-
10
Omg, Merlyn “ I hate coloreds, spics, chinks, and cunts” is an absolute dumpster fire! Never disappoints. His particular take, a superlative example of white incel diarrhea. I’m so here for it. Thanks, M. You get a 10 out of 10.
-
10
I was on the fence about getting this. I'm glad I picked it up though! Mantle passing of characters can be a hard sell to some but it makes perfect sense with iron fist. The characters mythology already has it so many have been iron fist and many more will be. It's not at all like Danny rand is the essential iron fist. He may be your favourite and that's fair and okay. There have been great characters to come out Mantle passing. I may be a minority on this but my favourite green lantern is Kyle Rayner. And here, Danny is still around which is great. Should the series kill him off or write him out I may be less enthusiastic but for now it's all good.
Also, people giving low reviews because the new iron fist isn't white ... Just ... Wow. What if it had been a white guy? Would you still hate it? There's a few people on here that are clearly Klan members! They cry anything that closely resembles diversity and then insist others are the racists. Projection all over comments. Just like YouTube! I don't know how they got into comics in the first place.
more
-
10
Jay Garrick is The Flash. Tired of these boring token replacements like Barry Allen.
-
10
I'm so glad that swordmaster is still alive, when he fell off the cliff I thought he would die but I'm glad he didn't. now the story was very interesting, I was curious to know what would happen to the dragon egg after the end of the last series and here it continues very well with that legacy, I hope to see more of swordmaster and see if danny becomes his mentor
-
10
Be honest. Is ANYONE surprised by the usuals giving this a 1 star without even reading it?
Iron Fist has been a mantle since day one. Rand wasn't even the first and he wasn't ever going to be the only one, but he was evidently the first white one. The irony is he WAS the diversity hire. But that's lost on the usuals.
Of course Kun Lun doesn't have politically inclined clowns like our Divided States of America does, so it probably wasn't a problem for them. That'd actually be a nice story beat, Ken Lun comicsgaters. They should do that.
Giving this a 10 cuz im petty like that. Also this new guys costume is awesome.
And Danny is VERY prominent in this book and its clear hes going to be in this series quite a bit, likely to train this guy. The art is decent, not perfect, but I like the concept. Just figured I'd add in some more detail. Its a quick and easy read. Pretty fun stuff.
more
-
9.0
Not the strongest first issue, I like the idea of who the new iron fist is. I'm mostly on board to see how they bridge the gap to the present, that is this book, to when we last saw you know who take a dive. I also didn't love the art.
-
8.5
I like this. I like how Danny Rand was still very relevant. I'm really interested in hearing more of the new iron fist's backstory. This was a very good start and I'm definitely on board. His costume was really cool looking too.
-
8.0
I only like Alan Scott. John Stewart who?
-
8.0
I was never much of an Iron Fist fan, so this is a nice jumping on point. The whole concept of a rich white dude becoming a savior in another culture always seemed iffy to me (Dr. Strange is the biggest culprit), it's just a played out concept and this is a nice change up. Overall, I enjoyed the story. It was a bit exposition heavy, though it sets a solid stage for things to come. Also, that costume is a major upgrade.
-
7.5
SO I DIDN'T KNOW WHO SWORDMASTER WAS CUZ I DIDN'T READ THAT SERIES.
I was very lost feeling I missed an issue or something while reading this and a quick search showed me why. Hindsight is 20/20 so I feel having this character debut more cleanly as The Iron Fist would have been better.
The issue wants to respect this character's past but it doesn't do a great job of introducing him.
I loved the artwork and I loved the banter between Danny and Lin. I'm very curious to know more so I'll stick around for the miniseries hoping it gets better once it finds its footing and maybe get a legit ongoing if it sells well enough later in the year.
There's some great stuff in here!
-
7.5
É ok, a arte ficou devendo.
-
7.5
I wonder if this website will ever stop allowing racism. Probably not. This issue is pretty good, especially if you've been following the character since his debut and have been painfully aware of just how underwhelming he is. With that in mind, this reinvention works very well. It makes the character more interesting. Is it a great book? No. However, I support the inflated review scores because it's the only thing that can push the racist reviews out of the spotlight as nothing will be done about those. Imagine thinking this is all the result of a controversy from what, six years ago? One that was pretty much disregarded by the comics community. Danny Rand has always been a token white savior, it's part of the character at this point. Iron Fist is a mantle, however, there's been many of them. I love how Merlyn acts like Marvel should have developed this character on his own with his own title. Buddy, there was a 10 issue series that no one read called Sword Master. Know how I know? I read it. It is so painfully obvious that the problem has nothing to do with a mantle change. It has to do with the character being non-white. Nothing will be done about these reviews or these attitudes, but at least take solace in this: These racists will die forgotten and left behind by society. Despite how much they hate it and how loudly they whine, the world is at least progressing on that front. It's far from where it needs to be, of course, but we're slowly escaping the hatred of bigots. The people hating on this book for racist reasons all come from hotbeds for bigotry though, so they're even further behind. Merlyn is eastern European. Old Soviet bloc. That basically means he is a Nazi, it's a birthright there. Sup3rsa1yan1990 is Brazilian, I'm guessing. They're having a hard time over there. Briton is... well, British. And really British people aren't actually people, so much as deviants, so. You ever need to figure out what to think about a social issue, just ask a Brit and think the opposite. more
-
7.5
Hm. I'm interested in the character and the setup, and I'm always happy to see comics that make the usual crew of racists cry (not that that's difficult), but... this issue was pretty slight. It felt like a throwback to the the early oughts when people thought the existence of trades meant pacing didn't matter. Hopefully this series finds its feet, but this is an underwhelming start
-
6.5
Average comic for me. I’m not familiar with the new guy. Apparently he was introduced before this? I’ll stick around for the next few issues.
-
6.5
For someone who wasnt familiar with Swordmaster, I'm going to say it wasn't a good enough first issue. I felt like it just gave some generic origin that didn't feel complete. I hope to get more moving forward.
-
6.0
boring
-
5.5
'A mysterious newcomer' who is outed in the first issues first few pages. For some reason I couldn't get hold of this issue without paying over the odds. Maybe thats what has swayed me but I was underwhelmed and expected so much. There was action, but not enough, and the impetus for the characters change probably means its short term. Of course Danny Rand will gain his power back eventually, but its practically telegraphed sooner rather than later. As a reader I'm wondering why I stay with this for the long haul.
-
5.0
I don't give a fig about the politics. I have no problem with Lin Lie becoming the next Iron Fist. It's a good idea.
But this is not a good comic.
The art is borderline incompetent, which is disastrous in a martial arts book. Somehow, Lin Lie has brought the pacing and storytelling problems of his solo series along with him. Explaining his status quo twice in one issue is inexcusable, even if he is talking to 2 different people.
It's all the more disappointing because Alyssa Wong handled the character really well in his last outing, Death of Doctor Strange: White Fox #1.
-
5.0
I didn't like it.
But,It wasn't as bad as I had feared.
The story sets up a bunch of questions that, hopefully get followed up.
What happened to the dragon?
How did Lin get the dragon's chi?
What effects do the shards have on his powers?
There's a decent action sequence at the start. A scene with Danny and Lin that establishes that their relationship is going to be rocky. Then the talking starts. I believe Lin's backstory is rehashed at least twice. The threat to Kun Lun is established. Ends on a cliffhanger. Dialog was fine. But there's a LOT of talking for the sake of exposition.
The art was... okay. After a Jim Cheung cover, pretty much anything else is a let down. The art team was competent, but the style just didn't do it for me.
Here's the thing: I believe this was created in good faith. This was not the character assassination that Heart of the Dragon was. Danny is treated with respect, and portrayed as competent, if cocky. This is important to me. I've followed Danny for over 30 years. There have been many Iron Fists, passing the baton is not an issue. Crapping on character I care about to build up a new one is an issue. That's not what happened here.
Lin has potential. I like the costume. I like the attitude. I hope he's given the chance to earn the title. The current penchant with new characters is to tell us how awesome they are. Show me why I should keep reading. Give him thrilling adventures, terrifying villains, an interesting supporting cast. Don't blow it. more
-
1.0
I am so sick of white heroes being replaced by those of other races. Marvel's position in the culture wars sickens me.
-
1.0
Yeah, this is awful. Not just that the story is bad but the reason Marvel came up with this is awful. It all began when those idiots online started screeching that Finn Jones should be replaced with an Asian actor because in their tiny minds only Asians can learn martial arts. Imagine being this deluded. So Marvel broke the no.1 rule on the internet: don't cave in to online morons. And ever since they've tried to steer away from Iron Fist because he is pRoBlEmAtIc.
Here's the thing: Danny Rand IS Iron Fist. Just as Tony Stark is Iron Man, just as Bruce Wayne is Batman, Clark Kent is Superman and so on. There isn't anything racist about this, not even a tiny bit. If anything Marvel is the one being racist by believing that only an Asian character can learn martial arts and only an Asian writer should write a book like this. Identity politics kills the joy out of our comics.
Lin Lie is Sword Master, develop his own identity instead of pushing him into a role that isn't his. The concept for the character is interesting, unfortunately writers haven't been able to develop his story, mostly because they were focused on other issues other than those that would have helped the character evolve.
P.S.: Notice how some people who don't review ANY OTHER BOOKS specifically come here to inflate the rating of this issue. I can be damn sure those people didn't even read the book. I won't name names. Just check their profiles and how many other books they're rating. You'll notice some just don't review other books at all so they're just inflating the score here artificially. That doesn't seem right.
P.P.S.: There is a review here that literally states that all Eastern European people are Nazis "by birthright" and that British people are "deviants". These are the same people that always, always scream "racist" whenever someone dislikes a book they like. Normally, this would be laughed at and not encouraged, but we're not living normal times, are we? more
-
1.0
The immortal diversity (h)iron fist
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
8.5
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.0
-
6.0
-
6.0
-
5.0
-
3.5