/81_medium.jpg)
Prev
It is definitely poorly constructed and written, but bitch... this ain't my first Metal Gear Solid 2.
It's time for the big showdown. Batman is calling Bane out. But is the Dark Knight Detective ready to take on the foe who broke him worse than any other that came before? And what else stands in Batman's way, to put an obstacle between him and his enemy? Tread lightly, Batman, because not only do the lives of your son and trusted friends hang in the balance, but your entire home could collapse on top of you!
Naked Harvey Bullock aside, this is yet another great issue from King. The City of Bane storyline proves that King gets Batman, despite what the doubters may claim. Add some great art from legends John Romita Jr. and Mitch Gerads, and you get an amazing Batman issue. Read Full Review
John Romita Jr and Mitch Gerads create some beautiful art in this issue. Romita Jr's gritty style is perfect for this heavily action oriented issue and Mitch Gerads follow up story with Bullock is a brilliant tie in to the Justice/Doom War. Read Full Review
A great issue of Batman all around. If you like Tom King Batman, this is some of the best. City of Bane is a really interesting arc, and it seems to be heading toward something truly great. Seeing this is the final stretch of King's run, it is one hell of a way to go out. Read Full Review
The last two pages are drawn by Mitch Gerads and they are the best of the issue. It ties into the Year Of The Villain and I enjoyed it. It is a decent enough comic book. I'm interested to see how this all wraps up. I know it will be very cool for sure. Read Full Review
Overall, Batman #81 is once again a terrific issue of Batman that starts to fill in some of the gaps, while delving into the differences between Bruce and Thomas. Read Full Review
Regardless, this chapter ofBatman appears to be coming to a close and I've got a feeling that we'll get the closure we need to walk away from it with a sense of satisfaction, even if there was some frustration or impatience occasionally along the way. Read Full Review
There's a strange backup with Harvey Bullock half-naked and singing a weird song while wearing Joker makeup, and I'm not sure what to make of it, but the art by both Romita Jr. and Gerads is top-notch, even if the story feels scattered. Read Full Review
Tom King is going out on Batman the way he came in: With style and poise. "City of Bane" puts a bow on quite a few tales that Mr. King has woven since picking up the pen on Bruce's cowl, and he doesn't disappoint. Nor has the foot come off the gas pedal when it comes to twists and turns with this issue. Batman #81 is another must-grab as Tom King wraps up his run on the main title, and I can't wait to see what he has planned next for Bruce (and Selina). Read Full Review
As much as I complained about Batgod in this issue, I freaking love it. Its the Batman I grew up with and hes back. God I cant wait for Bruce to beat his father senseless. Read Full Review
Ultimately what works here most comes in the last few pages, when you realize Batman's plan isn't going to plan. It makes up for the somewhat disappointing undoing of most of the series' drama and the fact that we still haven't gotten to Bane. Read Full Review
BATMAN #81 is compelling, though much of the actual story here is simple exposition; the Bat Family's "How I Did It" statement. The artwork is phenomenal, though, making for a visually-stunning work. Read Full Review
I have issues with some of the revelations that have come with this issue, but the Thomas Wayne moments made for a solid issue. Read Full Review
While it's a bit difficult to read, King's writing makes this issue well worth reading for everyone enjoying his run and this arc. Read Full Review
Overall this is one of the better issues I have picked up in a while and I was most excited by the fact that there was finally something that drew me in and got me pumped up to see what happens next. It finally brought Bruce Wayne back into his element and that is always nice to see. We also learn of a drawn-out plan he has had throughout which brings us back to that detective mastermind feeling that has been absent for a little bit. As drawn out as the series has been, this issue makes up for it and I highly recommend picking this one up. Read Full Review
For me Batman #81 pulls its narrative threads together in an oddly boring way. King teases just enough to keep things intriguing, but the mechanics of the storytelling feel very pedestrian. Read Full Review
Heavy-handed narration throughout the issue wipes away anything that made this storyline remotely interesting, all so we can build up to a predictable ending. Read Full Review
DC's flagship Batman series continues to struggle even as it builds to a major finale. Read Full Review
With four more issues left in his run, King has to start advancing the City of Bane and while theres definitely some movement on that front, its still hardly satisfying. Read Full Review
Batman #81 is such a massive disappointment. Rather than being cool character development, the heavy exposition from Bruce Wayne is just exhausting. By the midway you start counting how many more pages are left in Batman #81. This issue is just a complete failure in building anticipation from what will happen next in "City of Bane." Read Full Review
We are truly in the endgame of King's Batman and, personally, I think it has taken a huge blow. The remaining four issues can still be decent as standalone issues. But I don't see them redeeming the overall story. I sure as hell hope King manages to prove me wrong. Read Full Review
While this issue isn't without some good parts, it ultimately ends up incredibly disappointing as the majority of the issue is, once again, simply recapping the events that we already know. The most interesting part of this issue finishes with an off-panel fight scene that would have been much more interesting than the actual panel that we got which basically just looked at a clock while the sounds of battle happened elsewhere. I've given this book a lot of leeways but this issue I cannot hold back on. The good parts of this book do not even come close to outweighing or even balancing out the bad. Read Full Review
Batman #81 - like most of King's Batman run, especially the back half - is utter nonsense. I do not recommend it. Batman should be leading the comic book industry, and King's attempt has done anything but. Read Full Review
Game on ! Bane!
Another fantastic issue. Romita's art is hit or miss with me but the past two issues are masterful, kudos sir! King is moving the story forward while filling us in on the details of recent events. It all makes sense and has me engaged for what comes next.
Sweet jesus. I know people are expecting the climax soon, but how is this issue just a recap? It gave us mostly information we didn't previously know and could only speculate on. It is definitely convoluted as heck, but bitch... this ain't my first Metal Gear Solid 2.
It is definitely poorly constructed and written, but bitch... this ain't my first Metal Gear Solid 2.
If you thought this was tough to follow, we're not in the same class of people.
Not only did I not say I found it hard to follow, but being able to follow a comic book has nothing to do with class. Are you okay?
You're the one who brought up not being able to follow, like that is even in question. And if that is in question for you, then we're simply not on the same level.
Yeah, I'd break my legs from the fall if I got on your level.
Oh come on. I've managed to somewhat enjoy the recent issues, I've even loved JRJR's art last issue. But this is crap. Nothing actually happens here, nothing makes sense, and it looks like crap.
I think I'm probably in the 99th percentile of lovers of King's Batman but this issue was disappointing by every metric. Here's hoping King has 4 great issues left in him. The last couple have felt like steps backward.
Holy crap! I never expected to see a review like this from you. I’m so shocked that I’m legitimately sad that this disappointed you. Sorry man.
Worst Batman Rebirth issue to the date.
Come on King, you have 4 more issues left, you can't do a recap now, that's not the right time.
Even the little bit of progress we did get was unsatisfying because Bruce's plan doesn't make any sense. And on top of that, the art was underwhelming and boring to look at.
What a waste of time.
Okay first off let me start with saying I liked parts of Tom Kings run a lot and have disliked parts of it equally as much. This issue however just pissed me off. I didn't mind the " plan" to a point. Some of it was Batman-ish enough to believe he would do that. But seriously him allowing himself to be beaten by Bane to further along his plan to bring him down. Seriously!!! What if Bane had grew a pair and decided beating him wasn't enough this go around and just killed him instead? Are we the reader to assume he had a plan for that to? Or what if the "broken" back wasn't fixable and he was left unable to move? Then what was the so called "plan"? I'm sorry King but that whole Batman's - it was all according to my ''plan'' is just BULLS - - T !!!!! It would have been more believable if Bat had said I had planned this but this happened instead and I had to do this.... To have Batman make a mistake or admit a failing would be more realistic then this "plan" crap. I mean come on Batman is just a human male.
Moving on from the so called "plan" what really pissed me off the most was the hideous art work and the clock. WTF !!! What would have been the best part of the issue we don't get to see at all. Instead we get a clock over and over along side of snippets of the fight that are drawn so that you don't really know who's doing what to who. Also the dialogue written for it was incredibly lame and down right stupid. AND it makes us fans of the comic stupid as well because we paid 4$ to look at panels of a badly drawn clock!!! So F- you Tom King and John Romita Jr for giving us fans a trashy issue.
One last thing. If Bane made this venom that makes you so powerful why isn't Bane using it to make himself unbeatable?
All that being said as I am not nor have ever been a Bane fan I still say this is the BEST Bane story ever!!! There is hardly been any Bane in it. more
"You irrelevant old man"
I think that the next thing Tom King should tackle is the X-Men. To hell with Hickman, Tom King should write X-Men. His ability to tell a "story" without actually telling one is truly Uncanny.
Ok, now that we have this terrible joke out of the way, let's delve into the issue.
There isn't really much to delve into to be honest. It's the same old, same old. Telling a drawn out, paper-thin story and making an excuse that all that has happened was a part of the plan. Of course, sure it was. NOPE.
You can't just do things and then try to convince us that is was the plan all along, that it was a part of the bigger picture form the beginning.
But it gets even better. It turns out, that the sucker punching everyone around, that TK made Batman do so fondly, was actually Dark Knight's way to convey a super-secret-hush-hush-no-one-can-know message. I have to try that one day.
Tom King is really testing my mettle here. At this rate, I don't think I will make it to the issue #85. more
2.5 points for the art this time. It's about average thanks to a good deal of coloring work. I respect and admire JR Jr. for all his past work, but it's too squared these days and doesn't work as well with modern coloring. Also the art direction I this book is poor. Scenes of Batman and Catwoman are of them prowling. Scenes of the big "fight" are all off panel. And Bane, while looking like classic Bane at the end, looks nothing like he has for this entire run. 1 point for writing. Words were on the page in complete sentences this time, the characters got from point A to point B, and there was even some dramatic irony. But this plot is still the most contrived, dragged out, awful excuse for a mainstream superhero comic. Not only does it explain away everything from issue 50 on, but it makes every bit of story going back to issue 1 a waste. Gotham didn't know he was secretly buying Venom? Batman wanted to get lost in the desert? The bats have a punching language? Clayface is not only alive, but back and able to infiltrate Gotham as the Joker? All nonsense. Tom King pretends again that good storytelling is when you pull something out your rear end during the finale to explain away all the plot holes. The Gothams weren't on Venom in issues 1-6, we never knew how or why Batman was in the mountains after getting tossed in a desert pit, the bats don't have a mystical punching code language, the bats wouldn't be defeated by Thomas Wayne Batman, we still don't know how he's even in the universe or why he would align with Bane, and the world wouldn't sit back as Gotham is invaded by a foreign power. more
Does your heart race when you see JRJR's typically stunning depiction of Bane rising above the word "SHOWDOWN!"? Well don't you worry your nerves, it's a false alarm. This is just another issue of people meandering about explaining the plot to one another. Tom King's run might be ending sooner than was meant to, but it's definitely ending later than it should have.
So the slap was a message? Total bullshit! Last minute change due to people asking about the aftermath. Got way too much recap. Just an awful story.
“So you see Selina, that is when you and I went to a beach--” “Yes, I was there” “And we trained together--” “Yup I remember” “Do you mind? I’m trying to narrate for the audience, because this is too convoluted otherwise.”
Communicating through violence. I’m PRETTY sure Batman didn’t support this when it was done with Cassandra Cain so I doubt he’d adopt it with the rest of the family. An aged alcoholic alternate world Batman got the shit beat out of him and then magically, off panel, defeats the group of much younger and better trained fighters. Seems legit. Everything has actually been part of BATMAN’s plan now? Riiiiiiiight. With this writing, I honestly don’t know how King keeps getting work. Seriously. How did this guy get awards for this type of bullshit? The art was just bad. I like JrJr for the most part but his work here and on All Star Batman has been horrendous. The cover doesn’t look bad but the interiors suck. The best part of this issue is that it’s one more down until King is off this book. He’s made Bruce a pretty unredeemable character which is why he’s going to have to be replaced, again. Only 4 more to go. more
This is how King has Batman characters win. They get beat on and beat on, and once the attackers get all tuckered out from pummeling the victim, the victim then turns around, all bloody and beaten, and hits them once and they drop like a sack of potatoes.
Apparently, in King's world, there's not such thing as broken noses, concussions, internal bleeding , damaged backs, knees and hands. You just take a huge beating, walk it off and then hit someone once.
That's basically played out again in Batman 81. It turns out the Bat Family joins with Damian (may he rot in Hell) and beat and beat and beat Thomas Batman. He utters "because I'm Batman" and hits them once and they drop. King seems to have forgotten, or perhaps never knew, that Thomas Batman used guns because he wasn't in the super condition of Bruce. Didn't have the training and was an older man. Also, is Alfred dead? Still dead? That part of the plot is ignored and I'm bored with it.
But no matter, because King often ignores continuity or flat out repeats things other writers wrote beat for beat (Think Wonder Woman and Batman trapped in eternity. The same story was done in the 2000s for Superman and Wonder Woman.)
Bruce's plan was to steal the super Venom powering Gotham Girl. Joker was actually Clayface. (Yawn). And again we get a lot of text boxes explaining the text in an on the nose manner. Did subtext do something to King when he was a child?
And the issues ends with Bane, Bats and Cats getting ready to square off. The actual defeat of Bats' rogues was very rote. We, as I've written before, didn't see any Bats outthinking enemies or setting up traps, etc. We just get static shots of Bats and Cats hitting guys and they go down.
Just one problem. This has been done before 25 years ago. And the problem with Bane knowing Bruce's secret identity is never played to the logical conclusion. We know the bad guy is going to lose, so why doesn't he expose Bruce? Because if they did, the comic series would be over. That's ALWAYS a terrible thing, having a character act stupid because plot demands it. Stan Lee having the Green Goblin know but forget Peter's secret identity was genius. The threat was always there, but not really, but really. Great for building up suspense. Gerry Conway's Spider-Man 121-122 was the logical conclusion of that.
King's explaining Bruce's plan after the fact strikes me as a cheat. We sort of go, oh that's why he was in Hawaii. I prefer it when writers play fair and we see the heroes follow the clues the writers left and we say, wow I wish I thought of that. Well played sir. (See Murder on the Orient Express for why that works so well).
Overall, a dull issue. Can't say I loved John Romita Jr's art. This story doesn't do justice to the characters and just sort of happens because it has to happen. Can't say I'm a fan.
Or I could be wrong. more
Nice review! I agree so much with the idea of wanting the writer to play fair. It happened in Heroes in Crisis as well...King doesn't let you play along and then just drops info in your lap and when you go back expecting the Sixth Sense moments that you missed, they just aren't there! Plus, i may have to "borrow" that subtext line, so funny!!!
Just be sure to give me credit. It’s hard to think up original snarks. I am very proud of that one.
I've always loved JR Jr and his art. Especially when he was on ASM. But now it just doesn't seem right. It seems like he is not focusing as much in this, as he did in ASM. A New Ways to Die, ASM #600 all had better art than this. Maybe his style just doesn't fit Batman as well as it does on Spidey.
As for the rest of the issue. It was bad. Just no. All this being Bruce's big plan that has too much luck in it? Just no. I liked the idea of Bruce being broken better than Bruce planning this all. And Thomas taking all Batfamily? Just doesn't seem right. I can't see how 30 years older man could take them like Bruce would.
I just cannot understand anything anymore. Bane isn't nearly as much in this as I hoped. Thomas doesn't make sense. Bruce is being a god of deception again. Or god of foresee and I hate it.
Overall, a bad issue in almost every way. I hated Knightmares, but for different reasons. I'm not mad, just so disappointed, it is hard to feel any excitment anymore, what little I had for Knightfall 2.0. more
if you think you cannot understand anything anymore, King never understood any of it. this mess of a run truly feels like he went into this completely blind with NO plan. ...he's been phoning it in and coasting along on all the praise he gets from the 'Perfect 10' shills.
"No plan until you realize you have to give DC something so you make up some crap that makes it seem like it was all part of the plan" seems like the routine King went with this.
Probably the worst single issue of Batman I have read in the 8 years the book has been on my pull list.
I'm glad the art looked like a burnt bag of turds that someone had put out with a hammer, as it meant that I could zip through the issue in about 5 minutes (5 minutes I shall never get back, I might add!).
#85 can't come quickly enough.
Wait. I thought Catwoman standing Bruce up "broke" him? Now he says his brokenness was part of a master plan? So that means he proposed, knew he would get stood up, and even knowing that, let it "break" him? HUH???
Also, the "epiphany" Batman had about needing others to help him? The guy is in more groups (JLA, Outsiders) than anybody else, and he's been relying on his support family - only some of which are are shown in the splash page - for years. So that doesn't make any sense, either.
Then, of course, that entire support family just lingers on the sidelines while Flashpoint Batman has a gun cocked at Robin's head. What? Betting that this maniac wouldn't shoot? Not a safe bet, in my opinion.
So yes. This sucked. more
This is the THIRD issue of this type in this run. It was lazy every single time. The way you properly set up a twist like that is that you foreshadow it. You leave connections and clues. You don't just think it up, not bake it into the background of the story, and then at the end go "Aha! I'm so smart!" I don't understand how anyone could read this and think it's good. And, by the way, I called it. This is just I Am Suicide on a larger scale. The plans upon plans are so convoluted and ridiculous and circuitous. They don't make sense without a lot of luck and a lot of people doing things Batman THINKS they will do. Which is something you can't plan around. And even then, the explanation doesn't explain the plot holes that have formed.
Docking some points for that added on bit by Mitch Gerards to tie this into Year of the Villain. That's so obvious and stupid. more
Terrible issue. The writing is over complicated and convoluted. The plot is full of holes. I usually like JR JR art but his work here seems lazy. I don’t understand how Thomas Wayne can defeat the whole bat family alone ( including cass Cain). I guess I will never know since it is all off panel. For the first time in ten years I may drop Batman...
I'll be damned, I don't know what worse in this piece of filth of a comic - writing or art. It's bad on every considerable level, from the storytelling perspective, through dialogues, to sketches and inks. It's trash. Just trash.
Back when King started his Batman run, he created I Am Suicide arc - and as I said many times before, I like it, a lot in fact. The final plot twist, showing how Bat outsmarted Bane, was fun, surprising and somewhat fresh. Doing the same thing the second time simply doesn't work, and as much as King would like to build his story on similar themes returning multiple times, every now and then, it's, in the end, just tiresome and predictible. Tom King is not Noam Chomsky, who actually can get away with repeating certain facts like a broken record, to show how significant and interconnected they are.
On top of that, I'm sick and tired of everything interesting happening behind the courtains. Look how much filler King insterted in this trainwreck of a run, while he could have explored his investigation of Gotham Girl, and her connections to Bane. It surely sounds way better than having two issues dedicated to Bt banging the Cat in tropical paradise.
Now, the cherry on the top - art. Holy shit, this comic looks like an amateur hack job. I'm not a fan of Romita Jr. nor Janson, but both of them seem to had a bad day drawing these illustrations. Not only they're awful, they're also anything but dynamic, and I guess that's the main problem, since the issue is very action oriented. There's a lot of fighting, yet it all looks so still and motionless. Compare that to David Finch's outstanding job from the very beginning of Rebirth Batman. Yeah, this guy knew how to draw an action scene which feels dynamic.
My final verdict - avoid this dumpster fire like the Hot Topic face tattooed trailer trash abomination which is DCEU. more
i can't say i blame Romita or Janson. it must have been agonizingly painful to illustrate this cancer incarnate trash fire of a script.
May as well be. But personally I think it's still anything but good. Absolutely awful comic.
King has wasted every opportunity to explore the interesting characters in his run. He thinks it is deep to reiterate that Batman and Catwoman are soulmates. Gotham Girl? Not explored. Thomas Wayne Batman from a different universe? Not explained. Bane? Glossed over.
Yeah, absolutely. Shame, since he set up Gotham Girl as a key figure in the run, and then she appeared pretty much only in a terrible crossover with Flash, made out of literal scraps and leftovers. What a waste. Thomas, Bane and Selina as well weren't explored at all. Seems like bloody Kite Man has more depth than all of them combined at this point.
all excellent points Superheroes for Hire. i'm pretty sure Tom King had no idea what he was doing when he was put on Batman. he just rode the wave of hype and praise and let it go to his head. DC being the fools they are stuck him on the book another 50 issues. a decision that would bite them in the ass. at least someone was smart enough to cut this mess short. pity they couldn't do it sooner and save us this current arc. the series should have just ended with Batman kicking a tree.
I am not surprised Kite Man is better written, since Kite Man is a D villain therefore not explored much. King however didn’t know anything about Bruce, Selina, Bane etc.
Imo, the extreme praise he got when the Bat/Cat stuff hit changed the overall direction and then became a crutch when things went bad and then the downfall when the wedding didn't happen. If this issue doesn't show there was never an overall story plan, i don't know what does. Worst part, most of the stuff people hate were always there, it was just new and we were not used to it or annoyed by it yet.
He writes in such an ambiguous, let the reader fill in the blanks way that it's silly to think most of these things were a plan. It would be nice if any of yhese things were something you would go back and see clues that we just didn't recognize at the time, but sadly, that's not the case
i don't know how people praised this run so much in the beginning. i thought it was terrible after the very first issue. ... "i'M gOnNa HaVe To DiE iN oRdEr To SaVe EvErYoNe On ThE pLaNe. wOuLd MoThEr AnD FaThEr Be PrOuD?"
Weird Science Jim - it's so true that he used the Bat/Cat thing as a crutch after his run started nosediving. he's such a boob that he couldn't even get that right though. it's only fitting that this run end in such a disaster.
Lol...look back atvyhe first issue snd when Gotham Girl and Gotham save the plane, Batman says "Clark?" Even though Superman was dead at that point! I liked the first arc, actually, but have you ever seen a writer be so careless with their own character (Gotham Girl) or actuall seem to write them OOC? She is one of the few original things he did and has just messes her up!!!
no worries. my typing skills are bollocks, and i'm using a keyboard. - Now that you mention it, that always did strike me as weird that Batman said "Clark?" even though NewFiftyTwoperman had just died. - he really is so inconsistent with his writing. he can't even decide if he wants Batman to be a blubbering depressed crybaby, or an omniscient OP badass. King still never even gave a proper explanation as to Gotham Girl & Bro's powers, or Bane's motivation for going after Batman the way he is.
*Tom King's Bane* - "I WILL BREAK THE BATMAN!!!" . . . *Fans* - "Why is that, exactly?" . . . *Tom King's Bane* - "BECAUSE CHUCK DIXON'S KNIGHTFALL IS VERY POPULAR!!"
Darkseid24 - i know. i'm pretty Bane'd out myself. but just remember, Just like Tom King's Batman, this is not really Bane. ALL of these characters that King has been writing are just weird twisted & perverted versions of them. i say in all honesty that Tom King is the WORST Batman writer i have ever read. even WORSE than Neal Adams. and that's really saying something.
Agreed, but he is still not the worst for me. Nothing beats Darkseid War in crappy writing for me ( And hopefully never will). I hope Tynion is doing a little better. Didnt like his Detective Comics& B&RE also sucked.
Detective Comics has been going down lately as well, I'd say it's okay, but not much more. I didn't even feel like reviewing its last issue or two.
Nihilist - Agreed! I that damn bi-weekly deadline is burning Tomasi out. the quality is not consistant, and we've been getting a series of "good arc, bad arc..." and the overall quality has been steadily dwindling. I'm hard pressed to keep buying it, but my respect for Tomasi as a creator and as a person are the only reasons I really stay with this series.
Like I said Tomasi can be very mediocre. Happened before in Arkham War& in the Arkham Knight comics. Wouldnt blame the bi-weekly schedule, since other writers still deliver. DC overall just currently has only mediocre writers.
as far as i'm concerned, every writer that has been on the bi-weekly has been turning in S#%T stories. even the runs that started out good eventually turned into crap. ...but i do think that DC has been filling their ranks with more and more crap writers. Bendis, King... it's getting to the point where i just want to re-read back-issues.
Yeah, I agree. It's just big names they care about, not really paying attention to what they write. Look at DC Black Label - it' been a disaster, with most of the material being plain terrible, but hey, DC's gotta release something, anything, because they've created a mature brand, so it needs to be kept alive. And then the bi-weekly series, so the flagship properties are monetized, even if it hurts their reputation and quality in the long run...
I like majority of Black Label titles, but apart from the cursing nothing is in it, that justifies Black Label. Doug Moench wrote good stories& he wrote Detective Comics& Batman both for a while. So I think writers can, if they actually are talented enough.
T
Prelude:
King's Batman has been improving recently so here's hoping that trend continues.
The Good:
Nope. Nope. Nope.
The Bad:
WHAT THE ACTUAL ----!
Batman actively teaches his kids how to interpret his punches when he hits them? WTF!
God, this stinks of BatGod.
Art has dipped as well.
How can Thomas beat the Bat-Family here, let alone Orphan who is a BETTER FIGHTER THAN BRUCE HIMSELF! Thomas is roughly 60, he shouldn't be able to take actual trained vigilantes.
Dialogue was pretty poor, especially without knowing who was speaking.
Also what the hell is that Clayface twist?
Naked Harvey Bullock. Do I need to say more.
Conclusion:
Just as Batman was getting good again, King throws that all into the drain. more
no real progress in the story, this issue is pure tell don't show to try justify the messy plot, flashpoint batman vs the bat family makes no sense
When you have to publish an issue to explain the story in previous issues, it's pretty clear that you've lost focus and perspective in your own story. Just end the damn story already and start another story arc already...At this point I just want to read a two issue story about the Clock King.
at this point i'd rather read a two issue story about Bruce loading his utility belt supplies.
also looks like the "show don't tell" rule got down the toilet at this point i would rather read a story about alfred making tea
SnakeWilson - i'm with you on that one 100% ! ! ! ! ! ! ! . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . how i'd relish seeing Alfred go through the cupboards trying to find just the right flavor tea to brew up.
This is the worst issue of Batman I've ever read.
This is a legitimate waste of paper, ink, money, and most importantly, my time.
Fuck Morse code, now you can just punch people to convey a message. - Tom King the Scholar
No shock here....more garbage by Tom King! As I've said before, he can't leave this title soon enough. The art is also well below average, so this month the art can't even help the book at all.
Is this a joke?
The worst part of the book is that it got published. It feels rushed, the twist here is just incomprehensibly stupid and based on tons and tons of pure luck. But the worst part of it is that it clashes with the previous 20 or so issues.
It's hard to decide whether this or Heroes In Crisis is Tom King's lowest point.
What started as an interesting story ended up being filler after filler issue with ridiculous (even for a superhero comic book) plot and twists.
Tom King is a talented writer. But Batman is definitely not a book that shows his talent.
At this point, I cannot say Tom King is a talented writer. I never read Sheriff of Babylon, and I only read through issue 6 of Vision (I had no background with the character). But Omega Men was the only thing I've read of his that had a coherent story. Batman has been all over the place, but has trended to garbage. And Mister Miracle was garbage disguised as philosophy. There is no plot, no resolution, no continuity, no morality, no purpose. Just B.S. philosophy, a suicide, and an open ending.
Miracle Man is the most over-praised, over-hyped book in the last forty years.
oh for pete's sake!!!
the painfully obvious back-peddaling that this issue starts with
just proves that Tom King had NO plan of what the heck he's doing.
King never bothered to read Flashpoint to learn that Thomas Wayne uses his guns
to make up for the fact that he lacks the years of training that Bruce had.
Tim Drake's lack of reflex skills was just LAUGHABLE!!!
King made Batman & the Bat-family into just as big a dope that he himself is!
this is seriously EMBARRASSING!!!! Tom King, have you NO shame?? beyond pathetic.
along with awful writing, even the art was phoned in.
Putting King on this book has been a blunder of epic proportions. It is clear that the man does not know what he's doing.
The problem was leaving him on this book. DC should have pulled him from the book 50 issues ago and let someone else pick up all the dangling plot lines. It's not like King is doing well with tying any of it together.
i'd go as far to say that he should have never been put on as high profile a book as Batman. he just never bother to do any real research into the characters nor did he set up some sort of plan what to to with this run. it's felt like he's been just making this SH%$ up as he goes, and digging himself a deeper and deeper hole. he's still never bother to answer many of the questions that were brought up early on. with the amount of filler in this run, it's obvious he has no answers. he's a hack.
Or minus 1
I've been very supportive of Tom King which was a mistake. I dropped Heroes In Crisis but kept buying his Batman. Supporting him. This is the issue where it's obvious that the writer doesn't care, the editor doesn't care, the artist doesn't care.
Nobody cares but they still ask for our money. Huge plot holes covered with cringy excuses and dialogue.
I get it that Tom King is angry or sad that he was fired from Batman but he could at least try and wrap up his story. A story readers have invested time and money.
But he doesn't.
It's disappointing. Whatever King's problem with DC is it's not worth disappointing his fans like this. I'm still a huge fan of his previous work but this is the point I have to say goodbye to his books. I won't be checking Batman/Catwoman either. more
© 2025
