-
10
Absolutely brilliant!!!! The writing in this is so beautiful. I love hearing Jim Gordon explain his detective work I love how everything came together I just plain love this issue. I don't know how I'm going to be able to wait for the next issue. James tynion continues to blow me away his writing style just speaks to me. The artwork was beautiful throughout this book as well. Thank you to the creative team for this gem
-
10
This issue its a little bit boring, still it has some great and powerful moments. The art its so breathtaking and work so well in this type of story.
-
9.0
A detective noir that shifts into a globe-trotting action-adventure featuring enough Courts of Owls and Banes to keep it firmly in the world of DC Comics Batman.
-
9.0
Idiots who are bawling their eyes out over not getting enough Joker wank are pathetic.
Edit: lol here comes my mentally deranged stalker who is obsessed with me.
-
8.5
I actually really enjoy this comic, it's very engaging. The "Also featuring Punchline" on the cover feels more like a threat than anything. Let us speak of it no further.
-
8.5
" But forever after that, at night, when i closed my eyes, i could see him waiting for me. I could hear him laughing."
- JIM GORDON
-
8.5
It's so odd to read two of the writer's issues at the same time, when one is good and exciting and the other is boring and tedious.
That is happening with Tynion's Joker and Batman run. I'm currently invested in this but I'm so bored of Tynion's Batman run.
And I don't get it.
As for the Punchline story, I skip it. Because I don't care. Maybe it should affect the rating bu eh, I don't care about that story enough to do so.
-
8.5
Great artwork and dialogue for the characters.
-
8.0
The Joker story was great as usual especially with the ending but the Punchline story backup was a bore and feels like this story is dragging and I've lost my interest in it.
-
8.0
Tynion is doing great. March is at his best. But I can't give a higher rating to this because of the backup.
-
8.0
A step down from the prior issue in quality from a writing standpoint but still good. (I'm ignoring the very dull Punchline story in my rating.)
-
7.5
I definitely the previous issue liked much more , this one bored me a bit. I wonder, why can't Tynion give him the same quality in the Batman series as he is doing here?
On the other hand I thought that the idiotic comments were over, however ComickerPerson this week forgot to take his medicine for dementia since curiously I don't see anyone asking for the Joker in particular and If someone wishes to have more of the Joker, this person does not have to offend ANYONE. WHY DOES NO ADMINISTRATOR TAKE THIS GUY OUT HERE? it's disgusting read someone launching offenses even if it is to ghosts, it reminds me of a crazy woman that I saw years ago, the woman launched offenses to passersby near her just because she it offends his presence. She is crazy, but that does not justify tolerating such behavior. more
-
6.0
Ugh, the main story continues to be one of the best comics DC is putting out, while the backup continues to be fucking garbage.
-
6.0
In the story of JIMMY GORDON, (I think they was called this series Joker to attract readers and not Gordon It's great the focus on Gordon and not the weary Joker, this time Tynion is doing a good job) the rhythm has dropped, it starts with a good introduction reminiscent of Killing Joke and the trauma that Jim experienced at the hands of the Joker, after that the speed drops notably, there are fragments that I would dare say are a bit boring .
The Joker's statement confessing that Arkham never gassed gives rise to new suspects and one of them is possibly Jim's contractor.
Puncheline's story didn't appeal to me in the least.
-
4.5
This series got off to a decent start, but I don't know why I smell like disaster now that Tynion summoned his Joker.
I don't know why they should put Punchline in, it's really such a bad copy of Harley Quinn
-
1.0
Nothing quite like 15 pages of solid narration in a comic book to show what an excellent writer you are. There is an old rule in comic book writing "Show don't tell", this seems to be lost on Jim Tynion. I'm going to call him Jim because with him using IV in his name he seems like an uptight guy. Anyway, the book could be good if it wasn't for the over narration and other various aspects. Female version of Bane looks as ridiculous as it sounds as a concept. The secondary story for Punchline is trying too hard to generate interest in a character no one asked to be created in the 1st place much less follow in an ongoing story. Save your money kids!
-
10
-
9.5
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
7.0
-
1.0
-
1.0