-
10
Exciting and surreal.
-
10
It just keeps getting better. And Tony Daniel's contributing the best work of his career. I've always liked his art well enough but he's been out of this world on this arc. I've loved the slow burn/long game of King's run but we're nearing the endgame now and pace has really picked up and the urgency has too. The last two issues have been fantastic.
I see a bad end coming for Flashpoint Batman and Gotham Girl but I really hope they manage to stick around, especially FP Batman. I haven't been so excited by a new Batman villain since Ra's al Ghul.
-
9.0
It took half a year but King's run is finally back on track.
-
9.0
When I heard of Captain Atom showing up, I had predicted the government wanted to wipe Gotham off the map or maybe that Psycho Pirate controlled him and Bane was using him as a deterrent. I totally forgot somehow Gotham Girl is already a deterrent...
This was pretty great. I am in love with this idea of Gotham being run by villains and it continues to deliver.
-
9.0
I just want to say this:
Good art
Good story
Tom King and Tony Daniel show us what is Gotham City right now and it is amazing. It is a story that encompasses many issues, so it will progress little by little.
-
9.0
Gotham is descending into madness and it's such a joy to read.
The issue starts with Gotham Girl and Captain Atom fighting because Atom can sense that something is wrong in the city but gets beaten by Gotham Girl pretty easily (maybe the fight should have been tenser or longer), reinforcing the idea that getting into Gotham city without Bane's permission is not an easy task to do. We then jump to scenes with Kite Man (Hell Yeah!) and Scarecrow trying to run away from Bane but eventually they get caught because no one can escape Bane's plan. While all of this is happening we get some scenes that show us Catwoman trying to take care of Bruce. Loved those scenes and I can't wait for Bruce to finally wake up and give us what we waited for so long.
Tony Daniel's art here was probably one of his best. Such a good artist. more
-
9.0
"Shit negro, here we go again"
City of Bane continues to introduce us to the New Gotham City. King's still writing so there the same qualities and problems than the last 75 issue. I really enjoyed the issue, the stakes keep getting higher. The Batman chasing vilain was cool and it is nice to see Kite Man again. Hoping to see more of him in the next issue.
-
8.5
I think a lot of people are blinded by their hatred towards Tom King and his... erm. Disastrous Heroes in Crisis. And believe me, I am not pleased at what came out of that series, either. I'm also really mad at him for how he wrote that story. It ultimately left a lot of soreness. However, I try not to look at the writer, but the story. And what I see is a pretty good story.
I see that the stories are improving. After trudging a long way from the Knightmares, the story feels like it's picking up pace again. Overall, it's a good read.
It was nice to see Tim and Damien interact. I haven't really seen them much, and I think Tom handled them pretty well. Damien acts like a spoiled brat at first, but it's clear he's hiding his fears and worries behind a spoiled face. He really wants his Dad back. Handled well, and almost perfectly how I see Damien nowadays (thanks Tomasi). And Tim, of course, is keeping a cool head and trying to solve the issue. But he's also worried.
The Cat/Bat thing is getting a bit wearisome. I'm one of the minority opinions who just want them to get back together as quickly as possible. But we all know that's not going to happen. Batman won't forgive her THAT easily. Realistically, that's not happening.
To answer a couple of questions (SPOILERS!):
1. How in the world could Gotham Girl take down Captain Atom THAT easily???
It was a bit confusing for me, too, but then I remember that Gotham himself pretty much defeated the Justice League in a stroke, until his juice ran out and he plopped. I can imagine Gotham Girl pretty much doing the same thing at this point. So if Gotham could trade blows with the entire JL, it's not too hard to imagine Gotham Girl sweeping the floor with CA. Sorry Cap.
2. Why does the Cat/Bat story keep going? I just want it to end.
Yeah, I almost share that sentiment. Believe me, I'm not the biggest fan of the whole Bat/Cat thing. The concept, though, has been out there for a while. And I still ship them. Evidently, King does, too. I'm hoping that they actually get together in the end, cuz that would be a good ending. King, don't fail me (even though you probably will).
So yeah, overall, not a bad issue, and finally, I'm hoping to see more of what King has. more
-
6.5
I have mixed feelings on this issue. There are some parts I really liked..........
1. First off I have to say I love the art. Selena looks so pretty. Strangely oriental when I believe she is supposed to be Romanian, Italian mix. But who cares. She looks awesome.
2. I did enjoy the part with Tim and Damian on the roof top. I really liked that for once they showed Damian being lost and looking to Tim for answers on what to do. It was a nice brotherly moment for them. I would have liked to have some dialogue about what happened between Bruce and Tim as well as some mention of why they questioned believing him to begin with. I know Bat's has had his crazy like moments here and there over the years. But after all that Bat has done to fight crime why would they jump so quickly to not believing in him? I hope that is answered before Kings run is over with. I have a feeling if not it never will be. That's one of the most annoying habit's comic writers have. Dropping the emotional in depth issues for just writing fighting scenes. I like the characters to actually talk to each other about things. Character growth!!!!
3. I loved Selina with Bruce and how she was begging him to wake up. Even going so far as to bribe him with never stealing again. That was so sweet and emotional. Plus it was good to see Bruce actually hurt and having to be taken care of. He should be in a bad state considering all he has been through. He should have been that way for the last 2 issues. It really was a joke how fast and easily he was "fixed" after his back was broken. Then to be able to fight his father, get out of that pit then travel to and climb some snow covered mountain in search of the Memory of the Mountain guy. I think the writers forget too often that Batman's main appeal and claim is that he's just a man without powers fighting crime.
4. The main thing I love about this story arc is it's supposed to be the City of Bane and yet this issue had none of him it in and the last issue has very little of him. For a person who doesn't even remotely like the character of Bane if I have to have him forced on me because of my love of Batman comics then this is the type of story I want. The type of Bane story that has little to NO Bane in it. LOL
The part I didn't like so much...........
The main issue I had with this issue was that it just didn't move the story along more. Too much time was spent one again telling us what we already knew. There are a lot of unanswered questions that could/should be addressed without repeating information that was revealed in a past issue. We get it Gotham girl is all powerful. Bat daddy is just another heartless villain doing what Bane wants. The question I want answers for is it all him or is he one of Banes puppets also?
more
-
6.0
I don't know. It always feels like King has no clear goal for his stories. I hate the way he writes villains and I'm fed up with his convoluted dialogues. I'm still here for the art and because I want to get over with his run.
-
6.0
I jumped on in the mid-60's, and this qualifies as the first Batman by King that I've read that was halfway decent.
I note that being on the desert on a horse with no name over the previous issues, ending up in a brutal Batman v. Batman throw-down with one Batman emerging, meant absolutely nothing. All those songs, all those Russian storybooks read to us over and over and over...nothing. So what was the purpose in putting the readership through it? To see how low sales had to go before you got fired? (The answer seems to be around 83,000 books...but sales are still dropping...barely hanging in there over 80,000, confirming that it is indeed time to get a better writer on this title and soon.)
We got a painful soliloquy on the downside of being Kite Man in a Batman world, which was silly fun. Considering the volume of spandex running around Gotham on a daily basis, a little silly fun probably happens as a statistical probability. Good on King to finally cast his gaze in that direction.
And I find DC's use of Captain Atom as a de facto Dr. Manhattan intellectually lazy. But that's apparently a DC-wide matter, because the same persona for the good Captain popped up in DCeased.
The art was OK, standard DC stuff.
But all that said, it wasn't an awful issue. And that is a drastic improvement over recent issues. I'm not saying that I would recommend this to anyone, not yet in this world of $4-5 comics (GO READ FREEDOM FIGHTERS INSTEAD), but it's improving...at least for this month. more
-
5.5
And just like that...King lost me again. This is getting a 6 (edit 5.5) from me solely because of the art and atmosphere. With only 10 issues left on the title, King seems to be taking his sweet time because the plot with Bruce goes nowhere in this issue, it's just setting up Gotham's atmosphere, which is cool, but the last issue already did that. We already know it's a bizarro world in Gotham. Daniel's art is great as always, but unfortunately it seems to be wasted.
-
5.0
"Easy or hard?"
Adam Strange is screwed.
-
4.0
The biggest disparity between beautiful visuals and incoherent plot since Prometheus.
-
4.0
I mean the political aspects are kind of cool, but I really could give less of a shit at this point.
Damian is still written like a one dimensional brat, ignoring all of the work Tomasi and Morrison have done for the character since his creation.
I guess Kite-man is dead?
Just a bland story arc containing some good ideas paired with terrible buildup and dialogue.
-
4.0
It's impressive how many parallel points of view Tom King manages to squeeze in just one issue, and make them all so bland and pointless at the same time. I'd love to see the story from Kite Man and Scarecrow's angle, I'd love to see more Gotham Girl, and Robins as well, since they were criminally underused in this run. But at the same time, I can't stop thinking, there's something big missing in this comic - call it "heart", call it "plot", doesn't matter, but despite having all these different POVs, none of them feels captivating and tense. Yeah, even chase and fight scenes.
The art is beautiful, though.
-
3.5
Just hard to follow.
-
3.5
More garbage from Tom King, but some nice art by Tony Daniel.
-
3.0
It had promise last issue.
-
3.0
This comic is so baffling to me. From the way it's structured, to the way it's written. I'm so sick of King's tropes at this point. And there's not even much of a story anymore to form around said tropes. What is going on with the structure here? This comic is slowly breaking down and it's an incredible thing to witness.
-
2.5
I'm tired of this. I'm tired of saying "this issue was better than last issue, at least," because the bar has been set so damn low. I may just stick to rating this series from now on, if that. As for my thoughts on the issue:
Well, it was better than last issue at least.
-
2.5
A pointless issue from an incompetent writer. That's really all there is to say. The art was nice but the lack of coherence and actual story leaves this at a 2.5 for me.
-
2.5
Well we see Selina stealing paintings to pay for Bruce's coma care in Paris. Gotham Girl beats up Captain Atom.
You're caught up.
Nothing else really happens. We see a little more of how Gotham works, but nothing really that informative. The Robins are frustrated, but that's it. Just more decompressed story-telling. The art is nice. But it's also more told, not seen. We don't know who Selina got Bruce from the snowy mountains of wherever there were snowy mountains last issue. (I forget and don't feel like looking it up.)
More Kiteman. To paraphrase Indigo Montoya - "you keep thinking Kiteman is interesting. I don't that word means what you think it means."
We also see Dad Batman using a gun. So what? How does this affect the villains, the cops, the publuc? Again, not show or even told. We do get some shallow villain characterization. The Scarecrow gets off on Kiteman's fear. Wow, deep King.
This is a dull, slow, decompressed issue that moves the story ahead about one inch. It lacks forward momentum, excitement and the feeling that I have to tune next bat-time, next-bat channel to learn what happened. And that's a problem for serialized story telling.
Or I could be wrong. more
-
2.0
I didn’t like this issue& I can’t understand how people can rate it 7 or better. Even the biggest Tom King fan can’t ignore the big plotholes:
Two issues ago Bruce was fighting with a broken back in the desert.
Last issue he was walking around in the Himalayas ( or wherever)& met Catwoman ( even so last time we saw her, she was in a city in the US.
This issue he’s in Paris with Catwoman—- how does this make any sense?
Things are getting even more ridiculous in Gotham. King lets Gotham Girl beat Captain Atom with one punch. This only shows, that King doesn’t have a clue about who the characters are he is writing. Did he ever read a comic with Captain Atom? I don’t think so.
It doesn’t become any better with how King treats the villains. Scarecrow was on Bane’s side during the Knightmare arc, he showed up in a pic, that showed the villains, who are against Batman some issues ago& now he is suddenly against Bane? I mean I sure can’t blame him. Who would want to be part of an inconsistent story like that? I also can’t see, why Scarecrow would hang out with D villains like Kiteman or the Tweedldedum cousins or why he would need their help? King doesnt seem to know anything about Scarecrow except, that his signature weapon is the fear gas. Scarecrow talks very weird in this issue, if he talks at all. The only good thing here is the art& Scarecrow‘s outfit.
It’s also more than boring, that Scarecrow ( don’t expect much of the other two) is only canon fodder for Flashpoint Batman. King sure wants to show what big threat Bane& Thomas are, but that’s just lazy& bad writing. A good writer never wastes the villains and make them look weak. It’s not only ruining their characters, it’s also boring as hell for the reader.
The dialogue also is awfully badly written. Is King not capable of writing at least one decent english sentence? I’m really sick of characters talking as if they were braindead idiots.
So overall the only good thing is the art, but everything else just awful.
more
-
1.5
Tom King just has no idea how to tell a story.
his "plots" are all over the place and incoherent.
Tom King also does not understand nor does he respect any of the characters within the DCU.
him being one of the main writers is a major reason why DC Comics is in so much trouble right now..
DC should just change the companies name to 'The Titanic'.
that would make Tom King an iceberg.
-
1.0
LOL this is the MOST RIDICULOUS BATMAN ISSUE I've ever seen.
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
9.5
-
9.5
-
9.5
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
6.5
-
6.0
-
6.0
-
6.0
-
6.0
-
5.5
-
5.0
-
2.0
-
1.0
-
1.0
-
1.0
-
1.0