/Annual_1.jpg "Uncanny X-Men Annual #1")
CRITIC REVIEWS Back to Top
-
9.5
AIPT - Chris Hassan
Jan 23, 2019Ed Brisson and Carlos Gomez set Scott Summers up for one Hell of a second act in this very pleasing annual. Read Full Review
-
9.5
Lyles Movie Files - Jeffrey Lyles
Jan 25, 2019X-Men fans, this was the return you've been waiting on. Brisson and Gomez make an easy case for the return of X-Men's leader and with a refocused Cyclops back, things are about to get much more interesting. Read Full Review
-
9.4
The Super Powered Fancast - Deron Generally
Jan 24, 2019I loved the art in this issue. Carlos Gomez does some amazing things visually with this issue. The highlight is definitely the throwback, newsprint visual style of the first flashback. It looks amazing. Read Full Review
-
9.4
Comic Watch - Steve Batley
Jan 25, 2019Putting aside the McGuffin Cage and Bables blurred lines of logic and motivation, I have to say this is the turning point of the Uncanny X-Men right here. Everything else was preamble and now that Slim is back we have some definitive direction coming our way. Welcome back Summers, weve missed you. Read Full Review
-
9.0
Comics: The Gathering - Ryan.L
Jan 24, 2019I thoroughly enjoyed this issue a lot and it's about time. Some of the previous Uncanny issues felt a little mediocre and this one shows that we finally have the right person on the flagship book. Brisson just manages to encapsulate everything that makes a great X-book. Pick this one up, it's also a great jumping on point for new readers to Uncanny X-Men. Read Full Review
-
9.0
All-Comic - Jeremy Matcho
Jan 26, 2019Cyclops is back and Ed Brisson is setting him up to be better than ever! Read Full Review
-
8.5
Weird Science Marvel Comics - Jim Werner
Jan 25, 2019This Annual suddenly has me excited about the Uncanny X-Men book. The varied art by Carlos Gomez was great and Ed Brissons story felt smart, exciting and important. If you have been reading Uncanny, this is a must read and if you bailed out of the series, this may get you fired up to jump back in. Read Full Review
-
8.0
The Beat - Alexander Jones
Jan 23, 2019For hardcore X-Men fans, Uncanny X-Men Annual #1 is a definitive BUY! Read Full Review
-
8.0
Comic Crusaders - Kevin Given
Jan 28, 2019It's a wild ride as we explore the psyche of Scott Summers. Brilliant writing makes this an easy, yet somehow complex, read. Cyclops saved Paul Douek so it's only fitting that Paul return the favor here. Cable's role is necessary to this story and I wouldn't have it any other way. We get a tour of Scott's life before we see his ultimate triumph over death. And this is Marvel story telling at it's finest. **** (8.8 rating) Read Full Review
-
7.2
Graphic Policy - Brett
Jan 23, 2019The issue does what it's supposed to, answer the question as to how Cyclops came back from the dead. The reason delivered is a shrug and a little convoluted but some of the meta discussion makes it all rather interesting. If you're itching to know how it all goes down, then this issue is a must but beyond that, this isn't an issue that really excites. Read Full Review
-
7.0
Newsarama - Pierce Lydon
Jan 23, 2019Ultimately, it's great to have Scott Summers back even if the way he gets there is a little convoluted and strange. I mean, this is still an X-Men comic, we're all aware of what we signed up for. Welcome back, Cyclops. Read Full Review
-
7.0
Comic Book Revolution - Kevin Lainez
Jan 24, 2019Uncanny X-Men Annual #1 is not a perfect issue but it does succeed in its most important mission of returning Cyclops back to life. Ed Brisson used everything that Cyclops did and how things turn out for him to create strong motivation for what will push the character forward. With where the X-Men are now Cyclops returning as the team's leader couldn't come at a better time. Hopefully the positive character work done here is a sign of compelling stories to be told in the pages of Uncanny X-Men. Read Full Review
-
6.5
Black Nerd Problems - Jon-Carlos Evans
Jan 28, 2019The question remains - is the revived Cyclops the Cyclops we want or need right now? Read Full Review
-
5.0
Razorfine - Alan Rapp
Jan 28, 2019The story by writer Ed Brisson and Carlos Gomez ties in a flashback to a scientist crucial for Cable to bring Cyclops back (and printing it in old-school comic-style was a nice touch). As we've seen elsewhere, the new Cable is a bit of a dick forcing Cyclops to choose between helping the X-Men or saving the innocent man who resurrected him. Rebranding the character firmly back in the hero column, the real question is where does Cyclops go from here in his steps to rebuild the X-Men? Worth a look. Read Full Review
-
4.0
ComicBook.com - Jamie Lovett
Jan 23, 2019The issue has solid art and some strong character work, but otherwise, it feels like a continuity bridge between two different eras of X-Men and little else. Read Full Review
USER REVIEWS Back to Top
-
10
Perfect. Brisson developed a very good way to bring back such an important character that was severely disrespected over the last decade. Excellent art and a very good story, that bring back the first x-men and the true leader of this team.
+ Like • Comment• Likes (1) -
10
I wish Ed Brisson was writting the X Men title and not just the annual
-
9.5
Lit AF
-
9.0
I've missed you Scott. And I'm glad you are back and better than ever.
-
9.0
YOU MAY HAVE THOUGHT SPOILERS WERE DEAD, BUT ALAS, THEY ARE VERY ALIVE IN THIS REVIEW! THE GOOD: -This Uncanny X-Men series is really starting to pick up. This was a great issue that let us know the story behind how Scott's alive. -Really great art, especially the flashback scenes. -Solid writing. I like the dialogue especially. -Cool opening scene. I thought it was well-executed. -That flashback scene was great and nostalgic in all the right ways. -I thought the Paul Douek storyline was really nice and compelling. -It was interesting to see them go through the Death of X, Phoenix Resurrection and X-Men Disassembled story lines in a different point of view. -I really liked both Scott and Nate in this issue. more
-
9.0
Kid Cable runs a complicated timey-wimey caper to explain how Cyclops is alive again. The upshot is, a little judiciously-applied super-science finessed the temporary rebirth the Phoenix performed during Resurrection and made it permanent. Plenty of attention is paid to the logic of it all, and the story also features some nice character work on Kid Cable and Scott. Part of the former's plan involves presenting the latter with a little character test before releasing him back into the wild. Cyclops passes with flying colors - as does this compelling comic.
-
8.5
I stop the monthly very fast. It wasn't good for my point of view. It was very very bad in fact. But. But I read a good review about this story and I decide to take it. I wanted to give it his chance. And I was surprised in the good way. It's not perfect, but Brisson use the timeline smartly and damn I liked his cyclop. I'm not a fan of Boyscout Cyclop. I liked him when he stood for what was right to stand (But didn't like that marvel make him a terrorist). And I'm ok with what I read there. Cover - Not really in link but nice. 1/2 Writing - It's simple, that use well many X-men story (Who was bad for most) and that pose a brand new good cyclop. Yes the solution is a deus ex machina, but at least Brisson didn't try to sell a brand new more
-
8.5
This was really good. It brings Cyclops back in a reasonable (for comics) way.
-
8.5
At this point the best issue of the series.
-
7.5
Fine. Not great, but Brisson did his homework.
-
7.5
Super excited that Scott is back. The way they killed him off was dumb, so I am glad they made it happen, although I am sad that we still haven't seen the Scott, Jean meet up yet. This is like Mary Jane and Peter, Marvel just doesn't want them to be happy. Ever. The reason the book got a bit lower was because Scott's voice seemed off. Maybe it's because he's been dead for so long, but it just didn't read like a leader, it read more like a lackey. I have high hopes for him and Logan to team up... I mean my two favorite X-Men, working together and saving the mutant race? Yeah, sign me up.
-
7.5
This was a pretty cool issue even though time travel sucks.
-
10
-
9.5
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
6.5
2025 In Review:
