J.M. DeMatteis Comic Reviews

Current Series: 1 Total Series: 49 Issues: 276 Critic Reviews: 599 User Reviews: 211
7.7Avg. Issue Rating
7.5Avg. User Rating
+ Creator Watch List

Current Comic Book Series

7.6
Star Trek: Hell's Mirror (2020) #1  

All Comic Book Series

10
Abadazad #1

10
Abadazad #2

10
Abadazad #3

N/A
Adventures of Superman (1987) #578

Mar 8, 2000

N/A
Adventures of Superman (1987) #579

Apr 12, 2000

N/A
Adventures of Superman (1987) #582

Jul 12, 2000

N/A
Adventures of Superman (1987) #583

Sep 27, 2000

N/A
Adventures of Superman (1987) #584

Sep 13, 2000

N/A
Adventures of Superman (1987) #585

Oct 11, 2000

N/A
Adventures of Superman (1987) #586

Nov 15, 2000

N/A
Adventures of Superman (1987) #587

Dec 13, 2000

9.2
Adventures Of Superman (2013) #2

May 6, 2013

6.1
Adventures Of Superman (2013) #4

May 20, 2013

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #223

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #293

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #294

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #368

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #370

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #389

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #390

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #391

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #392

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #393

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #394

Oct 5, 1994

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #395

Nov 9, 1994

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #396

Dec 7, 1994

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #397

Jan 4, 1995

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #398

Feb 8, 1995

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #399

Mar 8, 1995

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #400

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #401

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #402

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #403

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #404

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #405

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #406

N/A
Amazing Spider-Man (1963) Annual #24  
7.6
Amazing Spider-Man (1999) #634

Jun 16, 2010

8.9
Amazing Spider-Man (1999) #635

Jun 23, 2010

7.5
Amazing Spider-Man (1999) #700

Dec 26, 2012

N/A
Avengers (1963) #209

N/A
Avengers (1963) #218

N/A
Avengers (1963) Annual #11  
5.0
Booster Gold (2007) #35

Aug 11, 2010

N/A
Booster Gold (2007) #38

Nov 10, 2010

8.0
Booster Gold (2007) #41

Feb 16, 2011

N/A
Booster Gold (2007) #42

Mar 9, 2011

N/A
Captain America (1968) #261

N/A
Captain America (1968) #262

N/A
Captain America (1968) #263

N/A
Captain America (1968) #264

N/A
Captain America (1968) #267

N/A
Captain America (1968) #268

N/A
Captain America (1968) #269

N/A
Captain America (1968) #270

N/A
Captain America (1968) #272

N/A
Captain America (1968) #275

N/A
Captain America (1968) #276

N/A
Captain America (1968) #277

N/A
Captain America (1968) #278

N/A
Captain America (1968) #279

N/A
Captain America (1968) #280

N/A
Captain America (1968) #281

N/A
Captain America (1968) #282

N/A
Captain America (1968) #283

N/A
Captain America (1968) #284

N/A
Captain America (1968) #285

N/A
Captain America (1968) #286

N/A
Captain America (1968) #287

N/A
Captain America (1968) #288

N/A
Captain America (1968) #289

N/A
Captain America (1968) #290

N/A
Captain America (1968) #292

N/A
Captain America (1968) #293

N/A
Captain America (1968) #294

N/A
Captain America (1968) #295

N/A
Captain America (1968) #296

N/A
Captain America (1968) #297

N/A
Captain America (1968) #298

N/A
Captain America (1968) #299

N/A
Captain America (1968) #300

N/A
Daredevil (1964) #344

N/A
Daredevil (1964) #345

N/A
Daredevil (1964) #346

N/A
Daredevil (1964) #347

N/A
Daredevil (1964) #348

N/A
Daredevil (1964) #349

N/A
Daredevil (1964) #350

7.9
DC/Hanna-Barbera: Green Lantern/Huckleberry Hound #1  
N/A
Defenders (1972) #92

N/A
Defenders (1972) #93

N/A
Defenders (1972) #94

N/A
Defenders (1972) #95

N/A
Defenders (1972) #96

N/A
Defenders (1972) #97

N/A
Defenders (1972) #98

N/A
Defenders (1972) #99

N/A
Defenders (1972) #100

N/A
Defenders (1972) #101

N/A
Defenders (1972) #102

N/A
Defenders (1972) #103

N/A
Defenders (1972) #104

N/A
Defenders (1972) #105

N/A
Defenders (1972) #106

N/A
Defenders (1972) #107

N/A
Defenders (1972) #108

N/A
Defenders (1972) #109

N/A
Defenders (1972) #110

N/A
Defenders (1972) #111

N/A
Defenders (1972) #112

N/A
Defenders (1972) #113

N/A
Defenders (1972) #114

N/A
Defenders (1972) #115

N/A
Defenders (1972) #116

N/A
Defenders (1972) #117

N/A
Defenders (1972) #118

N/A
Defenders (1972) #119

N/A
Defenders (1972) #120

N/A
Defenders (1972) #121

N/A
Defenders (1972) #122

N/A
Defenders (1972) #123

N/A
Defenders (1972) #124

N/A
Defenders (1972) #125

N/A
Defenders (1972) #126

N/A
Defenders (1972) #127

N/A
Defenders (1972) #128

N/A
Defenders (1972) #129

N/A
Defenders (1972) #130

N/A
Defenders (1972) #131

7.1
Defenders (2005) #1

7.5
Defenders (2005) #2

7.0
Defenders (2005) #3

10
Defenders (2005) #4

8.0
Defenders (2005) #5

N/A
Detective Comics #489

Apr 2, 1980

N/A
Detective Comics #493

Aug 6, 1980

N/A
Detective Comics #494

Sep 3, 1980

N/A
Detective Comics #495

Oct 1, 1980

N/A
Doctor Strange (1974) #54  
N/A
Doctor Strange: Sorcerer Supreme (1988) #84

N/A
Doctor Strange: Sorcerer Supreme (1988) #85

N/A
Doctor Strange: Sorcerer Supreme (1988) #86

N/A
Doctor Strange: Sorcerer Supreme (1988) #87

N/A
Doctor Strange: Sorcerer Supreme (1988) #88

N/A
Doctor Strange: Sorcerer Supreme (1988) #89

N/A
Doctor Strange: Sorcerer Supreme (1988) #90

5.9
Doom Patrol (2009) #1  
9.3
Formerly Known As The Justice League #1

9.3
Formerly Known As The Justice League #2

9.3
Formerly Known As The Justice League #3

8.7
Formerly Known As The Justice League #4

9.0
Formerly Known As The Justice League #5

10
Formerly Known As The Justice League #6

6.0
Hero Squared #1

5.0
Hero Squared #2

7.0
Hero Squared #3

8.0
Hero Squared #4

7.0
Hero Squared #5

8.0
Hero Squared #6

6.0
Hero Squared X-Tra Sized Special #1  
6.0
Hero Squared: Love and Death #2  
N/A
JLA #35  
8.8
JLA Classified #4

Feb 16, 2005

9.0
JLA Classified #5

Mar 23, 2005

8.0
JLA Classified #6

Apr 20, 2005

8.0
JLA Classified #7

May 18, 2005

9.0
JLA Classified #8

Jun 15, 2005

9.2
JLA Classified #9

Jun 29, 2005

6.0
JLA/Spectre: Soul War #1

4.0
JLA/Spectre: Soul War #2

7.4
Justice League 3000 #1

Dec 11, 2013

7.6
Justice League 3000 #4

Mar 12, 2014

6.9
Justice League 3000 #6

May 7, 2014

8.1
Justice League 3000 #7

Jun 4, 2014

7.3
Justice League 3000 #8

Jul 2, 2014

7.5
Justice League 3000 #9

Aug 6, 2014

7.8
Justice League 3000 #10

Oct 1, 2014

9.0
Justice League 3000 #11

Nov 5, 2014

9.2
Justice League 3000 #13

Jan 7, 2015

8.1
Justice League 3000 #14

Feb 11, 2015

7.5
Justice League 3000 #15

Mar 4, 2015

8.1
Justice League 3001 #1

Jun 24, 2015

7.2
Justice League 3001 #2

Jul 22, 2015

8.1
Justice League 3001 #3

Aug 26, 2015

7.8
Justice League 3001 #4

Sep 23, 2015

7.6
Justice League 3001 #5

Oct 28, 2015

8.2
Justice League 3001 #6

Nov 25, 2015

8.4
Justice League 3001 #7

Dec 23, 2015

8.5
Justice League 3001 #8

Jan 27, 2016

7.3
Justice League 3001 #9

Feb 24, 2016

7.3
Justice League 3001 #10

Mar 23, 2016

8.4
Justice League Dark #25

Nov 27, 2013

6.8
Justice League Dark #29

Mar 26, 2014

8.6
Justice League Dark #30

Apr 23, 2014

7.9
Justice League Dark #31

May 28, 2014

8.7
Justice League Dark #32

Jun 25, 2014

9.2
Justice League Dark #33

Jul 23, 2014

7.3
Justice League Dark #34

Aug 27, 2014

8.7
Justice League Dark #35

Oct 22, 2014

7.3
Justice League Dark #36

Nov 26, 2014

7.2
Justice League Dark #37

Dec 24, 2014

6.4
Justice League Dark #38

Jan 28, 2015

6.7
Justice League Dark #39

Feb 25, 2015

6.2
Justice League Dark #40

Mar 25, 2015

5.9
Justice League Dark Annual #2  
6.8
Larfleeze #2

Jul 24, 2013

7.7
Larfleeze #3

Aug 28, 2013

8.4
Larfleeze #4

Oct 23, 2013

7.4
Larfleeze #5

Nov 27, 2013

7.9
Larfleeze #9

Mar 26, 2014

8.5
Larfleeze #10

Apr 23, 2014

8.0
Larfleeze #11

May 28, 2014

7.9
Larfleeze #12

Jun 25, 2014

N/A
Marvel Team-Up (1972) #101

N/A
Marvel Team-Up (1972) #115

N/A
Marvel Team-Up (1972) #116

N/A
Marvel Team-Up (1972) #121

N/A
Marvel Team-Up (1972) #132

N/A
Marvel Team-Up (1972) #133

7.8
Phantom Stranger (2012) #7

Apr 3, 2013

7.3
Phantom Stranger (2012) #8

May 1, 2013

8.2
Phantom Stranger (2012) #9

Jun 5, 2013

7.6
Phantom Stranger (2012) #10

Jul 3, 2013

7.9
Phantom Stranger (2012) #11

Aug 7, 2013

8.1
Phantom Stranger (2012) #12

Oct 9, 2013

4.0
Planetary Brigade #2  
7.0
Planetary Brigade: Origins #1  
6.8
Scooby Apocalypse #1

May 25, 2016

7.1
Scooby Apocalypse #2

Jun 15, 2016

7.0
Scooby Apocalypse #3

Jul 20, 2016

8.0
Secret Origins #6  
N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #123

N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #125

N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #126

N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #127

N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #128

N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #129

N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #130

N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #131

N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #132

N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #133

N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #134

N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #135

N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #136

N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #137

N/A
Silver Surfer (1987) #138

7.6
Star Trek: Hell's Mirror (2020) #1  
10
Stardust Kid #4  
N/A
Superman: The Man of Tomorrow (1995) #15  
6.0
The Authority: The Lost Year #8  
8.0
The Last One #1  
8.4
The Life and Times of Savior 28 #1

Aug 26, 2009

9.0
The Life and Times of Savior 28 #2

Sep 2, 2009

8.0
The Life and Times of Savior 28 #3

Sep 10, 2009

9.0
The Life and Times of Savior 28 #4

Sep 16, 2009

6.7
The Mighty Thor Annual #1  
6.7
Trinity Of Sin #1

Oct 15, 2014

7.0
Trinity Of Sin #2

Nov 19, 2014

6.6
Trinity Of Sin #3

Dec 17, 2014

4.5
Trinity Of Sin #4

Jan 21, 2015

6.8
Trinity Of Sin #5

Feb 18, 2015

6.9
Trinity Of Sin #6

Mar 18, 2015

6.8
Web of Spider-Man Vol. 2 #1

Oct 14, 2009

6.0
Web of Spider-Man Vol. 2 #3

Dec 9, 2009

8.4
Web of Spider-Man Vol. 2 #8

May 12, 2010

N/A
Wonder Woman (1987) #164

Nov 1, 2000

N/A
Wonder Woman (1987) #165

Dec 1, 2000

N/A
X-Factor (1986) #93

N/A
X-Factor (1986) #94

N/A
X-Factor (1986) #95

N/A
X-Factor (1986) #96

N/A
X-Factor (1986) #97

N/A
X-Factor (1986) #98

N/A
X-Factor (1986) #99

N/A
X-Factor (1986) #100

N/A
X-Men (1991) Annual #4  

Reviews for the Week of...

October

September

More