This issue is fantastic. Using subtle storytelling Tynionweaved an amazing story of family and the past, while explosively bringing us into the present. I didn't expect such a powerful story, nor for it to come in such a subtle way! Read Full Review

While some of the Rebirth titles initial story arcs lost steam midway through, Detective is five issues in and remains just as exhilarating as it began. As usual the two weeks for the next installment cant get here fast enough for me. Read Full Review

Look,Detective Comics #939 isn't a perfect comic. But no comic is perfect, and this gets about as close as may be possible. The creative team executes the whole affair with utter perfection. Just when I thought this was a series that couldn't get any better, it proved to me that it most definitely could. Read Full Review

Detective Comics #939 is proof that characters can go a long way to making a comic book great. James Tynion IV has found a groove in his writing, balancing the cast members as they go through this turbulent time. The emphasis on Red Robin is well timed; after having built up the young man's indecision in previous chapters, his choices here are satisfying to read. Artist Eddy Barrows returns in top form, his expressive characters keeping the drama flowing even as the action slows for a moment. That won't be the case for long however, as Tim Drake's decisions look to have dangerous consequences. Read Full Review

The bottom line is the same as it's been for the whole run: the book is fantastic. While this issue wasn't packed with action, it was filled with great characterization and important plot points that will clearly have an impact going forward. What the impact will be remains to be seen, but I recommend coming along for the ride. The art is always high quality, and the writing is compelling. For some of the coolest things to appear in DETECTIVE COMICS, you need to read this story arc. You won't regret it. Read Full Review

Detective Comics once again serves up an action and character-packed adventure. The stakes are higher than they've been, and my investment in thecast continues to deepen as the characters are developed. James Tynion has said that he would love to take this book to #1000; after such a hot start, I'd be happy to follow him all the way there. Read Full Review

This was another great issue of Tynion's Bat Team. It's got action, it's got great character moments, it's got amazing art. This is everything you could want from a comic about the Bat-Family. Heck, if I wasn't afraid he was going to die, the Red Robin scenes would be thrilling. This is the coolest Tim has been since the launch of the New 52. Just look at this badassery. Read Full Review

Let me tell you that Detective Comics #939 contains a twist/cliffhanger that will make the wait for the next issue pure agony as the conclusion to this arc has achieved "can't miss" status. Needless to say, 'Tec firmly remains the strongest of the flagship Batman titles. Read Full Review

Anyways, this series just doesn't let up, Tynion and co. leave us with another exciting cliffhanger after a fun issue. The whole arc has been fantastic. I'm excited to see how "Rise of the Batmen" reads all together after the final issue comes out next month. Read Full Review

Unlike Action Comics opening storyline, this lengthy arc has yet to overstay its welcome. Read Full Review

The issue didn't have the “holy shit” moment I expected from the teaser, but it does have an ending that's really cool and not exactly where I thought things were going. Luckily we don't have too long until the next issue and I can't wait. Read Full Review

Six issues into “Rise Of The Batmen” and it proves to be a well-crafted story with a killer plot that's littered with twists and action galore. Yet when Tynion takes a second to let things breathe, he somehow continues to keep the momentum high and further the stakes. Detective Comics continues to be a must-read series for all Batman fans as Tynionand team deliver on all fronts. Read Full Review

While I certainly expect Tim Drake to survive, the issue does tease his upcoming absence in the title. I'll be curious to see what that means for the team and its other members (particularly Spoiler). Writer James Tynion IV has fashioned, by far, my favorite of the Rebirth Bat-Books and I'm in no hurry to see one of the characters depart. Worth a look. Read Full Review

No question this is the best issue of this arc so far. There is a solid mix of action and character building while setting up for a thrilling finale. Just to top things off we also getClayface as effective comic relief. What more can you ask for? Read Full Review

Batman and Batwoman take decisive steps to defeat the Colonys plans for good, but Tim is forced to put himself in deadly danger as a result. Read Full Review

Speaking of distracting, damn those eyes! They stare straight through me! Read Full Review

This was a down issue of Detective Comics.  It is full out setup and while it sets up some pretty good stuff, we are forced to wait until at least next issue for any sort of payoff.  Throw in some of the worst art this series has seen so far and this is the first issue of Rebirth Detective Comics that I can't outright recommend. Read Full Review

Issue 939 covers a lot of bases. 3-4 character really get a chance to shine. The cover is a good representation of the issue as Tim Drake probably gets the most attention but there is also some great conversation between Batman and Batwoman. I thought this arc was maybe starting to run too long but it turns out its only getting better.

Best DC release of the week. Tim Drake is done superbly, with Batwoman becoming the strong lead we all knew she would be. If you are not reading Detective then I would point you to the score of this comic.

Amazing issue but I wished they wrapped the Death of ******** right here.

Detective is arguable better than the Batman title as of right now. I like how Detective makes me feel like investing in the Batman and Robin Eternal series wasn't a complete waste of money, as it builds on the characters and storylines that series introduced. It does seem ominous for Drake on the very last page but I think he's the only Robin that has yet to experience a notable death out of the main 4 Robins.

God I love this series! Really hope they're not going to kill Tim Drake next issue, like the foreshadowing leads us to believe they might. This series has made him an invaluable addition to the Batfamily again, in a way he hasn't been at least since the introduction of Damien.

another solid issue in a run that is easily becoming one of my favorite Batman stories in years!!!!! . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . i won't spoil what exactly what it was, but 'The Black-line' bit of the story was pretty frikken DOPE!!!!! . . . . . . . . . . . also, VERY awesome scene with Clayface!!! . . . but the way the issue ended . . . . . all i can say is - . . . . . Damn Tim Drake, . . . . you crazy, selfless, SON OF A B@%$#!!!!!!!

Action-pumped, but still a well-developed story

The action continues to build up as Tynion moves towards the final chapter of what has been one of the biggest comic surprises of the year. The action set-pieces and the story continue to work well, but Tynion's real strength is his ability to make small character moments standout. Whether it's Clayface's confusion about everything, or his love for Tim Drake (the best Robin), Tynion has shown that he has grown as a writer. Eddy Barrows returns on art and delivers a great-looking issue.

Some good stuff, some bad stuff here. Most of this issue flowed well, except for the contrived writing that leads to the cliffhanger. The only reason there's any tension to the cliffhanger is because of the rumors of a certain character being killed off. Barrows is back on art, and his work is considerably weaker than Martinez's.