs that long-time fans will no doubt pick up on, and we've got a good start to this ongoing series. Read Full Review

As long as you can separate this comic from the regular Spider Man mythos its a fun, quirky, and well written book that has some interesting things to say about Hollywood and comic book movies. Read Full Review

Carlos Gomezs art is expressive and playful, which is what youd want from a Mary Jane comic. Its also consistent with the aesthetic established by Ryan Ottley on Spencers Amazing Spider-Man, making a seamless transition between readers of the flagship title and this spinoff. I havent been following Amazing Spider-Man too closely, but based on what I know of that ongoing story (as well as Ottleys art) this title feels like part of a whole with that one, which is a credit to Williams and Gomez. Read Full Review

The solid writing and art, coupled with a unique and interesting premise, make for a good opening chapter to this offbeat comic. Read Full Review

The Amazing Mary Jane #1 is solid start to her first solo outing. Williams writes a lovable and believable MJ that you can get behind, navigating appropriately absurd circumstances to give her plenty to speak her mind about. It’s funny and heart-warming, with art that strongly enhances the qualities that make it both of those. MJ fans can check this out and expect a pretty good time. Read Full Review

Amazing Mary Jane #1 may not be as, well, amazing as its title would imply, but it is a very entertaining reading experience. Yes, there are opportunities for meaningful discussion that it avoids in favor of a broader appeal, but the safe approach by Leah Williams and the Carloses might pay off in the long run. After all, a broader appeal means a wider reach, which can in turn lead to more opportunities. Read Full Review

Despite arriving at just the right time, The Amazing Mary Jane #1 doesn't exactly live up to its name. Read Full Review

Amazing Mary Jane #1 is a solid start to the latest addition in the Spider-Man line of comic books. Leah Williams portrays Mary Jane Watson as a highly charismatic character with a strong fortitude that shows the great potential of this series. Williams just needs to be careful to not fall into several pitfalls that popped up due to certain story choices. Avoiding those pitfalls while focusing on the strengths will be key to Amazing Mary Jane's success. Read Full Review

Heres the second problem I have with this book: WHY DOES IT EXIST? Nobody was clamoring for a Mary Jane book. The new Spider-man movie is still a couple of years away at most and while the comedy is great, the main idea of trying to get this movie made just doesnt seem that interesting. It doesnt justify spending 4 dollars over and over again. It may be good for others, but I simply read too much every week to give this my money. Read Full Review

The Amazing Mary Jane might feel like a disconnect from Nick Spencer's take on the character, but the moviemaking angle gives the series a unique enough spin to give the second issue a shot. Read Full Review

The Amazing Mary Jane #1 spends more time establishing a fun scenario rather than actually utilizing that scenario to make a good story. Read Full Review

In the end, your enjoyment of Amazing Mary Jane will come down to your ability to cope with terrible artwork to enjoy a well-written story. I wasn't up to the task, great though Williams' dialogue is. Hopefully she'll find a more capable partner on future projects. Read Full Review

A dull premise and inability to live up to its own promises leave The Amazing Mary Jane dead on arrival. Read Full Review

AMJ #1 was really good. I started reading ASM in my teens during the One More Day storyline. I loved those issues that were just these long arguments between MJ and Peter, so much so that I got to learn every line of hers by heart. So AMJ #1 hits close to home.

This was fun and well written. Not how I expected the story to go, but I like it nonetheless.

Surprisingly very enjoyable issue! Art was solid and Leah Williams did an alright job on the dialogue. Story is one I can get behind. Plus that cliffhanger, well done! Would easily recommend this issue.

If you know the reason for this book to exist, I mean, you actually read The Amazing Spider-Man (2018 run) then I think you can get an idea about it, so taking that into account, it is a solid start, the art is beautiful.

" WE ARE MAK--ING ART HERE ! "
- MYSTERIO

A pretty good start to what seems to be a really fun book in the making. The writing was good even if the story doesn't seem to offer much yet, and the artwork, while quite generic, but looks really nice - or at least the MJ does.

Rather disappointing.

This was nothing unmissable and the art is a dreadful collection of poor imitations of great Spider-Man artists, but ultimately this comic was a hoot and I'm glad I didn't skip it.

Its fun. Its nothing special but, was perfectly enjoyable.

This was okay but I didn’t love it.

This comic spends so much time winking at the camera that "plot" becomes an afterthought. I'm coming to believe that that's Leah Williams' signature shtick, and I don't care for it. You can't do a meaningful deconstruction of a story if you're too preoccupied to tell a story in the first place.

This comic is horrible; I do not know why some Authors & some Publishers decide to give non-superheroes their own comics, especially when their whole existence is based on a superhero. In this comic Mary Jane is an Actress starring in a movie with real life Villains. She took the role because of the high-profile Director who come to find out is actually Mysterio, who is trying to tell his life story. Mary Jane is unhappy with the script; & that's basically the whole comic in a nutshell. Lots of talking, no action; at the end you see a few villains plotting but you're unsure of their actually intentions and I'll never find out due to this comic being boring.

I 👏 can't 👏 believe 👏 Mysterio 👏 talks 👏 in 👏 claps 👏. Do 👏 you 👏 think 👏 Leah 👏 has 👏 a 👏 Twitter 👏 addictio- and I oop. Okay, I can believe the last bit. Peter is definitely a VSCO girl.