Magic and superheroes don't always work well together, but they're not always written by James Tynion IV. His penchant for mystery and darkness makes him perfectly suited for the world ofJustice League Dark.The DC Universe is getting darker and more dangerous for its' heroes, but it couldn't be a better time for the readers. Read Full Review

This is the perfect introduction to a new series it sets up the immediate conflict, peppers in enough foreshadowing for future stories and conflicts, brings the team together quickly and urgently, beautifully fleshes out the magical corner of the DC Universe, and does it all with a sense of ease and purpose. Add in some detailed, bright and beautiful art, and you've got a book that earns a very high recommendation indeed. Read Full Review

This book was fun! It was creepy and it was full of cameos galore! If you can think of someone in the magical spectrum of the DC Universe, then they were likely in this book. My money's worth was when John Constantine tells Zatanna he can't attend the meeting because Baron Winters won't let him in his house again after he made several people burst into flames. Which is a direct reference to "Crisis on Infinite Earths" from the pages of Swamp Thing. Read Full Review

Solid characters, a brilliant script, incredible cameos and art to die for. If the rest of this series is as good as the first issue, I'll be one happy reader. Read Full Review

It's very clear that Tynion has plans for Wonder Woman and her team that will be terrifying and multiverse altering. Justice League Dark #1 is clear and convincing beginning to a horror story that the mainstream DC Universe has never seen. This series is going to be one hell of a crazy ride. Read Full Review

Gloriously mystical, stylishly dark and all kinds of awesome! This is the perfect jumping-on point for those wishing to experience the magical side of DC. Read Full Review

JUSTICE LEAGUE DARK #1 is truly a spectacle. Every scene is executed beautifully. Magic comes to life, right off the pages of this comic. Although some of the characters seem out of place, I am completely spellbound by the plot. This is a story full of magic, mystery, and intrigue. Definitely, a strong start to a new series. If you are a fan of the magical side of the DCU, then JUSTICE LEAGUE DARK #1 is a must read! Read Full Review

Tynion doesn't spend a lot of time assembling the team, which makes the threat seem all the more imminent and threatening. In just this first issue, Tynion teases that the Justice League Dark team roster might not be complete allowing for the possibility of more magic users to eventually sign up. As for me, I'm already hooked and eager to see what kind of unexpected and unusual adventures Tynion and Bueno take this team. Justice League Dark doesn't need any tricks when it's got such a strong creative team steering a potential-ripe title. This should be a fun ride. Read Full Review

This is an extremely promising first issue, one that made me genuinely excited for the run. Read Full Review

Even though parts of the issue were heavy in dialogue, Tynion makes new readers in this realm feel comfortable moving forward while igniting an interest that has had fans clamoring since REBIRTH. Read Full Review

Backed by interesting conflict and a new team that works (surprisingly) well together, Justice League Dark (2018-) promises to be great. Justice League Dark (2018-) #1 is a solid first issue that establishes the tone of the series and introduces readers to a new super-group and the conflict that has brought them together. Read Full Review

Justice League Dark #1 is off to a fantastic start, bringing its gonzo team together slowly while showing how and why this will be a strained fellowship. The characters are compelling, the plot is grisly to a beautiful degree, and the art is impeccable. This one earns a recommendation. Give it a read. Read Full Review

The first issue of Justice League Dark definitely lives up to its name by being darker and more disturbing than a lot of other comics on the shelves now. Wonder Woman serves as a nice surrogate for the audience, and I'm looking forward to seeing a lot more messed up magic in the future. For now, I'll think I'll watch the DC animated film Justice League Dark, which is probably better than any live action version of the film we could ever hope to see. Read Full Review

Although Tynion is going to be missed on Detective Comics, this feels like a new hit for DC in the making. Read Full Review

In Justice League Dark #1, James Tynion takes one part of his tongue in cheek, yet serious exploration of magic and its consequences and complexities in his Hellblazer run, another part the family dynamic of Detective Comics, and gives the book the blockbuster sensibility of co-writing gigs with Scott Snyder and others on books like Dark Nights Metal and Justice League No Justice even going back to his work on the Batman Eternal weeklies and turns into a fairly delightful concoction. Read Full Review

In the end, Justice League Dark #1 was a strong start and I'm eager for issue 2 and as the Tree of Wonder happens to be Salem, I'm looking forward to see how this all plays out and courtesy of the story, the dialogue and the art, I'm invested! Read Full Review

This is a great first issue that looks like it's taking the reader to the darker side of the huge story arcs we just finished. Can't wait to see what happens next. Read Full Review

An exciting, well-paced first chapter which sets the stage for some unique adventures courtesy of the eclectic heroes and the book's dark, grizzly vibe. With epic event ‘The Witching Hour' already announced for October, everything's coming up roses for Justice League Dark. Read Full Review

I enjoyed the time I spent in the magical realms of the DC universe, plus I think Tynion is a great match for the tone and characters. It's a fun opener, and any excuse to spend time with this particular cast is more than welcome. Read Full Review

Justice League Dark feels somewhat like a rehash of things of DC past, but it is no less enjoyable. The magical arena of DC has frankly been neglected over the past few years, so a deeper dive as part of a trend with the publisher is a nice turn. Wonder Womans inclusion is one of my favorite parts of this comic, as her ties to magic are often ignored in favor of other story and lore elements. Magic in DC is assuredly weird, so it fits that the team is as well. However, Im curious to see how these characters work together and if this can turn into a fresh new story for them and the world of magic for DC Comics. Read Full Review

Justice League Dark #1 brings us back to the idea that “Magic problems require magic solutions.” This team may have come together reluctantly, but that is what you come to expect from characters who are not all that used to the idea of big super-heroics or that they can save the world. Read Full Review

While the majority of the issue is spent in exposition, Justice League Dark #1 succeeds in constructing a fun, intriguing narrative with likable heroes, mysterious, terrifying villains, and a new facet to a familiar world. The stage is set, and Justice League Dark looks to be a promising performance. Read Full Review

As a classic John Constantine fan, I'm very interested in where this will go. It's the dark world/hero crusader universe that they've been attempting in the live action films. This time, they are nailing it. Read Full Review

This is the best Justice League Dark Team ever and I really don't care whether you agree! Come on, it has Detective Chimp and Man-Bat! Read Full Review

DC's most recent team-book is an easy recommendation for readers who miss these characters, or just want to get to know them. There's no barrier to stop readers from totally understanding what's going on, and the creative team is working together to ensure that everyone from Zatanna to Man-Bat has a cemented personality by the final page of Justice League Dark #1. Read Full Review

When one starts to factor in magic and sorcery, however, anything is possible and I feel that as the story progresses, Tynion and company have certainly laid the groundwork to make a series that will keep you gasping as you rapidly flip page to page to try and find out what happens next. Read Full Review

If you were a fan of the New 52 Justice League Dark, then you should be picking this up. James Tynion IV is a great storyteller and he is bound to take us on a supernatural roller coaster. Read Full Review

I'm a bit disconnected from some of the events launching this from No Justice and we get mentions of Dark Knights' Metal as well. DC has been expanding from both of those for a while and what comes from it are titles I like, but they're weighed a bit by the event itself. JLD looks to move beyond it fairly quickly and shift focus to the danger that's coming which threatens a wide swath of characters and also simply how a good chunk of things function on Earth. I like the inclusion of Diana in it because she does have a strong background in magic if he's not the kind that she can manipulate and actively use in most ways like others. Tynion has a lot going on here and a lot of dialogue but Martinez and Fernandez keep it moving very well while not rushing it or setting up panels covered in dialogue. I'm definitely looking forward to more as it defines its path. Read Full Review

The characterization of the team is excellent, and the art team does a great job conveying mood and delivering consistently rendered work on every page. I do have some reservations about how far the book will push the envelope and if I'll be completely sold on Wonder Woman's spot on the team, but I can confidently reserve those judgments for later after such a solid start to the series. Read Full Review

Martinez and Tynion impress and have me excited for the rest of this series. The characters are all present and look awesome, and it’s just up to Tynion to continue giving Martinez weird things to draw. Read Full Review

If you enjoyed the previous series or other magic-centric titles in the past, put this on your pulls presto.Packed to the gills with supernatural action, elements of horror and strong dialogue this book not only delivers bang for your buck, it truly feels like the start of something special. Read Full Review

Ultimately then, while its clearly still ramping things up story-wise, this first issue proves that this latest JLD resurrection is going to be a worthwhile one, with a blend of interesting characters and a passionate creative team who are clearly planning on shedding a little light on some of the darker corners of the DCU. You can count me in for the foreseeable future, thats for sure. Read Full Review

I am not sure of the logic of this book. Is there a huge Detective Chimp following that I am unaware off? The previous series suffered, as did many of the New 52 books, falling to crossover hell, with the Trinity War and Forever Evil causing all sorts of problems as well as other minor crossovers with books that had very little fan appeal. In the end, not event the writing might of J. M. DeMatteis could stave off the Cancellation Demon. Now Tynion and gang have a chance to show the DC universe in a different light. Ironic, given the title of this series. Read Full Review

An intriguing premier issue with an eccentric cast of characters to follow. Also, the art is top-notch and worth your time. Read Full Review

Final Verdict: 8.0" With a well-done introduction to the latest incarnation of a mystical Justice League, “Justice League Dark” #1 definitely carries on from the well-done introduction to the new League since “Dark Nights: Metal” and “Justice League: No Justice.” Read Full Review

Justice League Dark is not the perfect start to a series and already stopped the series from being perfect in terms of writing. Luckily it is the art that makes for all the faults worth it, at least until everything builds up to what could be a long-awaited peak for the series. It is surely going to be a series that DC will push strongly for the future and will make previous Justice League Dark fans happy of its return. If you like pretty things buy this book, if you do not get comics for the art, or for Wonder Woman, Justice League teams, or any magical based character then this book is a skip. The art, however, is a must to look at. Read Full Review

Justice League Dark #1 succeeds on the strength of its compelling new team. Read Full Review

Justice League Dark Vol 2 #1 comes with three covers; Cover A is drawn by Alvaro Martinez Bueno & Raul Fernandez Cover.Cover B and C Variants are drawn by Greg Capullo & Jonathan Glapion but theCover C is an Incentive Greg Capullo & Jonathan Glapion Inks Cover. Read Full Review

I can't fault the book for not being exactly what I wanted out of it, but I am still going to point it out. If you are looking for that sweet spot between horror and superheroes, I am sorry to tell you that this isn't it. But, if you are looking for a fun, stylish and well written blend of superheroes and the supernatural, you can't go wrong here. Read Full Review

All in all, Justice League: Dark #1 got off to a great start. Now that the DC Universe has marked a line in the sand that dares any multiverse to cross it will be the first of many. I love that Wonder Woman has taken the lead to this investigation by the horns. For now, I want to see her and the rest of the dark-art members fight this common enemy on their own. Read Full Review

Such vivid delights in the inaugural issue of Justice League Dark beguile, with imminent bewitching still to come. Read Full Review

Wonder Woman's getting the band back together...and that's pretty much all that happens in this inaugural issue. If the idea of these characters teaming up fills you with excitement, then I imagine you'll hang on for the next few issues. I know I will. But if you think DC's magic side is silly, then you can probably skip this series entirely. Read Full Review

A fascinating plot combined with an almost cinematic art style. This series promises to live up to its name, creating a truly dark and disturbing Justice League that I look forward to seeing more of. Read Full Review

It has a unique line up, with at least one choice I was surprised by. Overall, it is a solid book but it might take a little longer to remember the spells to be true magic. Keep your eye on it and pick it up if magic heroes are your thing. Read Full Review

Though a bit overly dependent on previous events, Tynion and Martinez produce an exciting, atmospheric opening for this new Justice League Dark. Read Full Review

Holy shit I loved this issue. Horror, comedy, action. This issue had it all and it sets up the series to be one of the best ongoing dc titles.

Really solid start. It seems Tynion knows what he is doing with this new series and i want to see more of that.

Funny, good art, and a cohesive buildup for a first issue.

Great start

Really excited to see where this goes.

Really good first issue! I love the team line-up for this version. I always liked the premise of the first JLD series but felt like it never lived up to it with constant writer changes and team roster shakes-up every story arc. Here's hoping Tynion can turn JLD into the awesome book it has the potential to be.

Tynion continues to prove he's one of the best writers out there right now. I wasn't too thrilled about this series before reading it, but I did enjoy it and will be back for more.

It was nice to see Tynion writing Constantine again, even for a few minutes, and I'm going to go ahead and be cautiously optimistic about this title as a whole.

Solid. Strong to quite strong.

You had my curiosity, but now you have my attention. Solid first issue. If this can be half as good as Tynion's epic run on Detective Comics then this is going to be an amazing series. Plus it's always good to see Zatanna involved in anything because she's so underrated. Bring on issue 2

I really liked this issue. I think not only is it super satisfying to see all of DC's mystical characters and elements in one book, it is also one of the best scripted and illustrated issues of the week. Easily the best part is Alvaro Martinez Bueno's art which 100% eye candy on every page. This book is illustrated so well, I cannot even begin to express how much I loved the art. Although the first five pages were unfortunately very rushed, the issue eventually slowed down to take the time to lay out the conflicts and the threats of the forthcoming issues. Also, those conflicts are actually interesting for once mostly due to the fact that The Upside Down Man looks to be a unique and original new villain. I also really enjoyed the characters in this issue, as they are written very, very well. I don't think I've ever seen Detective Chimp written so well. Zatanna and Wonder Woman were both good, however the real show-stealer was surprisingly Man-Bat who has more heart, personality and humor than any other character in the book. Lastly I just want to say James Tynion IV's script was really, really good. I don't usually like exposition but for once he made those scenes very interesting. All in all, a great issue, one of the best of the week. more

I give it a 7.8 so I'll be generous and round up. More so for the eclectic DCUmystics appearances than having a clear understanding of this magical threat that WW feels compelled to spearhead the solution for. And there were a couple nice images with an otherwise decent art effort.

Very promising beginning for the new series, teasing the big mystery and setting relationships between the main characters. I'm excited for the plot - lovecraftian monsters jumping out of Zatanna's hat, or deformed zombies are definitely my kind of thing, and I can't wait to see where Justice League Dark will take us, the readers.
I can't say I'm particularly interested in Zatanna's portrayal, though - out of all the characters, she semed like the least sympathetic to me, even though she should steal the show easily. I mean, her competition are a bat, a chimpanzee and a walking cannabis plant, not mentioning Wonder Woman. There's something about her personality that didn't click to me, but for now, I can't identify what exactly it is. Her braid doesn't help either, though - it's not exactly flattering for a showwoman.
Overall really solid issue, I hope it will be followed by equally worthwile ones. more

"Down here in the weird shadows of the world, it's all a bit messier than that"

Justice League Dark or magical Justice League returns after some time away. This time led by Princess Diana instead of John Constantine, but still many familiar faces appear.

Because of the giant hole in the Source Wall magic on Earth goes haywire. Magic users can't keep their magic in check, so they have a meeting to discuss the issue.
Meanwhile, Wonder Woman is trying to investigate the deaths of several magicians killed by their own spells. But she comes out empty handed and all alive magicians she asked for help turned her down.

This is a good debit issue. The mystery introduced here seems interesting and the situation seems dire. But I'm sure our heroes will prevail and I want to be there.
Also, Detective Chimp is pretty great. He is a big downer, but he doesn't let this stop him from solving the next mystery. more

For now I'm not convinced by this title. Not that their isn't good part on it. I really like how Tynion IV add Detective Chimp or Kurt Langstrom to the story. But it's less effective for Zatanna who don't want to be in. Even if her encounter with Swamp thing help a little.
I will wait for issue 2 to convince me or not.

Cover - The variant beautiful & related. 2/2
Writing - A bumpy ride with good part & part less good. 1.5/3
Arts - The art is good, but the character seem a little empty when we look at there eyes. It seem easy to do, but this kind of layout & panel wasn't at all. 3/3
Feeling - mixed 1/2

A good but very talky start. But given that Tynion is in the same mode as his run on Detective, odds are this will get flowing soon enough. And I love this cast.

I had such expectations. Now I have nothing but a resigned sigh of disappointment. I love James Tynion IV! The art isn't bad. But... I've already seen Marvel do this story and ruined Doctor Strange for years. Yes, magic is dying. groan.

Next thing you know we'll have Burnside quality art and a full-scale lessening of the "magic" part of the DCU that we've all been clamoring to get MORE of instead.