-
10
This continues to be my favorite book. Unbelievably great writing and artwork. I love everything about this one
-
8.5
Really not sure what folks are asking for. This is a high stakes story with a classic Batman villain and new ones, a lot of toys to play with and storylinrs running snd it never skips a beat.
Im having a good time reading this.
-
8.5
Batman - 8.5/10
Ghost-Maker - 8/10
-
8.5
Arte maravilhosa, o problema da edição é que 80% já estava em Alpha.
Mas a cena da Cass derrubando o Batman me ganha uns pontos.
-
8.0
This was a good start to the proper Fear State storyline for Batman. Jimenez continues to put out fantastic work here, and Tynion's story is certainly intriguing. Batman is basically cracked out of his mind because of Scarecrow and I thought it was interesting to see him that way, as opposed to him always having his guard up completely without error. The backup story isn't bad either. I actually like Clownhunter and I think he has potential to become a pretty good character. It will just depend on how he's handled in the future.
-
8.0
I actually liked this one. It was a little redundant but kept me entertained. I also didnt mind the back up story either.
-
8.0
Jimenez is really doing some top notch work here. I stopped on multiple pages just to admire his art and Morey's colors just sing. And while the issue was a bit exposition heavy, I think it worked as we continue to see Tynion's pieces move into place. The general sense of paranoia the writing exudes permeates each character and really lends to the overall theme of the event. I'm a bit worried about event bloat, but so far we're off to a pretty great start.
-
8.0
I am probably one of the minority bit I really enjoy the beginning. The art is great and even though it's recap I feel that at least the story is finally progressing for once. We actually know the purpose of magistrate for once and the exposition isn't that bad
-
7.5
The part of the issue I really enjoyed was the beginning where Batman escapes Scarecrow. Scarecrow can be a terrifying villain, and Tynion and Jimenez are obviously well suited to tell that sort of story. The rest is not nearly as fun for me. It's not a bad issue, but Tynion is asking a lot from me to truly enjoy this. The backup was fine, I guess.
-
7.5
A lot of dialogue, mostly which is recap. The writer does ramp up a little bit since the "fear state" event has started with this issue and it does excite for the next issue but its sill nothing special.
-
7.0
Nice issue, but that ´´unofficial`` Peacemaker with with a Saint logo on his chest was dumb as fuck. Loved seeing Cassandra drawn by Jimenez.
-
6.5
I thought the first story was ok, again very great art from Jimenez, the second was just unnecessary and bad.
-
6.0
It's not like this is bad. But after Alpha being mostly setup, this issue being just recap and more setup really isn't a good thing for this series' pacing.
I've reread Tynion's Batman run and while I do like it more now when reading it back-to-back, this series really has poor pacing and plot progression.
But Jimenez's art is still wonderful.
-
5.5
This was more or less the same thing we've come to expect from Tynion's current run. Another new character, Batman returning after spending several days held by an enemy. If you feel as I do you're counting down the remaining issues not for the story's climax, but the fact it will finally be over. I was looking through some old issues remembering how I'd anticipate each new Batman issue in the old days, but these days I'm just not as enthusiastic.I'm just hoping things will improve a little after this story finally ends.
-
4.5
More of the same from Tynion, which is just basically a rehash of previous Batman stories done in the past. In this it's Knightfall. Batman is replaced by a more violent version that kills and hears voices.
Batman has to, through shear force of will, fight off the attack that was meant to cripple him. In Knightfall, it was his back, here it's Scarecrow's mental games. You may say that's different, but I am declaring variation of theme.
Calling in Ghost who wears white bed sheets is just like how Batman called in Azrael. It's not a one to one parallel, but it's pretty close. All the actual action took place in another side book. So this issue is all exposition setting up the new paradigm. St. Simon Says wants to go through with his plan even though he knows it's been hijacked by Scarecrow. I think Tony Stark holding a whiskey glass might have something to say about that.
We see Batman with Oracle, the Batgirls and they talk and talk and talk yet do nothing. You can't have a main story where all the action takes place elsewhere. That's just a bridge too far for me. In these multi issue crossovers, the main action takes place in the main story book, and the side issues can be skipped, but do offer a fuller viewing of the main story. That's the way it was done in the past when the kids stayed off my lawn and I see no reason to change that now.
We still don't really know a lot about the, what is it - third?, group created by Tynion as a reaction to Batman's war on crime. I can't even remember their name. And what's their goal? What's their manifesto? Their purpose? What holds them together? Damned if I know, but I will admit to only reading the stories once, so maybe nuance has been lost on me.
I am SO SICK of the "Batman has to shake off the villain's efforts to break him through his awesome Batwill." That's been done to death in Knightfall, City of Bane, Snyder's Batman run, the Joker Wars, and God knows how many other stories in the past years. Here's a thought, instead of robbing Frank Miller's Batman yet again, why not try something different. A Batman who is smart, treats his fellow heroes well, and can be seen actually helping people. I kind of like Adam West's Batman. Jokes aside, his Bruce is seen as being caring, tolerant and working toward a better world as both Batman and Bruce. He suggests the study of music and math because they can bring people together. Instead of condemning hippies, he notes their flower power stance is meant to bring peace to the world and therefore should be applauded.
Now that would be a brave and bold stance, writing a Batman who is actually nice and well-adjusted. That attitude certainly didn't hurt Steve Englehardt's famous Batman run in the 1970s.
The art was nice, but the story was, again, just there and just a rehash of Batman stories from the past. These stories can be easily accessed because DC has continued to put them out in books that can be bought at any comics and regular book store. Do something original.
Or I could be wrong. more
-
1.0
Drivel, pure drivel. Is it a race to the bottom for DC at this point?
-
10
-
10
-
9.5
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
6.5
-
6.5
-
6.0
-
6.0
-
6.0
-
6.0
-
5.0
-
5.0
-
1.0