Overall, I love this book and look forward to the continuation of the series as we are now at the halfway point of the mini-series. This is a must-read for both Batman and horror fans. Read Full Review

The action ratchets up throughout the issue, creating a suspenseful and foreboding tone that culminates in yet another great cliffhanger for this series. Read Full Review

Pure Pulsating Perfection From Start To Finish! Read Full Review

But what happens when being Batman stops working? What happens when every ace up Batman's sleeve is completely useless, because his adversary knows how many Batman's holding and when he's going to use them? Batman has come back from having his back broken, faced down Darkseid, and even defeated the Justice League. But he's never faced the worst possible version of himself. Snyder is going to show us what happens when the pillar of Batman crumbles, the rug is pulled out from under him, and the plan of being Batman no longer works. You won't be disappointed with the results. Read Full Review

I'm already adding this series to my ‘Best of the Year' list, and even thought its only February any other comics are seriously going to be hard pressed to knock it off that particular perch. Read Full Review

Jocks art is perfect in this issue. Everything from the stark and shocking reveals to the quiet and subdued dialogue heavy moments is filled with detail and drawn in a tone that perfectly matches the story. Read Full Review

Snyder paces his story perfectly and this is a shining moment for him writing this series. He knows his story well and writes the hell out of it. And Jock gives this book some of the best art of his career. We are now halfway through and I have no idea where the hell it might go. Read Full Review

It's a story about crime, insanity, and corruption, and it's easily the best thing Snyder has written for DC since the end of his 52-issue Batman run. Read Full Review

Packed with action and excitement,The Batman Who Laughs (2018-) #3is a highly-entertaining issue that ends on a note that is sure to leave readers eager to read the next chapter of this intense story. Read Full Review

With his breaking down of Batman, Snyder continues to prove why he is one of the best Batman writers ever.Theres no way out and Im loving it. This issue will leave you stunned over the revelations at the end. Read Full Review

This book is just precious. While I can't speak to the implications of this issue given its ending, this is going to be an amazing story to just hand to somebody who wants to read an iconic Batman story. Read Full Review

Last thing, the Joker looksterrible, even by his standards. Jock's art and David Baron's colors only make things look a million times, worse"in a good way. Read Full Review

This story is twisting my guts and stealing my breath. I know that this is a comic, but I haven't felt as fearful for Batman's life since the heady days of Knightfall. I haven't felt Batman slipping so far from his code or his morality since the death of Jason Todd. Let me state right now, what Bruce decides to build in the Batcave workshop at the end of the issue leaves readers with a cliffhanger par-excellence. I cannot unsee what I have seen. My eyes, MY EEEYYYEEES! Read Full Review

A fantastic issue with a shocking ending! 4.5 out of 5 stars. Read Full Review

Well, Bruce just became the Batman Who Laughs. I am curious how he will avoid the fate of the Dark Multiverse version. Read Full Review

The artwork is also great: Jock and Baron establish a foreboding and moody atmosphere and especially the way they render Batman's body language adds depth to Snyder's script, as it shows how Batman continues to descend into madness. Read Full Review

THE BATMAN WHO LAUGHS #3 painstakingly moves the plot forward with new character developments and one shocking cliffhanger. Read Full Review

This was a fantastic issue. If you're wondering what Black Mirror would look like with Bruce Wayne instead of Dick Grayson, I recommend you check this one out. Read Full Review

Halfway through their six-issue miniseries, Snyder and Jock continue to raise the stakes in the engaging and action-packed The Batman Who Laughs #3. Read Full Review

Writer Scott Snyder has once again delivered to us fans another truly great and memorable Batman story, and after seeing this book's twist ending, I can only imagine what madness we'll witness in the next chapter. I'm so looking forward to seeing that hahahahaha. Read Full Review

The issue as part of the whole is a good one though on its own it falls a bit short. It's definitely not a place to start but for those already reading the series, it's a good addition to the overall story. Read Full Review

This issue suffers a bit in the pacing department as Scott Snyder pauses a bit to make things fit a little bit better.  I am still on board and the cliffhanger has me pumped for the next issue.  Jock's art was great, but overall this issue was just good. Read Full Review

With another one shot slated to surround the Grim Knight in the near future, Dark Knights Metal continues to spin out new comics even a year after its finale. Snyder and Jock leave much to be desired as the larger meaning of the series still fails to present itself and accomplishing nothing of higher importance in the process. As it stands the series lacks a an actual purpose outside of cashing in on the hyperbole surrounding the the titular villain and his new sidekick from the Dark Multiverse. Read Full Review

Gordon Jr. is amazing in this. And so is almost everything else. The art is a bit rushed in some places but otherwise acceptable.

But why I like this mini-series so much is because of the ultimate villain that BWL is for Bruce. No matter what he thinks or plans, Batman Who Laughs has already think that. And Snyder doesn't undercut Bruce in anyway to make BWL look more awesome.

My only real issue in this mini-series is that the Grim Knight could have more backstory, but oh well.

And the ending only makes it better to me. The idea of Batman isn't working right now for Bruce. Bruce cannot do anything to defeat BWL, except to become like him.

+ Like • Comments (1)

• Likes (4)

• bucswin611
• SnakeWilson
• Darkseid24
• Linkush

Darkseid24 - Feb 13, 2019

The Grim Knight will have his own one shot soon. Guess his origin is explained there.

Sign in to comment

It's so cool to see Grim Knight vs Batman Prime in action here.

Keeps on improving. Very well-written, however, I find the titular character, The Batman Who Laughs, to be least interesting part of this book.

A more straightforward entry to the mini-series, Snyder continues his detailed and grounded prose, and new character interactions (Gordon, Jr. is added; Penguin) keep this arc fresh. Though he created BMWL, Snyder has given him such a distinctive voice that's honestly a joy to read, because the writer is at the top of his game in his monologues. But colorist David Baron (see Detective Comics #998) again is the star of the show, bringing a wide variety of settings to life.

Batman (the real one) is acting quite crazy and also pretty mean ( towards James Jr.) in this issue, but it’s still a great one. Can’t complain about much here. I especially liked Gordon’s interactions with his son. I already felt sorry for him in Batgirl, so I hope DC gives him a chance to redeem himself ( even so he probably will be a psycho mass murderer again). Have to say the Batman who Laughs is great so far, even so I didn’t like Metal. However Im wondering how James reacted, when Bruce went all crazy at the end. It’s nice to see Batman‘s limits& the alternative versions of him works quite well here. Penguin felt kind of pointless, but guess he’s part of the plan. This mini series keeps being great.

Nice entrance by Grim Knight. The Penguin business feels random, we must be touring more alternate Bruce Waynes, I hope this comes to some sort of payoff. Watching Batman slowly succumb to the poison is the most interesting aspect of the story.

I'm not sure if read Dark Nights: Metal and not liking it just made me more suspicious and critical of Snyder's writing here, or this issue is genuinely worse than the previous two. I'll probably have to come back to it later to be sure. But I feel like the tightness of the original, more metaphorical conflict is being stretched out by a more and more complicated plot.

+ Like • Comments (1)

•

dannymalt - Feb 16, 2019

Agreed, this one is confusing.

Sign in to comment

I enjoyed The Batman Who Laughs #2 and looked forward to this issue. Unfortunately, this one is a bit of a letdown on all sides. 

I'm a huge Batman fan but I'm not a fan of the pretentious version that is sort of a know it all. That variant of Bruce is literally all over this issue. 

This comic marks the first direct encounter between our Batman and the Grim Knight. It's a brief scene that also ends anti-climatically. The character looks awesome and the Idea of a Punisher variant of Batman is beyond inspired. This encounter just seems really weak. There's a moment where the characters are talking to each other within earshot of James Gordon and I'm finding it really hard to believe that the supporting characters don't know Bruce's true identity.  

Another key problem with the issue is Jock's linework. It simply doesn't measure up this issue. I hate saying that because I know what he can do when he's hitting all cylinders. This is not his best work and the story does not play to his strengths as an artist. 

There is a sub-plot with Jame's Gordon Jr. being brought in to help Bruce decipher The Batman Who Laughs plan and even that seems off.

The issue is just rough and I'm thoroughly disappointed. The creators behind this series are better than this.  more

This issue lost me through a few little things. First, there are so many typos in this comic. I don't know what happened. But it took me out of the issue every single time. Second, why is Batman so flippant with his identity in this? It seems like Jim Gordon, at least, should know about his identity. Third, we get the Last Laugh and Gotham Waterways explained again in this issue for no reason. Recap pages would fix the need for this. I didn't hate this issue or its story or the art, but it tried its best to make that happen.

This issue felt a little bit jumbled for me and I was kind of having trouble following just what was happening and why.

This issue lost me all throughout it! The story doesn’t need to be as big as Snyder is making it. Too many things taking place in this issue and all confusing from what program is Gordon jr talking about all the wya to the end with what the hell is Bruce doing?! The art is alright. Dialogue would have been great if I wasn’t so confused so it’s just eh.

"Nice shot, Bruce"

This one was kind of a snooze. I was bored.

Not up to par with snyder's other arcs. Teaming up with Gordon, Really?!

So, now we skim the top.

Story: 4/10
Art: 3/10
Overall: 4/10


Story: It's tough to give a review to this issue without spoiling the ending, but basically... you can skip issue 2 and 3, because it seems like issue 4 will start off at exactly the point issue 2 should have?

That's what I get from things. It all seems pretty well useless to me.
Listen, I met Snyder for the 3rd time last September, and in a private VIP setting, he was pitching this story. He brought up James Gordon JR, and it all seemed really really exciting.
I'm half way through the series and I can't help but ask myself, will I finish it?

Art: Jock really struggling here. I'm not sure if it was the script or what, but this had no standout moments. It almost looked like he had a bad deadline. Seriously.
The interaction between the Grim Knight and him, jarring...

Overall: I hate giving this a 3. This sucks though, you could skip this issue almost entirely. Oh well, I guess nothing is perfect. Maybe I should have waited for the trade, because these serial monthly releases aren't working out for me.

Wah wah.
4/10 more

More of the "Batman who Laughs" garbage. DC really needs to get over this character in a hurry.