Eh... started out with a great premise but this Hansel and Gretel thing in the middle for just one issue feels out of place.

it jumped to the action right away without proper story-building. i was a bit lost throughout

The art is beautiful and it fits the story, but I felt the story was a bit light. I wasn't very engaged with it or with the characters.

Good issue, but I miss the jokes of the first one.

The series started so great and then just fizzled

The art is great and the pacing is good, the writer is a good storyteller, I just felt like there wasn’t much new to this story. Feels like a story that’s been done many times before. But if you love this type of story you’ll like it

Holy ^{%}{*{ this is so good! Cates is such a fun, intense storyteller. So many different things can happen. I’m so so excited for this storyline

Eh, don’t feel like it adds too much to the story

One of the slowest issues in a while. I feel like it's setting up things, but there were none of the usual shocking moments. Still a huge fan of the series though.

This was an OK setup issue but I want more of Gideon falls!

The art was amazing but story wise felt like a filler

sorrentino is fantastic and i liked the story, but i think this was the weakest one of all 3. i expected a better ending to the series.

Good issue with good setups. Soule knows the characters well and stays true to them. The ending was the best part

I liked the ending but it was a slow issue overall

It’s good but it’s more of a filler. Sets up king in black but you won’t kiss much if you don’t read this

Best one so far if the series

I like were this is going and I have loved every issue's ending. However, I think it's a bit light and a quick read, I just want more. Great art and great characters!

gorgeous, gorgeous art, and the story is good, but just wish it'd go a bit faster!

It’s good but seriously... I want more to happen!!!

One of the best Star Wars series. Seeing the origins of the Knights of Ren and Ben Solo was fascinating. And the Luke fighting scene is worth the price of the book.

This issue was bland. It was just OK, I thought had more potential. The weakest one of the series

really good ending to one of the best star wars mini series

I liked this one a lot more than the 1st issue, and i'm glad I stuck with it. The art is beautiful and very appropriate for this theme. Really interesting story being told.

good story if you like WWII era stories.

Much more action and less story than other issues, which is not my favorite, but still good. The art as always is fantastic

Amazing art, story is good, I loved this story arch

really good story and art. even though it does follow the superhero blueprint i like that it's adapted to modern times and it keeps it real

Very interesting first issue. I liked the twist to the storyline, it definitely makes the whole situation very unique. The pacing of the story was good. Just feel like it missed a little something, maybe more dialogue, to take it from very good to great.

i like how the story is building and where it'll probably takes us. I think at the end it will all make sense. the writers are very good story tellers and the art is amazing

I like this series a lot. Classic Lemire, diving deep into the characters

it's ok but i feel that the story has more potential, especially knowing it's lemire

Nice set up issue

Really good story that’s setting up what looks to be a fun ride. Surpassed my expectations!

Really good story and this issue adds to it. I definitely feel like I'm immersed in this world. The art does a good job in expressing the characters' emotions. The cliffhanger at the end makes me excited for issue 3!

Very good series and very good storytelling. I could see how this was intended to be a novel. Looking forward to the ending

Story is picking up!!!

Tom Taylor always gets better as a series goes deeper

Good issue, love the art, but I'd like to see the pace pick up

This was my favorite issue of the series. I loved the explanation and the plot twists. Just kind of wish this would've happened an issue ago. Loved the ending and of course the art is fantastic and really does make it feel like a 70's movie

really good pace for the story and there's a lot of gory scenes. this is what I expected the series to be and it's finally living to its full potential

Everyone should be reading this series

Beautiful story. Sad it’s ending

Good restart and tynion does a good job helping you remember the story

really really good take on a zombie story. i'm hooked

Ending was ok but felt like it missed a punch

It's been really fun and it's a good creative team. Need a big multi issue story now though

Best issue of the series and it has all the emotion Skottie young knows how to do. Ramos is great in the art

They’ve finally done the set-up (arc 1) and now it seems they’re letting skottie young do his thing and it shows. Ramos’s art is great as always.

amazing plot twist

Very heartfelt story

the scene at the therapist was very emotional and raw. peak lemire

Very fun read

So good! My only thing is that they seem to have skipped a big chunk of the story from 1 to 2!

Very cool idea

This is a good issue but I’m kind of conflicted. It’s a good setup and I kind of want more, but maybe I was expecting a bit more, too, in terms of length. I’m definitely intrigued and u think this could go either way for the rest of the series.

This is a really good comic. The writing is exceptional and I like the water color art. It’s a slow but very fascinating build. A very well done horror story. I like how everyone seems to have given up on catching the killer. Why?

Very good story, seeing this until the end

Very cool first issue! The idea is very creative, it’s intense, and the art work is GORGEOUS. I recommend if you like different things

Very interesting first issue. Love the world building without having to explain everything at the start, it just feels natural

Excellent writing

Did not have too high expectations on this but it was a really good Star Wars story. Plus it’s the first cameo appearance of Marchion Ro.

Loved the pacing and the main character. Good start

Extremely unique story. I love it

i enjoyed this issue! it was a funny and entertaining read, a bit of a throwback style of storytelling.

Really good story, really entertaining and gorgeous art. It’s a very unique twist on a haunted house

Amazing writing and gorgeous art. Deep story

What a masterpiece of a series from Watters and Wijngaard. The art is gorgeous, especially the coloring. And it matches the story so so well, it all flows effortlessly. The story has a bit of everything, is well balanced, and is not as meta as Coffin Bound while still being very deep. One of the most original things out there. You’re missing out if you’re not reading this.

This was really good. Chip is a master storyteller

Chip is a master storyteller

You can definitely tell Kraus is a really good writer. It did feel More like A novel/movie, but the flow was perfect. Highly recommend

incredibly good writing, amazing pacing

Really good writing

So good

This was really really good. I had high expectations for this series and it did not disappoint. It will probably be the best Star Wars series in the last couple of years, and I think they have a real winner in this new era.

Really beautiful story with amazing art. If you like unique things you must get this

I love this series and have been very pleasantly surprised with it. The characters are amazing and it's such an original story. HIGHLY RECOMMEND

This comic is still the best surprise of the last few months. The art is GORGEOUS and the story is very endearing. Reminds me a bit of Descender, where robots were very humanized and there were ethical dilemmas. If you can find copies for all the previous issues please do so.

Wow, I was super impressed. I decided last minute to add this issue to my pull list, and did not regret it one bit. One of the best first issues I've read recently. Every one of the main characters is likable, and the villain is easy to hate. With just one issue you get to know a lot about the main characters and how they develop a deep connection quickly. The pacing is fantastic and had me wanting more. It reminds me a lot of Stranger Things in terms of the mood, pace, and story-telling, and I say that as a large compliment. The artwork is fantastic and perfect for this story. I'm not one to focus a lot on lettering but even that was masterful in this issue. Overall a really, really good issue top to bottom which I HIGHLY recommend.

Just gorgeous

This is why I love comic books. Such an amazing idea by Cates, very original, and very very well done. It’s a classic in the making. Don’t miss it

Love the idea and the characters. This was more of a set up issue and I can see this series is going to be amazing

Kieron at his best

Really good, funny, mysterious. The flow is great. An amazing start to the series

Very entertaining!

Like this series a lot but the ending of this arc felt rushed.

love this new series. one of my favorite in all of black hammer, probably my favorite since the original series. lemire as usual manages to tell a very deep story while also keeping the mystery of not knowing what is going to happen

two issues in and it's really, really good

i'm always blown away with this comic. i get so enthralled reading it. it really is lemire at his best, providing a touching, deep story with surprise ending. please get this even if you haven't read black hammer before

This is King at his best. He's using his best skills on this story. If you love Mister Miracle and Vision you'll love this. He's not rehashing old work, but the best of the style is the same. The combined art by Gerads and Shaner was an amazing idea. I can't wait for next issue. Seriously, pick this book up, you'll regret it if not.

Probably the better issue of them all. The intelectual battle between Alana and terrific is fasicinating

Best issue of the series so far

I LOVE this series and I think it is very underrated. The story is very well crafted and interesting, it's always keeping me on my toes. I always enjoy a psychological mystery/thriller. Even though the series can get sad at several moments because of the physical abuse, it makes you feel closer to the characters. Highly recommend if you like well crafted stories.

This series has by far been the best from Hill House. Issue 5 had me very engaged from the beginning. I really don’t know what will happen and it gets scary at points. Kudos on the whole team for an extremely well done story.

Really good ending to a great series. Could there be a sequel?

Wow this was good. If you like space sci fi then this is it. extremely well written and the art is just gorgeous. Can’t say anything bad about this

There’s no more shock factor like in the first issue, but it’s a really well done story and the art is gorgeous. Fascinated by this world

My favorite issue of the series. Really good writing and art and we start seeing some more horror. Love Erica and highly recommend this issue and series

Really good issue that starts giving us a bit more background on Erica. I love this series!

One of the best if not the best issue in the series. Don’t want to spoil things so I won’t say more except it has surprises

So good, I don’t want this comic to take a hiatus

Really great closure of the first arc

This series is just perfect

Wow! What a comic! Huddleston's art is MAGNIFICENT, loved loved loved the style. Hickman creates an amazing world and an amazing story. His usual pages of explanations are very useful to set the backstory, so then the main story doesn't feel overburdened. The actual main story is very captivating and the characters are great. I really can't wait for issue 2

Beautiful story, concept and art. Rarely do you see character development this deep

This was extremely good and really unique. If you like new stuff, amazing writing and cool art, pick this up

This is just amazing. It’s hard to describe, it’s sexy, funny, and philosophical. And the art is gorgeous. Amazing what March can do with a comic

Near perfect. If you’re a fan of both series (which you should be) you’ll live this. The crossover was very smart

Really great story and very creative view of the apocalypse. Love the characters

This was an amazing first issue and I'd put it with Dollhouse as the best of the Hill House comics. The story is very mysterious and it keeps you engaged. You are dragged with curiosity to see what is happening with the sunken ship. Highly recommend and it's Joe Hill at his best!

This is my favorite hill house comic. It reminds me a lot of 80's/90's horror sci fi thriller. It's funny, it's interesting, the pacing is great and the art is very good for this project. If you like Joe Hill this is a must

This was really, really good. The creators obviously love both dogs and horror movies and even though It’s a weird combination, it just works exceptionally well! The story and the art just mesh wonderfully. They do a great job at getting the right personalities for the dogs. Honestly, can’t wait to read issue 2

This series is so good and brilliant. Can’t recommend highly enough!

Creepy, amazing storytelling

This series is a masterpiece in storytelling. It’s ok if you cry. Can’t wait for the next series

This story will stay with you

Lemire at his best. And Crook’s art is always a guarantee. Highly recommend, especially for black hammer fans

Both stories are beautiful and unique. Highly recommend. Love what bad idea is doing

The issue starts a bit slow but the second half picks up the pace. Wow what a spectacular twist. The art is ridiculously beautiful and the story is amazing. Highly recommend

loved the dark humor and the storyline, will keep reading it

First I was unsure of the new artist, Bergara, as even though it looked gorgeous, I liked the darker style of previous issues, I thought it fit the character better. But wow Spurrier and Bergara worked amazingly well together and out out an amazing and very funny issue. My favorite so far if the series. Can’t wait to keep reading this series

This particular issue is just a masterpiece. The whole series has been amazing but this just takes it to another level. One of the best single issues I’ve ever read.

This issue is perfect. I really can’t understand why they’re stopping this. If they can’t market it it’s not the creative team’s fault.

Really amazingly well done story. Very excited for this

Amazing issue that further explain how all of the story component works. I’m a huge fan of Tynion but this is probably his best work, his masterpiece.

This story is amazing

The plot twist is really good. Tynion is very good at what he does

This is a really, really good comic with an amazing idea. I like end of the world stories but sometimes feel like they’re repetitive. Not this. It’s charming, emotional, and you immediately connect to the characters. The art is gorgeous. HIGHLY recommend!

Still amazing and touching story with a great ending. Can’t believe this is only a 5 issue series

This series is so emotional. It’ll break your heart, especially because you get to love the characters. Can’t wait to see what la coming

One of the best new books latently, definitely this year. If you like tech sci fi you can’t get better than this. Every little detail was amazing. Live it!

This series is practically perfect. If you like sci fi then read this

great humor, great story. highly recommend!

This book is amazing. It will make you laugh a lot. Axe is now one of my favorite comic book characters!

Wow was this book good. I grew up loving the turtles but had never read the comics. But this is a VERY good story. This is like a combination of a Batman, samurai and turtles story. Can’t recommend enough!

Wow... this book is a masterpiece. Mandatory reading for any comic reader

Just… wow. I’m emotional after reading it. What an amazing series and amazing ending.

Tynion is just getting better and better. This is just a masterpiece of a first issue. Cannot recommend highly enough. Ans Martinez’s art is perfect for this

Tynion is just a master storyteller. You need to pick up this book

Just... wow. Ridley is one heck of a writer.

Just... wow!!!!! It does hit a bit too close to home, but wow, what an incredible issue. What incredible storytelling. This will be a sure classic.