Batman vs. Robin might not be the big conflict DC readers wanted to see play out in 2022, but under Waid and Asrar's hands, this is a brisk read that offers plenty of intriguing directions for the future of the Batman titles and beyond. Read Full Review

The end of the issue brings in some major elements from Vertigo lore, making this rather perfectly timed for release. But amid the fast-paced story, this has some of the best Batman characterization I've seen in a long time, and an absolutely perfect Alfred. Waid is a master of the DCU, same as he ever was, and I'm expecting this to be an event mini to remember. Read Full Review

This is the DC event book to watch through the end of the year. It's eerie, action packed, and hits all the emotional beats. In other words, a must-read. Read Full Review

Plus, this new villain is straight-up scary. Its like a low-key Trigon meets the Superman villain Doomsday. Readers, the story is creative, filled with action, and leaves so many dangling plot threads and intriguing questions that will keep fans excited for whats to come. Furthermore, it appears to be a different type of Batman story that now looks a bit different than what was anticipated. I highly recommend giving Batman vs. Robin #1 a shot. Its got action, suspense, and mystery with Batman at the epicenter. What more could you ask for? Let me know what you think, have a great week, and God Bless! Read Full Review

BATMAN VS. ROBIN #1 is captivating from start to finish and will have readers eager for more. Is this the return of an old friend or is Batman in this fight against his son alone? Read Full Review

Asrar delivers some exciting visuals throughout the issue. The art is beautifully detailed, thrilling and filled with great visual touches that engage the reader. Read Full Review

Batman VS. Robin #1finds the Dark Knight fighting to save his son, as Mark Waid and Mahmud Asrar deliver a story laced with action and emotion. If you've been enjoying Waid's work onBatman/Superman: World's Finest, this comic is definitely for you, especially as it picks up from a plot point in that book. Despite its title, this series is less about the battle between the two title combatants and more of a story about family. Read Full Review

There's so much to enjoy in Batman Vs Robin #1, both in terms of style and content; from single moments (don't get me started on the reunion “acceptance” page!) to intriguing questions, and a high-stakes set-up that has already made this series feel like an event title. Read Full Review

This could have been a gimmick book, but it is in fact the best Batman book of the month. Engaging, beautiful visuals, and a genuine mystery to be solved. Read Full Review

Batman vs. Robin #1 will leave you wanting more, in the best possible way. Read Full Review

If you're looking for good action and triple-A artwork, look no further than Batman vs. Robin. The creators are throwing readers into the deep end with mega twists, surprising character choices, and the return of a Batman icon. If you can get past the lack of motivation for Robin, you're going to have a great time unpacking the mystery wrapped in the action frenzy. Read Full Review

Batman vs. Robin #1 is a quick, energetic read that earns the resurrection of a fan favorite character. While seeing heroes fight each other isn't always the most engaging storyline, the fast pace and high stakes set in this first issue overcome the inherent pitfalls of a "versus book. Mahmud Asrar's pencils maintain a sense of clarity despite the over abundance of magical attacks on display and Mark Waid's script delivers a healthy dose of humor to keep the entire endeavor from being a one note experience. Read Full Review

Despite some issues with understanding the underlying plot elements, this introduction is an interesting enough start to the battle between father and son. Read Full Review

Batman vs Robin #1 is an interesting start that promises a globe-trotting adventure with Batman and Alfred on the run from Robin, Mother Soul, and Devil Nezha. Read Full Review

Overall, Batman vs Robin is a fun read and sets the foundation for the series. If not for the few surprises, the story is pedestrian and almost a paint-by-number Batman event. We have the betrayal from someone he trusts, the people that could quickly fix it are incapacitated, and the main orchestrator is a potential reveal. The story is still a fun read but has the potential to be better, especially with Waid working with characters directly from the archive. Read Full Review

Timing is everything and Batman vs Robin #1 is an example of why that is. Mark Waid's decision to center the story around a one-note villain rather than diving into exploring the father-son relationship between Bruce Wayne and Damian Wayne was a big mistake. It is a decision that ends up reminding you that these characters futures in Dark Crisis On Infinite Earths instead of getting you invested in finding out how things will turn out by the end of Batman vs Robin. Read Full Review

Very much a mixed bag, Batman vs. Robin #1 takes characters backwards in their developments instead of forwards. I'm also not too pleased with the gruesome depicted of the lynched Zatanna who Batman and Alfred come to find while searching for answers as to just what is going on. Alfred may be back, and Batman is certainly pleased with that, but what kind of death will a magically-fueled Robin bring to bear in what's to come? Read Full Review

I was worried that this would be like the cartoon. Thankfully, it wasn't. Robin is being controlled in some way. I like that Damien is not in charge of his facilities. It wouldn't make much sense otherwise. I do love that Alfred is back, though we don't know how yet, but I really don't care. I just like that he's back. It was pretty touching and probably my favorite part of the book. Obviously, Waid is connecting this to World's Finest in some way.

Liked it. Pretty interesting story, just waiting for it to be revealed Alfred is not alive or something. Wish art was better.

It’s pretty good. Visuals are crisp and the style is interesting. I don’t know about Damian’s dialogue, but I am giving this the benefit of the doubt, considering he’s pretty transparently being controlled.

Batman is written excellently here. Alfred’s portrayal is perfectly executed.

Nezha is girthy and I love it. The dude’s thicker than a truck!

I can’t wait to see where this goes.

I didn't read Shadow War but am a little disappointed in the direction Damian has taken again. And again and again. But I have faith that Waid actually has a plan here. I don't really need to see more Talia or "evil" Damian just to get Alfred back. It was a mistake to kill him in the first place and now we have an awkward conflict that we've seen before at least in the hands of a skilled writer. The continuation from World's Finest issue 6 makes this feel stronger. I like that it actually has some ground laid for it before hand. We'll see where this goes. I'm looking forward to it.
"OG" Batman/DC readers need to get back in their hole and read their funnies. Time has marched forward without you. "Waaah I'm OLD! I know more than you do about how Dr. Fate USED to be. He's WAY cooler than you whippersnappers." Don't forget to quote devils and demons or your "God" will be pissed. more

Some really exciting mysteries at play here. Everything relating to Alfred was perfect. Waid has the ability to weave continuity and warm characterization together in such a harmonious manner and these pages are a great example.

While I'm a little over the constant reversion of Damian back into more of a villain, I trust that Waid knows what he's doing and will deliver on the why in the rest of the story, especially with Nezha and his corrupting influence involved.

This is really well written, and it's just a shame that Damian is regressing all over again. I just can't get past it.

You want to buy this for Alfred. Period. No other reason. I hate evil magic, and I hate evil Robins. Pretty much avoid the Al-Ghul family stories (ugh). But Alfred Pennyworth returns, and it is worth reading simply for THAT. And no, they don't re-kill Alfred in the first issue (which is why I held off thinking about buying it). This "Devil" Nezha and Mother Soul (Al-Ghul, ugh) stuff is a mess, but unfortunately that is the cost to read Batman and Alfred together.

Some readers will get this to see the corrupted (?) Damian Al-Ghul/Wayne and some other younger characters (Jakeem Thunder, Tim Hunter) use magic to attack Batman. What a shock. As OG Batman readers will tell you, DC Editorial would have killed off Batman Bruce Wayne decades ago, except that they need Batman to keep from going bankrupt. Sorry, kids. He is still The Batman.

About Doctor Fate: A reminder to Waid and the rest. The continuing underestimation of Doctor Fate is literally absurd. Doctor Fate has kicked the butt of "devils," "demons," extra-dimensional threats, and aliens too, way, way, way before you guys were BORN, as of course was The Batman. But writers seem to think Fate is some pushover, and that any magic creepo can enter the Tower of Fate at will.

What is really missing in a story like this is Jim Corrigan, The Spectre, as he is missing from most "modern" JSA stories, and don't get me started about the movie glamorizing the genocidal mass-murderer Man in Black. But another reminder, The Spectre has worked with The Batman before, and would also kick these devils and demons back into the netherworlds where they belong. But of course, in the Anti-Hero Age, it is important to have Evil win as long as possible. Eh.
more

Nop