It's an understatement to say that Wanda has a legacyon the page, screen, and otherwiselike no other, and Scarlet Witch #1 is an excellent addition to that. Read Full Review

The Last Door is such a simple idea that it almost seems like its TOO easy. What could be simpler than Wanda and Darcy and the door? New adventures will pop through the door every couple of months or so. Its nice and tidy. No need for any greater complexity. Themes can spin out in 1-2 issue arcs. Lots of different things can be explored. It all feels so well-defined right from the first issue. The challenge is going to lie in keeping the form from overwhelming the emotional center of the series. Read Full Review

A refreshing new start for Wanda, with a lot of elements familiar from her recent TV outing, with evocative art and well-done dialogue throughout. Read Full Review

SCARLET WITCH #1 is a promising first issue. Its light on character development, but that isnt a huge drawback. There are enough character moments to drive curiosity in future issues, and it avoids continuity messiness that is as likely to turn readers off as it is to engage them. What really drives the series potential is the concept of the Last Door. Making it untethered from specific corners of the Marvel universe (magic, mutants, cosmic, etc.) keeps storytelling possibilities remain wide open. The series only real limit is how imaginative Orlando can be when it comes to the characters stepping through that door. Read Full Review

Pichelli delivers some beautiful art in the first issue. The characters are dynamic and the world of the story is beautifully detailed and visually dynamic. Read Full Review

Don't miss out on SCARLET WITCH #1, there is something special brewing in this book. Read Full Review

Scarlet Witch #1 is an enjoyable read created by people who not only understand the character of Wanda as she is, but in terms of who she needs to be and where she needs to go. Read Full Review

Scarlet Witch is a good comic that approaches its characters with care and respect. Every scene has a deeply human aspect as we peer into a magical adventure of people doing their best and unpacking incredible mysteries. Scarlet Witch is memorable due to its heartfelt characters and fantastic magical abilities on display. Read Full Review

While I had interest in this I didn't have high hopes because a number of Marvel books I've tried recently have disappointed me. So many tend to be launching points from other events and there's significant catch-up needed or they're just poorly designed openers. Orlando does the expect big moment at the start but once you get past that you get a really engaging book. Just time spent sitting down and talking goes a long way to engaging and connecting us to the characters in a very necessary way as it makes me invested in wanting and looking forward to more. Orlando's able to pace this right and it definitely allows for Pichelli to deliver both in the character design elements but just the settings as well. I hope we get a lot more time in the shop – and Wanda and Darcy just hanging out with dinner and drinks in order to spend time with them and the dynamic that can be explored there. I'm cautiously optimistic. Read Full Review

Steve Orlando and Sara Pichelli kick off the Scarlet Witchs new book, and its beautiful. Sara out does herself here, giving Wanda and her world this old world flair, something youd see in a movie, like the Never-ending Story, or Harry Potters Diagon Alley, while Matthew Wilsons colors pop. I especially like that he renders Wanda and Pietro with a darker hue, paying tribute to their Romani heritage. While the storys villains are rather unremarkable, Orlandos new role for Wanda in the Marvel Universe could create a rather unique niche that weve never had before. Read Full Review

Scarlet Witch #1 is a fun start that can be read as a one-shot or enjoyed to see what else is to come. It feels different in that way from a lot of other comics to hit shelves, and that's a good thing. Despite it's issues, the debut is a fun one that looks to set up a new status quo for the character that opens up a world of opportunity and directions for her to go in to. Here's to see what's next. Read Full Review

This first issue does everything right and it does everything well to set up a new status quo for Wanda and show us a comic worth reading. Consider me on board to check this series out going forward. Read Full Review

Well worth a look if you are a fan of this character and want to see her have her own series. Read Full Review

Steve Orlando and Sara Pichelli hit all the notes that fans want to get from a first issue of a new series. We get the new status quo for Wanda Maximoff established, Scarlet Witch being a superhero, and a hook ending for an even bigger story for the next issue to pick up on. That is all an strong first impression by Scarlet Witch #1 that will leave fans wanting to read more. Read Full Review

Scarlet Witch #1 also boasts the superstar art team of Sara Pichelli and Matthew Wilson, which really makes for some stellar visuals. The Emporium shop feels lived in and cozy, while the various acts of magic come across as appropriately otherworldly. When dealing with magical subject matter, the limit truly doesn't exist, and I hope they get even weirder and weirder with it as the series progresses. (Another point of appreciation: Wanda and her brother Pietro are both depicted with deeper skin tones befitting their traveler heritage, which is often overlooked by color artists in their various other appearances. Details!) Read Full Review

It's literally beautiful. Such a great read

Scarlet Witch #1 by Steve Orlando is a captivating comic book that delivers an engaging storyline, strong character development, and stunning artwork.

The writing is solid, with Orlando's dialogue being well-crafted, conveying the emotional depth of the story without being overly dramatic or forced.

The artwork by Sara Pichelli is exceptional, the illustrations effectively capture the mood and atmosphere of the story, immersing readers in Wanda's world and the challenges she faces.

Overall, Scarlet Witch #1 is a fantastic start to a promising series, offering a fresh perspective on a beloved character and setting the stage for exciting future developments. It is highly recommended for fans of the Scarlet Witch, as well as anyone looking for a well-written and beautifully illustrated comic book. more

Steve Orlando's best work by far with Marvel.
This hit all the right spots. Writing is great and the ARTWORK IS AMAZING, OMG.
Glad I gave this a chance because this has the potential to be a very great run.
Premise is so good Marvel and Disney+ foaming at the mouth.

My QUICK thoughts: unlike Pietro, I'm not afraid to admit that I was...
VERY IMPRESSED❗❗

It felt FRESH & UNIQUE, with the BEST & MOST FAITHFUL VERSIONS of these characters that I've seen, in recent memory. LOVED the new setup & status quo for Wanda! The writing, the art, EVERYTHING, was TOP-SHELF Marvel!

A strong debut for a Scarlet Witch story that sets out to finally move on from the past. I'm not overly familiar with Wanda but her characterization here is very pleasing to me. She feels like a modern witch and I appreciate that while moving on from the past, Orlando doesn't just ignore continuity. The character appearing at the end is an intriguing surprise. I didn't expect her and had all forgotten about the circumstances surrounding her "birth". Orlando also introduces Wanda's current status quo well, I'm curious how much focus the shop'll get.

Sara Pichelli's characters are very expressive without coming across as too cartoonish, making the reactions of the characters genuine and when Wanda turns a truck into water, it looks quite impressive. Wilson's colors really set the tone. The color palette is quite harvest without being dark.

more

Wow! Orlando's name on a comic rarely inspires confidence and the assumption that this was targeted at MCU fans gave me pause, but I always have time for Sara Pichelli and Dauterman's design for Wanda's new costume is stunning, so I figured I'd give it a shot — and what a nice surprise! Dunno what petty thing has got the red 1.0 brigade all swollen with outrage this time, but ignore them: this comic is a delight

I enjoyed this, and my favorite part might be the new status quo it establishes. Wanda's Emporium is a great set-up, it's high time we got Darcy into the comics, and this issue lays plenty of groundwork for future stories.

On the art front, it also looks gorgeous. Complex coloring and a little inking support bring Sara Pichelli back up to her full top-shelf potential.

The plot du jour is a little trite ("ooh, look out, he's Killgrave, but *magic*"), the pace dawdles a bit, and there are a few clumsy lines. But overall, the script is very strong--there are a lot more sharp lines than clumsy ones. This is a much stronger performance than I expected, being no big fan of Steve Orlando.

Mark me down as pleasantly surprised and eager to read more.
more

Not bad at all, and the final page has be wishing for more.

Interesting premise and great art from Sara Pichelli. Orlando's way of laying the narrative feels off for me.

Neat idea with the door that brings those in need to Wanda and really cool costume along with decent art. The biggest problem I have is with Steve Orlando. I've never really been a fan of his and really dislike his writing style. The small talk in the beginning of this issue makes me grind my teeth but the dialogue later in the story is better. A good idea for the series, I just wish the exchanges between the characters flowed better. Again this is just me.

While I'm a fan of the premise, Orlando's weird pacing and stilted dialogue made for a bit of an awkward read. But the premise IS good and has a lot of potential. Leaning into Wanda's past and acknowledging the fact that she has a lot to reconcile for is a good foundation. Hopefully with most of the setup out of the way, Orlando can make the most of it.

Great art and beautiful colours. Lazy story and strangely awkward dialogues.