-
10
A beautiful end to a beautiful story. This was a long and difficult read, but an incredibly rewarding one. Bravo King and Evely!
-
10
Incredible.
Myth and legend combine and this is easily my favorite Supergirl story. Absolutely incredible.
-
10
King stuck the landing.
-
10
What a beautiful surprise this series turned into! A dramatic, passionate and exciting investigation of Supergirl's code against killing ending that shows King understands the character better than the dodgy early chapters suggested, and in the end I even cared about Ruthye. For a while I was just reading this book for the art, but the writing caught up in the end. (Now can Kara have her own series again??)
-
9.0
Series definitely peaked at issue 6 but I still found this to be a solid ending. Evely really did masterful work on this series. There was some slow parts but all in all I really loved what her and King accomplished here.
-
9.0
Well, I did not expect that eding. One of the best Supergirl stories ever.
-
8.5
Just going to leave my review for the entire series as I finally got around to reading it this week.
The choice by King to tell the story "True Grit" style, with narration provided by an older Ruthye, took a bit to click with me. Once we hit the 3rd or 4th issue though, I fell right into Ruthye's cadence and it really became a joy to read. It made the book read very deliberately, which made me really focus on each page, which meant more time to enjoy the fantastic art from Bilquis Evely.
Evely absolutely killed every page of this book, with issues #5 and #6 being particular highlights. I loved the way she depicted the race between Comet and Krem's magic orb, using the De Luca effect masterfully on multiple pages. The way those fun scenes contrasted with the scenes of destruction from the last remaining survivors of Krypton was something special. Her George Perez homage in issue #8 was also just wonderfully done.
King's script was also perfectly tailored to her style. He gave Evely the space to work, which is a credit to him. So many little moments were well done, from the gravedigging scene to the entire issue under the green sun. I also think the big choice he made at the end of #8 was perfectly executed and really displayed the differences why Kara is different from Clark in an organic way.
It's actually surprising to me how many people are misreading the ending. Ruthye's narration throughout the book is her published story to the public, one that contains a false ending where Supergirl kills Krem. In lying about Krem's death at Kara's hands, Supergirl takes the heat from the Brigands off of her new friend and points their ire directly at herself. Instead of killing Krem, they send him to the Phantom Zone. He remerges at the end of the story old and begging for forgiveness, which Ruthye refuses to grant him. Instead she smacks him with her cane as Kara looks on, and leave the old man to his guilt. Ruthye doesn't kill him, she just doesn't forgive him either. It's decidedly not a decision Clark would make, but one that felt very in character for this take on Kara, and it felt very true to the story King told.
If I had any issues, they were rather minor. King resolved the Krypto plot off page, almost as a throwaway, despite that being one of the driving forces pushing Supergirl and Ruthye together. But otherwise there's just too much good here to overlook. more
-
7.5
I'm conflicted on this ending. I feel like there was a good message in there, regarding female empowerment in the face of a world that so often brings them down. I also feel like that message is a bit unearned. If you wanted to make the book about that idea, maybe don't have Kara's feats be so much of generalized heroism, right? The only thing that makes it different is that Supergirl is a woman, but that's a very basic way of looking at these struggles. I don't want to say it feels like an afterthought, because it clearly wasn't. I think it's just a difference in perspective. But I do appreciate the message, buried in a book that I didn't hate, but I wasn't amazed by.
-
7.5
not how prison works
-
6.0
I leave this story as I came into it, with the sense that this was never a Supergirl story. It was a Ruthye story that got Supergirl attached to it. While Ruthye's character stays well told and consistent, Kara continues to be pasted in with little to no regards about her characterization. She becomes whatever is needed to tell Ruthye's story.
Maybe for a Supergirl fan the real payout of this story is that we saw a rare return of Comet. We don't get a deep dive with him and Kara's connection, but then this story was never really about Kara. But for the few panels we do have Comet around, King does portray him pretty well. Of course Comet ultimately cared about Kara because she dedicated her life to helping others. It would have been interested to see why he would care about her dedication to vengeance. Something that we might have dived into, you know, if the story had been about Supergirl. more
-
3.0
Just a horrendous story, yet another one where King takes a noble hero and throws that hero in the dirt probably to alleviate his own conscience and to feel better about himself. Horrible characterization for Supergirl, the "twist" at the end was so obvious and, of course, miserable at the same time. I genuinely laughed at Supergirl's lesbian haircut, let's hope they won't continue with it. There are two pages here I really liked but for the misery tour we've had to suffer it's just too little, too late. Let's hope DC will give Supergirl to a writer who doesn't have a feminist agenda (like they did these last few years) or to someone who doesn't hate superheroes, there is big potential ahead for the character, at least during Dark Crisis since Clark will be "dead". more
-
2.5
What a disastrous end for a misinterpretation representation of Supergirl in this series.
Edit: Now I realize why DC Comics it's been so bad in sales. Since DC hired this writers with edgys views for all characters. This make long time and casual fans walk away of this comics. And I know there is some characters, specially in DC who are good, classic being edgys. But edgy, killer, antihero doesn't apply for all superheroes.
-
1.0
In the blood-covered Supergirl cover of this story, the question is asked should an arch-villain be killed? DC writer Tom King's message is ultimately yes. But not before being punished, multilated, and spending many years in the Phantom Zone away from life. Troubling story and writing again from Tom King. Do horrible things happen in war? Yes. But the definition of war and "organized crime" by brigands are an important distinction. If Tom King writing was that Batman's values should encourage the mutilation,Phantom Zone imprisonment for a lifetime, and death of the Batman villain, what would be the public takeaway? That it is powerful and meaningful? Like when Supergirl, "Woman of Tomorrow," stood by and watched a mob stone someone to death? This is clearly the minority of opinion of those taking time to post here. But I would ask all of the positive reviewers, if the storyline was Batman, would you feel the same? Or is Supergirl's values simply something she has privileged entitlement to?
I find it deeply troubling by how Tom King's values come from a corrupted intelligence organization that have abandoned any concepts of values of human life and dignity. That he would then be put in such a position in DC Comics. Question. If this were not the USA, but it were Russia, or CCP, or (fill-in-the-blank), if a former member of the Russian FGS/KGB intelligence organization retired (or the equivalent), and then got involved in writing comics on costumed heroes to affect human values, how would the world react? more
-
1.0
The awful story and art continue on.
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
9.5
-
9.5
-
9.5
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
6.5
-
6.5
-
5.0
-
3.0