Maybe people just think it sucks?

Admins flat out called someone out for review bombing

Ahhh. Yeah that’s bullshit then.

Say the guy who bomb every Lobdell's book.

i'm more than positive this also goes the other way though. this site is kind of BS in many ways on both the critic reviews as well as user score. many comic readers are some of the most deluded individuals out there. look at what positive review is ranked the highest. not an actual review about the comic, a commentary about about some troll review bombing. doesn't say much for the comic in question does it?

no thay are not

thank you for that glimpse into your crystal ball Nostradamus.

Have you read Heroes in Crisis, nobody’s review bombing Tom king his work is legitimately infuriating, after seeming what he’s doing to Wally West, I regret ever giving him the benefit of the doubt I don’t think Tom ever actually gAVE a damn about the DC universe so congratulations, Taylor, you’re the better comic book Tom

don't feel bad The-MJP. you were holding onto optimism. that's not a bad thing. but at least you finally see what Tom King is and the harm he's doing to these characters. i smelled hints of what he was doing from the beginning.

Mycoinus ok calling Tom king a psycho was out of line and Tim Taylor isn't the acceptable target I was making him out to be I only damned him with faint praise because I was upset about him not knowing how nightcrawlers powers work and me disagreeing with some points that book made As bad as king was in this run my comments should not have been as angry as they were

seeing how Tom king completely mistreated Batman and all supporting characters, calling him a psycho could possibly be a fair assessment of him. this run will go down in history as an overambitious failure at the hands of a deranged clown. ....perhaps Tom King thought that he was being "META" and was pretending to be The Joker destroying Batman?

Mycoinus well I've come to realize that calling someone a psycho cause they make bad stories Plenty of writers put their characters through hell to make them come out stronger just because tom king does it poorly doesn't put him on the same level as the joker. Dennis hopeless (who's work IMHO is hit or miss) wrote avengers arena, does that make him a child-killer? Hell no, he just wrote a bad story. Though I know you probably think different that why I feel calling him psychotic is out line

if all King was doing was writing bad stories, that'd be one thing. as for him being a psycho, i do not believe so. he's someone that likes to exploit topics like mental illness and suicide for the purpose of capitalism. to me, that's much worse. that there is just evil.

Riri is a dick and I make no apologies for saying if you like that you are nothing more than a fascist SJW fucktard and you need to accept it

"fascist SJW fucktard?" Standing by this comment, MJP?

No but I still don’t like Riri

Why won't this site let you delete comics

COMMENTS

I am going to get so much hate for liking this comment. I'll say that it is okay for them to dislike and keep reading the book though, I do that with so many books.

I don't like this book

Does marvel seriously need to give an ongoing to every character in their encyclopedia Give me my tigra solo already leave it at that we didn't need a hulking ongoing spanning four trades

Addmitidley given the lack of LGBT representation in the everything industry hulking was a bad example but you get my point

Yeah, some decisions of Neil were weird, but it's still a great complicated and enjoyable story.

Fans are often wrong. Have you ever read fanfics? Most of it is awful& unbearable to read. And what have feminazis to do with this? The term is actually an insult to feminism& to the holocaust, ( and to intelligence)

By feminazi I am referring to over the top extremist “Feminists” who don’t actually know what their talking about, like Anita sorkesian

I was being a little facetious when I was saying that gas are never wrong, I was basically trying to say you should respect them and not treat them as if the characters they like don’t matter

I see. That makes sense then. But she has many good points& I think the guys who send her sexist comments and death threats are in the wrong here. When we talk her.

Anita Sarkeesian has made a joke of the actual struggles that women deal with by going after pointless things in video games, which she sometimes fabricated. And saying that absolutely everything is sexist, racist, homophobif

*homophobic just devalues those terms and makes people ignore it more.

I don’t think so. Sure worse is going on in the world than women being oversexualized in video games, but that doesn’t mean you have to accept the minor issues or can’t point them out. When it comes to the gaming community women face a lot of sexism& prejudices. Not to mention hate. Some gamers are plain right stupid.

Not to mention. She’s looking for stereotypical portrayals in video games. Same is done in literature with for example: femme fatale & femme fragile. I’d rather question, that video games aren’t of the same quality like literature. They are for relaxing, while literature has more depths. Maybe it’s from the gender studies/ sociological point of view.

She literally made a video about how it was sexist that Batman had a cape and Catwoman didn't in Arkham City. Because it covered his butt. That's stupid.

Ok, that’s stupid indeed 😂 ( and in AK the camera is right on his butt)

Ok this review did not age well. I apologize for my vitriol aimed at Tom king, he's a hero and calling him a psychopath is way out of line I mentioned X-Men red quite derisivley but that's only because it was a punching bag in corners I frankly avoid like the plauge now that comicsgate is deader than uncle ben, look I only brought it up in relation to Taylor due to the fact that most agree it's his weakest work that isn't Earth 2, reading it now it's ok, I personally don't agree with the whole

"We should limit free speech" undertones the series had that I don't agree with but I tend to ignore those things anyway Tom king is not a psychopath and X-Men red is not the acceptable targets I was making it out to be and I'm sorry for that Still not a good comic

you have absolutely nothing to apologize for MJP. .....whether he's a hero or not remains to be seen. but one thing holds true, Tom King's comics are more unpleasant than the stinkiest of stinky dog turds.

Everybody know that was Blindfold. And her story well documented why she did it. Man up.

Ambaryerno's talking about two deaths - not just Blindfold, but Loa, whose death is indeed gratuitous and too easily overlooked.

Thank God for hickman

Really cuz I thing hopeless has an eye for Jean and his X23 is the problem

I know this is mostly personal taste but dodson, a bad artist? Really? Dodson? The only art of his I didn't like was the generation x covers and that's into because the colors on those blended into each other and it stangley gave the impression it was a "woke" book Other than that I have read it so....no comment

Rather than dismiss Xavier as an idiot, consider that this undiplomatic visit drove Franklin straight into the mutants' arms. Bringing a combative roster -- particularly letting Magneto push Sue's buttons -- worked out great for him.

Diversity and comics sent me here to tell you you’re full of shit Wake up no one likes this book

Thats the dumbest thing ive ever heard.

I will now send death threats and insult trans people to compensate for the fact I have a tiny penis

DdJamesB

Youre so odd. Its a comic book. Enjoy it or dont read it. Hope you find something you like.

I was being sarcastic and honestly I like Jane fostor and I thing giving her cancer did wonders for her character development and I hate how people shit on her because Jason Aaron went on a weird tangent in one issue DDjamesB

I’m worried that gabby might end up like sally west ten years down the line with editorial thinking they’re doing the fans a favor by killing her off repeatedly simply because some very vocal fans don’t like her

was she unlikble before this? i'm confused, also, many would argue that this series made jean unlikeable, granted most of those people are jaded comic book store owners who parrot YellowFlash and Diversity and Comics but im sure they know what theyre talking about.

for the record I dropped this series after a few issues cause I didn't want to poke the bear by reading and giving my thoughts on such a divisive book that i havent heard the best things about. plus, I rarley read comics issue by issue anyway

I thought Jean Grey was unlikeable before this. It's subjective, of course. And you shouldn't worry about "poking the bear," that's ridiculous.

You say that it’s ridiculous but beck In 2016 I saw the ghostbusters reboot and when I told people I liked it I got flags and death threats for months The weird thing is, I don’t even agree with feminism

So? Death threats on the internet are a joke.

Hey I’ve met some pretty awful people on the internet Plus I avoid anything remotely political on the internet cause no matter what I say, I’m wrong

Okay, well you can discuss this comics without falling into a political debate

You’re right I’m overreacting But there’s still other comics I’ll read first and I can’t read comics week-to-week

Okay?

Thank you so much for your review of this issue that came out 14 years ago. We’ve all been waiting to pull the trigger to buy it. Now that MJP says it’s OK, let’s buy this!

Because it came out 14 years ago I can’t put in my two cents and share my opinion

Thanks for your review MJP, this obscure book had no reviews anywhere. Can you review Watchmen next? I heard it might be good. Don't want to commit just yet.

So I can’t share my opinion on the books that I read, I thought that’s what this website was for And since when is fan-favorite X-men run obscure

Can I get your feedback on Citizen Kane? Need your opinion before viewing.

what the hell is your problem with me posting a score an a comic that didnt get rthat many scores when it was originally came out, people give thoughts and recomendations on media that came out a long time ago all the damn time, why are my opinions suddenly worthless just because the comic is more than a year old

I like whedon's x-men and legitamtley didn't like Kim and Kim and wanted to give my thoughts on themdeal with it

and for the record, because of rising comic book prices and my ow financial situations, I rarely read comics issue by issue and usually just borrow trade paperbacks from lending libraries, which is why i score older comics more than newer comics

half of youtube and facebook would disagree with you

i stoped caring about what you have to say when you said "Jean Grey isn't as hot as she should be"

boo, youre review needs more 'evil sjw' rants (sarcasm)

a comic book by the big two showcasing new talent I can already tell the user reviews are not going to be pleasant

I wasn't aware books could be bad because of "reading" i thought we judged comics or "writing' and "art"

You're an asshole.

I simply dislike Mag Vsaggio and her politics and as far as I know she is not very well liked in the comic book cumminity

I wAs asking

I’m not a fan of mags, I feel that she just writes characters thinking that “Gay” and “trans” are personality traits

That being said, it’s wrong of me to claim that she shouldn’t get work because I don’t like her output, she already gets enough flak from comic fans as it is

You cannot be serious

Sadly, The-MJP is quite serious

How you know Synthezoid?

Oh shit, yes, he’s a straight up asshole.

For the record I had completely forgotten I had written this and I realize my comment is immature That being said I’m still not a fan of mags, and im not going to praise her just because she’s lgbtq+

MJP - Did you read Oh S#!t It's Kim & Kim #2? Not asking for you to praise something you disliked.

For me it’s one of those things you remember reading, but the only thing you remember about it is hating it

What kind of problems?

Angus, Gail Simone is a very talented writer. Her best being Birds of Prey, Wonder Woman, Red Sonja and Secret Six.

She can write well, but like a child she targets people with her jokes, only one group of people. She would never write a joke targeting a progressive. Liberals and conservatives are evil, we get it. She can only write her beliefs as positive. Limited but if you agree with her narrow view of righteousness then it must be great to see the same belief system pop up in much of entertainment.

My family and I escaped to the other side of the planet unwillingly to avoid this type of thinking so it is jarring to simpletons like a dumb middle easterner like me.

I understand you disagree with her politics but what does this miniseries have to do with it?

I said it in my comment, her comedy targets people. I read comics with my cousins (large family and I am the oldest in my 30s). We get on skype or hangouts and read them as few times a week since we have to live at different ends of the country. Writers like Johns, Tomasi, and so on seem to try to entertain without targetting anyone with their humor. Gail Simone targets ALL who oppose her and I guess she does not realize that she paints herself into the corner, not us.

When 6 out of the 9 of my family/friends comics group wont read her, it is on her. She does not understand nuance. It is straight to 3rd wave feminism. Misogyny jokes and so on. The teens refuse to hear that and endless make fun of it. The 20 somethings just laugh and let it go and me being in my thirties just wants to avoid it so I don't get fired at work.

But I keep giving her chances to just write a decent a comic without that stuff. And we can't go there. Her Tweet Bird/Sylvester/Catwoman comic, another waste of 5 bucks had to jam the jokes in there so another issue I am stuck with no one in my group wants to discuss. Perhaps we are just on the wrong side of history like tells us.

Anyway, I hope you do enjoy her comics. I am probably not going to give her any other chances since the big part of the fun is my family getting together and discussing them and she just cause fights between the 6 people who totally disagree with her, the 1 person who thinks like her and wont let it go and the 2 of us that don't care about her agenda since it has been disproven on various points for years.

"Her comedy targets people". That's rather vague. Can you give any specific example, based on this issue of Plastic Man?

Feminists are not real conics fans

U r right MJP, we don’t like conics

Comic princess, Tbh I was just parroting yellow flash and didn’t have any clue what I was saying When I take a step back I realized he’s not somebody I should parrot, especially when I realized I actually liked the comics he was bashing

Kingdom Come is considered his best.

I said waifs RECENT work

Waid’s

I do not understand the praise for this series To me this comic is nothing more than a ripoff of the Punisher, Black Wodow and Fantomex that retains just enough of each character to keep marvel lawyers at bay Also she’s Polynesian because...because even though the writer can’t seem to tell the difference between an African American and a Pacific Islander

Can't speak for anyone else but I personally like the series, and its mythos, and don't really see too much of resemblance between Silencer and other Marvel characters. Surely nothing as obvious as Gwenpool, Sideways, Deadpool or Old Lady Harley. Besides, Silencer has her own niche in DC - there's no other comic quite like hers. Even Deathstroke, since his comics have a very unique, one of a kind narrative and style.

People second the same thing about Youngblood lol