The puzzle just added a few new pieces in this dark mystery from Jeff Lemire and Andrea Sorrentino, and we can't wait to see them fall into place. Read Full Review

'Gideon Falls'#2 by Jeff Lemire, Andrea Sorrentino, and Dave Stewart continues to develop a genuinely creepy and disturbing tale told with perfect pacing and eye-catching artwork.5 stars. Read Full Review

Gideon Falls is quickly becoming a must-read, and this is coming from someone who usually doesn't love horror. The slow burn of the central mystery is allowing for some fascinating character studies and truly haunting moments. Read Full Review

I have no idea where Jeff Lemire is taking this story, but I can't wait to see. Andrea Sorrentino and Dave Stewart continue their fantastic work on the art as well. Read Full Review

A strong opening installment is followed by an equally strong second outing. A solid story from Lemire combined with more great art from Sorrentino and Stewart. Highly recommend this book, particularly if you like a mystery with a supernatural element. A great read. Read Full Review

The story of Norton Sinclair and Father Fred continues! What is this mysterious old barn? Jeff Lemire delivers suspenseful storytelling as Father Fred and Norton Sinclair wade through the mysteries of Gideon Falls. Andres Sorrentino and Dave Stewart provide gritty and raw artwork. Read Full Review

Gideon Falls #2 is another perplexing yet grabbing issue of the Jeff Lemire and Andrea Sorrentino series. This super team of creators are putting together something special here, even if it is playing coy with the plot. This one gets another recommendation. Check it out. Read Full Review

The more that we learn about this multifaceted story and the ominous Black Barn within it, the more obvious it becomes that there is still so much left to learn; with each door that opens, two more close. Gideon Falls #2 is wonderfully mysterious and is deserving of great praise. Read Full Review

Not using prop characters like issue #1 did, Gideon Falls issue #2 focuses on building characters, teasing new arrivals, and developing its core story which looks like a promising, terrifying saga. Read Full Review

Mysterious, engaging and showcasing a team in full synchronicity, "Gideon Falls" #2 remains a must-read for fans of psychological horror. Read Full Review

Dave Stewart's colors complete the experience, particularly with his use of red.  That shade means danger and when it appears on the page, the scare factor goes up.  Since most of the issue looks grim and dark, red stands out in a vibrant, violent nature.  It's a shock to the system.  Gideon Falls has pulled me in completely.  I still have a lot of questions, but the tone of the story and the mystery surrounding the Black Barn is more than enough to keep me interested.  We're still learning about the main characters, however we know enough about them to get wrapped up in their lives and want to see this through. Read Full Review

What is the purpose behind the Black Barn? And what of Father Quinn? Will Norton and his therapist uncover the secrets of barn? Pick up issue #2 and find out. Read Full Review

Gideon Falls plays out as something that I would find to be really intriguing if it was a late night premium cable series. I can envision the flow of it, the characters that inhabit it, and the way that the Black Barn and the red light around it would be quite chilling to say the least. As a comic, it's going to take some time to really warm up to as it's going for the slow unfolding of events, which makes sense for it, but it feels like it just needs a little more of a hook to really cement it for me. Read Full Review

The first issue was consistent but fairly safe in everything it did. It had that one killer scene which made it seem like American Gothic or some dramatic TV show with a grounded supernatural feel to it. The second issue doesn't have that one killer scene though and is a bit duller because of it. It's all consistent and safe, but nothing is so thrilling or interested that someone would need to keep reading. There's not dying need to know what the Black Barn is because so far, it's just there. Sure, there's a small element added, but it was expected, much like the rest of the plot. If you enjoyed the first issue, you're sure to enjoy the second, but if you didn't, there's nothing here that's going to change your mind. I'll likely stick with it for review sake, but my excitement has diminished a lot from the first issue. Read Full Review

Jeez. This was a gripping read. Pacing and atmosphere kept my shoulders tightened all the way through.

Another great issue from Jeff Lemire and team. I really enjoyed the mystery here and how both the protagonists suffer while discovering the truth behind the "Black Barn". This issue also had very good moments with the Dr. Xu character. I am still very intrigued in seeing where this mystery heads and cant wait for the answers to be revealed. As always great writing from Jeff Lemire and the always great art by Andrea Sorrentino that fits the tone of this book perfectly and at the same time keeps the creepiness touch to it. Overall, a very good follow up to the first issue.

Back to back homeruns (issue 1 and 2)! Can't wait for the next issue. Pick these books up NOW!

Fantastic! I typically don't like Sorrentino's art, but for this story, it totally works!

Gideon Falls continues to be a haunting story with tesion and great art. Serrentino is typically not my favorite but his style in horror is a great fit. Lemire is crafting a story that makes the reader feel like they are at the edge of a cliff they can not see and no one knows how deep we will fall. If you want a great horror series than do yourself a favor and jump into this book.

Intriguing story and amazing art.

It looks as though this could be a great series.

While slightly slower than the previous issue, this was still an amazing instalment to this intriguing story.

There are some interesting developments that's for sure; especially at the end. I'm digging the scratchy looking artwork and colours. Good stuff.

Norton continues with his therapy but something suddenly makes him go to Dr. Xu and ask for help but she seems reluctant at first. Father Quin tells the police his story of the events that happened but his story is not convincing at all. He calls the Bishop for help but to no avail. Then, another body is found...
In this second issue we get to know the characters a little better. The art is creepy and fitting. As for the story, it readslike a movie adaptation, like you can take it and film a movie scene by scene, panel by panel.I don't know if that is good or bad but it's good.

This issue was a lot of fun and is really building the mystery and characters well. Not a big fan of the art. The backgrounds and things look really good but all the guys look like evil steve rogers in secret empire.

Intriguing

The second part was more difficult for me. That's start to be weirder and the vibes are more heavy on the dark part.
I still cared for the character so I don't like the Inequity Father Fred lived.

Cover - Still great 2/2
Writing - Still great in the construct. But more darker & sometime unfair. 2/3
Arts - Still love the art. 3/3
Feeling - Sorry but not really for me 0/2