Tyler Davis's Comic Reviews

Reviewer For: Comic Watch Reviews: 172
8.1Avg. Review Rating

The Spectacular Spider-Men #1 is a fluffy and warm blanket that fills a vacancy in the current landscape of Spider-Man by simply trying to do nothing more than tell a grounded Spider-Man set in the 616 without any need for forced melodrama or shock-tactic writing. In many ways, it feels like Marvel has an answer to DC's World's Finest, the future of this title shining bright as one that can offer both comforting and challenging Spider-Man stories for years to come.

View Issue       View Full Review

While Ultimate X-Men would maybe be more well-suited for the title Ultimate New Mutants, it is in that bold declaration of difference the book shines as an honest yet still spiritually faithful reinvention of Marvel's mutant world.

View Issue       View Full Review

Superman #11 us a rush job paving the way towards The House of Braniac, a sad but rare issue in this run that sacrifices quality for the sake of speed and schedule.

View Issue       View Full Review

Miles Morales: Spider-Man#16 is action-packed and pureblooded fun, Ziglar's writing just strong enough allow Frederico Vincentini's art to steal the show.

View Issue       View Full Review

Ultimate Black Panther#1 is the familiar yet fresh take T'Challa and the Kingdom of Wakanda have been in desperate need of for the last three years. With so much potential brimming on the book's future, this is a must-read for anyone even considering jumping into Marvel's new Ultimate Universe.

View Issue       View Full Review

Overall, Red Hood: The Hill#0 lacks a sense of excitement or thematic weight in the current comic book climate, not offering much interms of artistic relevancy but what it does do is establish the potential greatness of what's to come from Shawn Martinbrough and company going into the rest of the upcoming mini-series.

View Issue       View Full Review

Avengers Inc.#5 is a safe, warm, and satisfying finale that will be sure to grow smiles on the faces of those longing for the forgotten pits of Avengers history to become relevant once more. However, outside of pleasing those with aforementioned connections to the material that inspired this series, I can't sayAvengers Inc.has much impact or value with its lack of emotional or thematic resonance.

View Issue       View Full Review

Overall,Avengers: Twilight#2 is moving forward at an underwhelming pace with just enough alternate universe spunk to keep the title interesting as it begins to drown under its heavy but underserved thematic core.

View Issue       View Full Review

Batman: Off-World #3 is a lesson in character-driven plot momentum, the penultimate chapter in this mini-series rich with detailed art and a healthy tonal mix. Whether or not the series will have been set-up for a perfect landing we shall wait to find out.

View Issue       View Full Review

Green Arrow #8 is a classic example of clever writing serving nothing but a boring plot as a subversion of expectation, while executed with grace, leads the book down a road that is monumentally less compelling than the potential of what was subverted.

View Issue       View Full Review

Avengers Twilight #1 is familiar yet grand, a perfect example of how pristine craftsmanship in both writing and art can be a little undeserved by a lack of conceptual boldness. However, what is setup is promising, the overall power of this story laying in the hands of what's to come as opposed to what's on display here.

View Issue       View Full Review

Green Lantern: War Journal #5 continues the first arc with some lumpy pacing that, for the most part, doesn't take away from the building climax this issue has setup. With what seems to be an excellent finale on the horizon with so much left in store for the series down the line, Johnson's writing continues to excel technically even the overall 'fit for trade' plotting could use some compression.

View Issue       View Full Review

Daredevil: Gang War #2 is not as strong as the first issue from a character standpoint, but it's titillating action and robust combination of 90's flair with a modern approach to pacing keeps the book moving and a continually engaging pace. This book continues to stand out as the shining gem of Gang War, and while it begins to tie more heavily into the event in this issue, it does so in a way that keeps the story at hand still a solid enough solo story for Elektra.

View Issue       View Full Review

Giant-Size Spider-Man#1 is anything but giant-sized, unless you count the price which fails to accurately reflect the book's actual value. With half of the issue being a reprint of material that's readily available in so many forms, then the totally average-sized main story needed to have more of impact, whether in plot or artistry, than it does for this issue to be a hard recommendation for anyone other than completionists.

View Issue       View Full Review

With a laser focus, Miles Morales: Spider-Man #15 manages to feel like the thrilling climax to Ziglar's entire run thus far without even trying to. It's exciting, tying up loose emotional ends whilst elevating the weakest part of the run thus far by playing all of those recent discordant notes together in a pure symphony of exciting superhero drama. It's a book that oozes classic Marvel style whilst maintaining a cutting modern voice.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Amazing Spider-Man#40 is a surprising glimmer of light in the dark, one that manages to maintain the momentum ofGang Warand even give it the stakes, no matter how schlocky they may be, that the event was missing at it's start.

View Issue       View Full Review

Daredevil: Gang War#1 is a strong tie-in that doubles as an equally strong Elektra story. Erica Schultz impresses here with her interpretation of Elektra, this series filling the gap between the current main Daredevil run and the role of Hell's Kitchen withinGang Warwith grace. Strong, character-driven storytelling overall wins this issue a glowing reccomendation, even if you aren't following the main event. I hope Schultz gets to continue on writing Elektra after this event, as Marvel may have just found the character's next great stewardess.

View Issue       View Full Review

Dark X-Men#5 is a relatively weak finale to an otherwise brilliant story. With an underlying acceptance on the repeated cycles of human nature, the uneasy and solemn final pages of this series seem out of character for what the book had been ramping up to say, but maybe that's just the nature of things. Regardless, I'm very excited to see where Madelyne Pryor goes next, hopefully with Steve Foxe still at the helm.

View Issue       View Full Review

Regardless of some reductive characterizations, Miles Morales: Spider-Man#13 continues to prove how versatile Ziglar and Vicentini are as events continue to plague their run. With beyond exhilarating visuals and writing that manages to balance the book's core story with the event's necessary threads, as far as I'm concerned, this is still the best Spidey book on the stands right now.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Amazing Spider-Man#39 falls further into feeling like a cheap grab for cash, it's story riddled with so many odd holes and lackluster moments of character writing that it's a shame something this unfinished is being billed as a top event for Marvel.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Amazing Spider-Man Gang War: First Strike#1 is weightless. It falls into comic shops with the velocity of feather on the wind, it's lack of proper story and character set up reeking of an editorialized idea meant to nickel and dime stores, readers, and creatives out of their souls as yet another nostalgia play infests the publishing line. While there's a chance that the creatives on this event can salvage what's here, it seems thatGang Waris simply dead on arrival.

View Issue       View Full Review

Local Man#7 continues "The Dry Season" story with a creative yet tad over extended second chapter that feels as though the team is letting loose on the side of fun without forgetting it's grounded tone. The back up in this issue is especially great, helping to enrich Farmington and Inga's backstories all the more.

View Issue       View Full Review

Miles Morales: Spider-Man#12 is a fine close to an out of place, if servicable fun story that reads as a filling stop gap to get the book's publishing schedule in line for this month's upcoming Gang Warevent. Hopefully the book finds itself in a place of substance after this, as the book's recent five month lull has taken a signifgant amount of energy out of the title.

View Issue       View Full Review

Kill Your Darlings #3 is joyous yet emotionally raw. So much character is packed into one book that it's a miracle it isn't an overstuffed mess, but instead a dare I say perfect comic with pacing, writing, and art deserving of award.

View Issue       View Full Review

Lunar Lodge#1 may not have enough going for it in its first issue to be a solidified must read, but what is here is promising. The book will at the very least get by on atmosphere and tone as its most engaging aspects all rely on the silent trust between writer and artist.

View Issue       View Full Review

Batman Off-Worldisn't just an entertaining and atmospheric comic, it's one that clearly understands the necessity of pulpy science fiction in an age of where corporate art is becoming extremely homogenous. With the edge of Rocksteady's Arkham Batman and a ferocious commitment to its science fiction ideas, Jason Aaron and Doug Mahnke have crafted a comic well worth checking out.

View Issue       View Full Review

While it isn't the most satisfying series finale,Red Goblin#10 is still a pretty strong ending to the title, one that provides an open-ended promise that this isn't the last we will see of Normie in the modern day. While niche and underserved, this series has been one of Marvel's best this year and something all superhero comics should strive to be: Engaging, exciting, and driven by human character.

View Issue       View Full Review

Dark X-Men#4 is filled with tension, atmosphere, and delicate character writing that brings a sharp edge to the themes and story of this series without bloating out its very limited page count with filler. Foxe and Scharf deserve to see this team grow beyond just a mini-series within the Fall of X.

View Issue       View Full Review

Captain Marvel#1 blips by at a rockets pace, kicking off Carol's new run with an exciting yet shallow story that excels in action, but leaves room to be desired when it comes to world and character building. However, there is a lot of headroom for those latter narrative weaknesses to become stronger as Wong and Bazaldua's run continues. Longtime fans of not just Carol, but Genis-Vell will get something extra out of this debut issue that shows how the team plans to play with the titles long history.

View Issue       View Full Review

X-Men#28 is full of plot and enough character work to keep the ongoing 'Fall of X' interesting within the main title, but the book's role as a tentpole servicer of 'things happening' is enough to bloat it's readability as a work of narrative fiction into something that feels less creative, and more mandatory. While the likes ofUncanny Spider-ManandDark X-Menget to explore the interesting themes and ideas this line wide event asks, the main title gets to be nothing more than a documentation of things needed to push the event along without being a true story itself.

View Issue       View Full Review

Spider-Boy#1 lacks enough oomph or voice to truly sparkle as a brand-new Marvel title, however, those in its target audience will surely find Slott's mix of classical pulp-horror and young reader tropes charming enough to continue reading.

View Issue       View Full Review

Giant Robot Hellboy#1 doesn't feel like the start of something serialized, but instead the first chunk of something that will sit better with reader's once it can be read in its totality. That being said, this issue is still worth ago in a monthly format, the beautiful designed interiors, cover art, and flow of intrigue Mignola brings to the plot is more than enough to guarantee a great time.

View Issue       View Full Review

It's more of the same from this run at a technical level, and no matter how fun and well-written Rek-Rap is, can't distract from the fact that this series is spiraling down a drain of disjointed and unsubstantiated storytelling that can't focus on a theme, tie up an arc, or tell a story that feels natural.

View Issue       View Full Review

Kill Your Darlings#2 zigs were one would expect it to zag, moving the plot forward in such a way that's both natural for the book's pace yet still unexpected and surprising. Bob Quinn's art grows more impressive with each issue of this series released, a sharp yet hyper expressive flow to the characters elevating an already rich story.

View Issue       View Full Review

Local Man#6 marks a creative shift for the series that really, really works. It builds upon the cultural ideas explored through heroism within small-town America by re-framing the series' current arc into one about superstitions and the disruption seen within Farmington when the dominoes of conspiracy begin to fall. This brings about rising drama, juicy tensions, and a continued sense of realism that is more honest than it is edgy.

View Issue       View Full Review

X-Men #27is a stepping stone issue that progresses little details down the pipeline, sampling some fun character dynamics and setting up bigger plot beats to come. In that regard, it's a standard chapter in a larger saga that will prove essential to the logistics of whatever 'Fall of X' culminates with, but on its own is just fine. However, it's held back significantly by the art's lack of visually interesting paneling or strong line work. This is a still a fun read, but one that lacks the visual oomph needed to elevate it.

View Issue       View Full Review

Dark X-Men #2is written with such richness that it's disappointing to see the evidently passionate work of Steve Foxe& Jonas Scharfbe constrained to a mini-series within the Fall of X. Both beautiful and thrilling, there isn't a Marvel team book quite like out right now.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Amazing Spider-Man #34is a great comic book, displaying sound writing and intense artwork to craft a story that's both incredibly entertaining yet thematically rich with a more-nuanced than usual take on redemption within the pages of this title.

View Issue       View Full Review

Local Man: Goldhas all the hallmarks of a great comics' story, leaning a little more into the 'fun' and boldness of it's inspirations for an special that's way more comedic and focused on entertainment than the main series has been thus far. It's definitely worth a read, even if you haven't been keeping up with the series.

View Issue       View Full Review

Black Panther #3 is all buildup with very little payoff, laying the groundwork for an explosive follow up in the next issue with Deathlok, political consequences, and exciting action. However, what is here drags significantly, and as its own issue doesn't stand well on its own. Even as the piece of a larger puzzle, this issue is boring at its worst, and plot-driven at best.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Amazing Spider-Man #32is the beginning of something extremely compelling, kicking off the next big arc in this series with a bang. Gleason brings the necessary amount of tonal finesse visually that Wells' has desperately needed since the end of his work onThe Amazing Spider-Man: Beyond. They're a match made for one another, and this issue is proof of how some comics live and die by the symbiosis of their creators' respective roles.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Invincible Iron Man #9is an engrossing read. With such an epic story building, it's astonishing that Gerry Duggan and Juan Frigeri have kept up this building momentum in such a calculated and engaging way. This is a definite must read for Iron Man fans, as well as those swept up in the Fall of X.

View Issue       View Full Review

Marvel Unleashed #1is one of many reoccurring attempts at bringing back the animal-driven narrative trope made popular eons ago, and may just be one of the best. With incredibly comedic writing and a great showing of comic book technique in both the writing and art, this debut issue is a great debut for both young and new readers alike.

View Issue       View Full Review

Overall,Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #142 is the same amount of grit and quality but at an expedited pace, lessening the impact and satisfaction of multiple story beats which is a shame as many of the ideas on display would have otherwise been excellent.

View Issue       View Full Review

Kaya #10 is penultimate bridge issue that introduces and builds up last minute yet needed ideas into this arc in order to bring its conclusion to a satisfying and explosive finish. With some of the best art and panelling this series has seen to date, this issue does not disappoint.

View Issue       View Full Review

Red Goblin#7 continues to mix forgotten parts of the Spider-Man mythos with a new, youthful main protagonist that is effortlessly plotted with depth, tension, and impressive character work backed up by strong art.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Savage Strength of Starstorm #3is a mixed bag of fun and flatness. When Craig is focused on building out his characters, the book is wondrous. When that crosses paths with the larger epic building silently in the background, the book's lack of balance can feel omnipresent and diminishing.

View Issue       View Full Review

Ghost Rider #17 is a great second chapter to this infernal crossover between Blaze and Logan, backed up by incredibly well-realized paneling and art that simply slaps. With only two issues left in the story however, the story is on shaky ground as to whether or not it will be paced well enough on what the story has set up.

View Issue       View Full Review

Spider-Man #11is an average superhero comic, with strong sequencing and character writing. However, it's better aspects relying on one's interest in Spider-Boy to have any vested reason to read the finale to this somewhat needless Spider-Man title.

View Issue       View Full Review

Final Order Cut Off for this book is September 9th, 2023, with an expected release date of October 18th, 2023!

View Issue       View Full Review

Kill Your Darlings #1is shocking on the first read, intriguing on the second, and desperately human from cover to cover. Alongside industry veteran Robert Quinn, Ethan S. Parker & Griffin Sheridan have debuted their first comics work on one of the biggest independent stages possible with roaring success.

View Issue       View Full Review

Miles Morales: Spider-Man #9 walks a tightrope in terms of narrative balancing, and does so with grace. This issue further cements Miles Morales' book as Marvel's most premier and highest-quality title with a Spider to grace its cover.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Amazing Spider-Man #31has a lot going on, and as a set of stories don't offer much interms of satisfying themes, but continues to make shortsighted promises that may turn into something great, but as the record shows, promises from this title will unlikely become anything worthwhile.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Amazing Spider-Man Annual #1features solid enough characterization, but fails to have any sort of impact both in its narrative, art, or any form of character work. It serves its purpose as filler entertainment, but it has nothing going for it outside of that aside from the development of more weird and uninteresting plot lines for Mary Jane.

View Issue       View Full Review

Knight Terrors: Green Lantern #2 is a perfectly entertaining and fun comic, filled with some interesting character beats and great art that works well to holdover readers as they await the main Green Lantern series to kick back up again after the line wide Knight Terrors event.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Schlub #1is a blast of fresh air into the superhero comics scene that it oh so desperately needs. With fantastic art and moments of genuine comedy, readers are in store for a exciting ride.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Invincible Iron Man #8is a really great comic, tying into the wider Marvel Universe in ways that signify the book's importance, while not losing it's main star amidst a slow but well done integration into the "Fall of X." Overall, this continues to be Duggan's strongest Marvel title on the stands with high flying action and great art.

View Issue       View Full Review

City Boy #3 is plagued by pacing issues but counter-balanced by raw character ideas and moments of excellent character writing.

View Issue       View Full Review

While it only has 36 pages to explore its ideas, there is something engaging about the ideas on display in What If...? Dark: Venom #1,even if they are mired in an over the top edginess that fails to deliver on the poignancy of themes that could have otherwise been really strong.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Amazing Spider-Man #30is just another Spider-Man story, scrambling strong story setup and the potential for a small scale and psychology personal story for Peter Parker in exchange for goofs, gaffs, and unearned emotional resonance that held little to no other prior importance.

View Issue       View Full Review

Crusader #1 is intelligently constructed and highly entertaining. This first issue kicks off with well-established character dynamics and grisly action all dressed up in an art style that manages to be both charmingly cartoonish and atmospheric.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Incredible Hulk #2is a moody next step for what continues to be an inspired and atmospheric return to form for Earth's angriest monster. The team continues to deliver on their promise of horror and grit, grounding the series in a rich sense of loneliness, tension, and desperation.

View Issue       View Full Review

Knight Terrors: Angel Breaker #1is and was always going to be the odd man out in terms of Knight Terrorstie-ins. It ties together some minor DC stories from the past year, working to help pepper the growing legacy of the relatively new Angel Breaker with some more stories to call her own. However, it has to play things safe and sound, leaving the overall book seem needless in the grand scheme of both this event and the ongoingDawn of DC, something this creative team should've been integral to from the get go.

View Issue       View Full Review

Sonic The Hedgehog #62isn't going to blow anyone's socks off, but it's light and loose storytelling fun makes it a good book to pick up whether or not your a fan of the source material. With a promising 'B' building in the background, this works as a good base for the rest of this mini-arc to build off of.

View Issue       View Full Review

While it misses out on effectively continuing the setup of last issues cliffhanger, Teenage Mutant NinjaTurtles #141is still a solid issue in it's own right, effectively moving the story forward while shining a more specific light on the Turtles growing divide.

View Issue       View Full Review

Hellboy in Love #5 sputters to an end with a tight but very anti-climatic conclusion to a series that shows more promise as an ongoing than it does a mini-series. Overall, the series was very strong and this lackluster ending doesn't take away from the near-perfection seen in other issues.

View Issue       View Full Review

Panya: The Mummy's Curse #1has a solid setting and okay arc, but fails to draw readers into it's world thanks to a generic take on mythology and main character who's too passive and lacking in personality to carry the rest of the book.

View Issue       View Full Review

Savage Squad 6 #1 isn't particularly interesting, but it's not particularly bad either. It's a pretty bland setup issue that lays the groundwork for a tight and compelling story to potential out sprout from the book's all too generic seeds.

View Issue       View Full Review

This year's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Annual is a light and overpriced read. While not a poor book, it overall lacks a story with enough depth or craftsmanship to justify its $3.00 price jump. All things considered however, the character it introduces here lays the groundwork for something interesting to come.

View Issue       View Full Review

Fishflies #1is beautifully illustrated and well-realized, but is better fit for a trade paperback than it is as work of serialized fiction. Those who like Lemire's work will know this and enjoy it for what it is, but many will overlook the genuine craftsmanship on display due to its wonky pacing.

View Issue       View Full Review

Miles Morales: Spider-Man #8is a nice change of pace for the title, giving more room to Miles' life outside of Spider-Man after two arcs back to back arcs of blistering intensity. It's nice to see Hobgoblin finding a place where he can be interesting again, as well as Ziglar's voice for the villain. Overall, Miles continues to soar as the top Spider-Man book.

View Issue       View Full Review

Red Goblin #6 is the setup towards an arc of growth for Normie, as he comes to understand exactly how and his demons affect those around him, especially Rascal. While it may not be the most exciting issue of this series so far in terms of massive developments, it lays the groundwork for well for heights that could possibly reach higher than the books stellar first arc.

View Issue       View Full Review

With Ed McGuinness and Marcio Manyz delivering their strongest work thus far on the series, The Amazing Spider-Man #29is an undeniably fun issue that plants some interesting and potentially exciting seeds for the title.

View Issue       View Full Review

Sirens of the City #1is brash, dingy, and beautiful, wearing its thematic heart on its sleeve with honesty. With a healthy mix of character driven writing and plot heavy world-building, this issue manages to both tell an entertaining, atmospheric, and message heavy story all on the first go.

View Issue       View Full Review

Swan Songs #1is beautifully realized in a painterly style, combining simple writing with an environmentally atmospheric setting to create a comic book that goes above and beyond what its 24 pages should be capable of.

View Issue       View Full Review

IfSpider-Man #1ohad been focused more on telling a tense story in the moment rather than working to squeeze Marvel's latest obtuse and lazy legacy rebranding, it could have been a relatively strong Spidey story. Instead what you'll read here is something fun but wasteful.

View Issue       View Full Review

Kaya #9 is an excellent middle chapter, utilizing strong pacing and natural narrative twists in order to continue the momentum of this massive second arc, not a second becoming dull or overdrawn.

View Issue       View Full Review

Brynmore #1is surprisingly light on plot or details, the promise of its ominous narrative lying within its vague ideas, stunning art, and the trust many readers will have in Steve Niles due to his past work.

View Issue       View Full Review

Good Deeds #2 sows the seeds of horror, softly laying a growing tension through human action and reaction in an all too believable horror tale about small-town life.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Oddly Pedestrian Life of Christopher Chaos #1 stands tall as an engaging opening to a story rife with whimsy and charm. It contains enough narrative richness within its moments of open table setting to act as both an excellent standalone tale, as well as the first chapter in an expectedly great series.

View Issue       View Full Review

This book is not for everyone, but in its niche kernels of genius is something that'll satisfy readers of old school indie comics. While definitely rough at the finer seams, it's overall a relatively fun and breezy book.

View Issue       View Full Review

There's a brave and methodical slowness toGood Deeds #1that gives the book so much time to develop it's characters, plot, and tension in a way that never allows the reader to disengage from the narrative. Tempting and terror-ridden, this is a great indie horror comic that's striving to put its character's first and foremost.

View Issue       View Full Review

Spider-Man: Fake Redis powerful, earnest, and a true to form Spider-Man tale that has so much to say about the power of superheroes as symbols for anyone in the world who may be facing any sort of struggle. Whether it's a personal sense of aimlessness or a fear of being one's true self, this expertly penned tale reminds use of what Spider-Man truly represents for readers, something that's been somewhat lost in the fluff of modern day nihilism.

View Issue       View Full Review

Thor #35was up against a set of unfair circumstances, and didn't manage to rise above them and be something worthwhile.

View Issue       View Full Review

Xino #1 is a super fun and visually engaging anthology series with a ton of varied tales that really characterize and explore the capabilities of science fiction in a punk rock fashion.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Amazing Spider-Man #28is a step towards the light, delivering an unproblematic but wholly vapid story that is sure to be building towards something, but as of right now is simple surface level 'fun'.

View Issue       View Full Review

Hellboy and The B.P.R.D.: 1957 - Fearful Symmetry #1 is a painfully boring and visually drab comic book that's existence can't even be justified by originality, as it lacks any notion of inspiration or artistic care.

View Issue       View Full Review

With an origin story now solidified for our Local Man, the future has never been brighter for this series to tackle even more exciting stories and really human conundrums that promise to continue the series' unconventional approach to superheroes.

View Issue       View Full Review

Vanish #8is a surprisingly quiet ending to the first major story arc from this title. Dark and concerning,this book was completely unafraid to revel in and condemn its at times messy representations of trauma, addiction, and human cowardice when facing those things down. The at times lopsided messaging can be concerning at times, but thanks to the strong plotting, character writing, and brilliant artwork, the book manages to end off with excitement and promise.

View Issue       View Full Review

While rushed, City Boy #2takes all the character setup from last issue and pushes forward on the the plot to root book deeper within the DC Comics mythos, expanding the series' scope far beyond what many expected it to be.

View Issue       View Full Review

Tales of Syzpense #1is an interesting anthology, combining classical comic book stories and abstract sequential storytelling. It is definite recommendation if there's room on the pull list for it, but it certainly isn't a book for everyone. However, the people who would enjoy it will really enjoy it, as it in many ways is an artistic masterclass in its attempted oddity.

View Issue       View Full Review

Cult of Carnage: Misery #2is another solid, character focused entry into this mini-series that is way better than it has any right being. Marvel's Symbiotic stories have never been stronger, and Misery is right up there alongside Red Goblin as yet another sleeper hit for the company.

View Issue       View Full Review

Guardians of the Galaxy #3is the runs first clunker, the team attempting to say something socially whilst forgetting that doing so poignantly would require an actual story to unfold. This issue isn't awful, and will read better when done so in a binge-like fashion, but it's unforgivably boring.

View Issue       View Full Review

Haunt You To The End #1is a great beginning to a series with the potential to truly satisfy on the sensations of fear and deeply human character work the best of the genre can offer. All the pieces are here wrapped up beautifully with the book's visuals, but only time will tell whether this book will manage to amaze.

View Issue       View Full Review

I Am Iron Man #4makes a bold choice in how it reflects and celebrates the 2000's era of Tony Stark, but it's a choice that pays off. The team here explores every facet of Tony, whether or not those facets are pretty or ugly, and does so with an expertise understanding as to how one should explore a character's darker corners while avoiding outright vilification.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Incredible Hulk #1isn't a perfect comic book but in it's best moments, of which there are many, it's an exciting and horrific start to the Hulk's next great foray into the world of Marvel Horror.

View Issue       View Full Review

Miles Morales #7is the best kind of popcorn action comic. It's got big action and big heart, peppering its quick pace with illustrations drenched in adrenaline. While the stories gone on a little too long,Carnage Reignshas served to be a great visit upon the best of 90's extremism, and Miles getting his time to shine with it has been nothing short of fun.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Amazing Spider-Manis a yawning man's comic, a mixed bag of setups and wrap ups that ultimately makes for a reading expressed only with a shrug. This could be fine, or it could be more of the same mechanically broken storytelling.

View Issue       View Full Review

Wolverine #34is the victim of its own pacing. Overall, theBeast Agenda/Weapons of Xmega arc has taken every possible step it could to drag out its story, whether it be in writing style or general plotting. While it doesn't hurt the moment to moment reading of this story, it has created a sense of repetition and fatigue within the pages of it's own story, this issue suffering the most as it's entire plot becomes one big circle that keeps the characters at the exact same point they started this book in. Are the moment to moment writing beats good? Sure, but the overall package comes down to being simple trade filler.

View Issue       View Full Review

Narrative dysfunction, while super prominent and somewhat disruptive of the main narrative at hand, isn't enough to take away from Pakndel's skill as a writer. While this issue doesn't hit the highs of those that came before, as piece in a larger puzzle, it keeps up the momentum of both Carnage ReignsandRed Goblinenough to keep either from faltering fully in the face of a crossover.

View Issue       View Full Review

Spider-Man #9 is a continued return to familarity, but not quite form. Hidden within the nostalgic writing and visual stylings of Dan Slott and Mark Bagley is a fun, down to earth Spidey tale that hits on well-missed characters notes in a particularly strong and conceited way.

View Issue       View Full Review

Local Manis one of the best superhero books on the market, hands down. This issue really cements that, utilizing superhero actions and thematic character philosophy to craft a truly deep, engaging, and rich reading experience.

View Issue       View Full Review

Kaya #8proves to be another solid chapter in a series that reads much better in chunks than it does issue by issue. Overall series pacing aside, the book is still as artisan as it could possibly be, Craig putting out a masterclass in fantasy comic storytelling that's perfect for people of all ages.

View Issue       View Full Review

All in all,Vanish #7is just more. More plot, more great art, and more of the same great story that is building ever closer to its moment of climax.

View Issue       View Full Review

With great characterization, solid heart, and natural connection to the DCU,City Boy #1is the start of something really great. Thus, with the debut of this issue, DC'sWe Are Legendsimprint goes three for three with their titles in terms of quality.

View Issue       View Full Review

Monomyth #1 has the craft, premise, and characters behind it to take off sprinting as one of this year's most well-made fantasy comics. The team exercises so much skillful and mechanical artistry alongside a very creative blending of worlds that demands nothing but praise. There's a true symbiosis between writer and artist at hand here that happens rarely, and I cannot recommend this book more.

View Issue       View Full Review

With strong writing and visual storytelling, Miss Truesdale and the Fall of Hyperboreais another solid hit for the Hellboy team.

View Issue       View Full Review

As an epilogue to Normie's first stint as the Red Goblin, this issue succeeds in defining the marching orders going forward for Normie as a hero. While light on plot both for this story and the stories to come, it's a nice bow on the end of a strong first arc that will come to forever define the character.

View Issue       View Full Review

Guardians of the Galaxy #2has a lot more to do and say than the first issue, making it a potentially stronger hook for those teetering after a good, albeit thin, first issue. Without the need for the setup, the writing duo has the ability to enrich and flesh out the team, giving them a few more shades of required depth under this creative team.

View Issue       View Full Review

With a little bit of humanity and a splash of one's twisted, depressed imagination,Ice Cream Man #35 makes for a tale that on first go is engaging and thought provoking, but on a second will have you stopping to consider its well-laid themes of near disturbing importance.

View Issue       View Full Review

Not even a crossover can grind Cody Ziglar and Frederico Vicentini to halt. Because the book is allowed to remain a smaller story with true weight for our characters and not a tie-in/variant farm,Miles Morales: Spider-Man #6works as both the next chapter in Miles' story and a story with the effort of an event.

View Issue       View Full Review

Excellent in every way,Superman #4is proof that Joshua Williamson & Jamal Campbell's work on this title isn't just a happy accident. It's concrete excellence.

View Issue       View Full Review

Clear stands as a monument to the emotional and artistic power of comics. In many ways, it is both Scott Snyder and Francis Manapul's best work.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Amazing Spider-Man#25isn't offensive because of its story decisions, but because of how plain and boring it is. The Spidey team has nothing to say with this story, leaving it as just a poorly paced history lesson to explain why the team wanted to circumvent the previous status quo to tell the same old stories we've been seeing for years.

View Issue       View Full Review

I Am Iron Mancontinues to be an excellent and loving anthology series rife with both celebrations and vivid explorations of the Iron Man mythos. This issue stands out as the most story rich, but not necessarily the most thematically deep. However, that trade off makes for an issue with more relatable emotional impact.

View Issue       View Full Review

There isn't much to dig into withSpider-Man 2099: Dark Genesis #2is fun to look at and conceptually interesting enough to read through. It feels as though Orlando really wants to be writing a Midnight Suns 2099 book, and the book suffers for it. Lacking a central character to follow and feel the thematic importance of the story through is necessary for crafting something that's more then just pulp, and that's the best way to describe this series. Fun, needless, science fiction pulp.

View Issue       View Full Review

With more focus, Orlando could potentially turn his love for 2099 into something a little more organized, exciting, and better written. Bringing in more 2099 versions of fan favorite characters is a promising reason to keep reading.

View Issue       View Full Review

While it doesn't grind to halt, Wolverine #33 suffers from the overdrawn plotting of this massive Beast Agenda story arc quite a bit. While the book still wears some of Percy's finer hallmarks with the character, you can feel just how tired this book has become.

View Issue       View Full Review

Marvel's been on their A game as of late when it comes to the magical side of their universe, andScarlet Witchis no exception. Head back to issue one and do some catch up, as this issue is the beautiful cocktail magic of comics in a nutshell. Popcorn excitement, human themes, and beautiful writing have all come together to deliver a book that never fails to impress.

View Issue       View Full Review

Cult of Carnage: Misery #1is a great debut for Liz Allen's new status quo. While it may pose as a difficult jumping on point for readers unfamiliar with her history, that doesn't change the fact that this book has strong emotional and genre themes coupled by great art and greater action.

View Issue       View Full Review

Spider-Man #8may have well been the true start to this secondary Spidey title. It's full of classical Marvel heart and fun that keeps a human heart directly at its center. Its restraint in penning a simple story make it such a quality comic, characters and themes matter more than shock and nostalgia.

View Issue       View Full Review

Overall, KAYA #7 continues the series with a really strong foot forward. While the previous arc had been visually astounding with a really strong sense of character archetype, design, and immersion within its world, it lacked in both narrative and character depth. However, due to the plot setup this new arc presents, the series holds with it the potential to marry its visual storytelling expertise with plotting and character work of equal strength.

View Issue       View Full Review

Overall, Local Man #3 is a densely rich issue with a lot to say about its main character, but doesn't stop the book's momentum as each instance of conversation, comedy, or characterization manages to still progress the story forward. Masterful, but and happily slow in its execution, this series has been one of the biggest source of consistent quality on the stands this year.

View Issue       View Full Review

Vanish #6 is a fantastically well-done issue that is both important to the overall series, as well as pretty damn good in its own right. Everyone is bringing straight heat on this title, delivering one of the best marriages between superheros and dark fantasy ever seen.

View Issue       View Full Review

Visually astounding and intelligently plotted, CLOBBERIN' TIME #2 follows up on the perfection of the last issue with the same level of quality, but with more focus on building an overarching story.

View Issue       View Full Review

Action Comics continues to be a top shelf book, what more could one say? Action, emotional stakes, great art, and even greater characters. Check it out!

View Issue       View Full Review

The opening issue to Williamson's Green Arrow run sets up an intriguing plot line, wasting no time in setting up a legacy-rich status quo. However, in that rush, the book loses its hooks and impact. It's not a Green Arrow book built off of a bonafide Green Arrow story, but instead one directly intertwined with the future of DC. It's the beginning of a run that lacks anything deeper at a plot level than fan service and plot promise, but nonetheless, with time it could go somewhere very interesting. With time, this first issue rush could be rectified, but as it stands now, this book is a jumbled mess.

View Issue       View Full Review

This series only continues to get better, and is Marvel's most underrated title on the stands. Every month it brings with it narrative and character quality over anything else. It uses the symbiote gimmick for both strong introspection and over-top, heart-pounding violence. Don't miss out on this book.

View Issue       View Full Review

Tim Seeley has put his Marvel chops on display,CAPTAIN AMERICA: UNFORGIVEN #1a treasure trove of fantastic characterization and continuity. While it's plot may lose steam, there's still a lot here to be appreciated.

View Issue       View Full Review

THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #24is far from a good comic, but it's moving the plot along enough, with fine character moments and well-paced visual storytelling, that it's difficult to completely kick the book down. It's the definition of a mixed bag.

View Issue       View Full Review

SUPERMAN #3is a masterclass in pacing and compressed comics writing, fitting so much in without the book feeling rushed. While rife with teases, the book never loses focus of the story it's in. Williamson continues his excellent characterization of Superman's world as Jamal Campbell only grows even stronger as a premier Superman artist. This issue asks to take a leap of faith with Clark into this new era of Superman that is both familiar and completely alien to the readership, and it's a jump worth taking.

View Issue       View Full Review

Overall,ARCADE KINGS #1is an explosive blast of energy that will surely make for this year's standout summer read. With heavy arcade and eastern influences, everything in this book radiates off the page with infectious, positive vibes.

View Issue       View Full Review

Nocterra #13 is a necessary read for fans of this series, and is wholly entrenched in it's mythos. What it doesn't have in story here, it makes up for in grand reveals.

View Issue       View Full Review

With the introduction of Grootfall that only raises more questions and a new, hard-boiled tone, I've never been more interested in what was going to happen next for the Guardians of the Galaxy. This is also a good jumping on point, so check it out if space-westerns are your thing.

View Issue       View Full Review

This issue is the epitome of what Superhero comics should be at a base line. Exciting action. great character work, and bombastic art have all fused together to create a hard-hitting debut arc for Cody Ziglar's run on Miles Morales.

View Issue       View Full Review

Blood Tree remains a consistently well-made series of pulp mystery fiction, pacing itself out with this issue being the one straddled with moving the needle forward. Still good, but missing some of the character themes and work within the last two issues.

View Issue       View Full Review

I AM IRON MAN #2is an unconventional yet magical approach to understanding, dissecting, and exploring Tony Stark and his mythos. Managing both whimsy and philosophical seriousness, I cannot recommend this book to Shellhead fans more than I already have.

View Issue       View Full Review

This issue is boring, poorly thought out, and beyond contrived. Even in Spidey's worst publication periods, at least something exciting, whether it be grand reveals or true storytelling was at least happening. Maybe the stories were offensively bad at times, but at least they were stories. Here, you're paying 3.99 for a bag of air that contains everything you already knew.

View Issue       View Full Review

Spider-Man #7is exactly what one should expect it to be. Dan Slott has brought his epic to an exhaustive, bland, to an end as Mark Bagley's pencils gasp for air underneath all the clutter of superfluous spider-people and heartless action. From here, the title can only go up, and for everyone's sake, it desperately has to.

View Issue       View Full Review

HELLBOY IN LOVE #4 offers up the best representation of what this universe of stories can be. It's an entertaining read that utilizes the medium to its strengths with some fantastic art and coloring. If you haven't already dove into this mini-series, now is the time as its first two acts have been completed, leaving you awaiting what is hopefully a tight finish.

View Issue       View Full Review

LADY BALTIMORE: THE DREAM OF IKELOS #1is a poster child for near perfection in comic book construction. While the plot may be somewhat underwhelming due to its length, the team still manages to pen a narrative with enough narrative substance and weighted themes to craft a story still worth reading.

View Issue       View Full Review

Overall, this issue is just a plain ol' action-horror romp that plays well with Marvel history and genre tropes to craft a fine, inoffensive story sure to tickle the fancy of genre fans. The team has a strong understanding as to how a story like this needs to be devised, keeping the narrative fixed, tight, and true to the voices of every character.

View Issue       View Full Review

At the end of the day, this book is a schlocky mess of fun action, well-written dialogue, and some piss poor narrative work.Going forward, VENOM: LETHAL PROTECTORhas a lot of work ahead of itself if it wants to keep readers onboard.

View Issue       View Full Review

SABRETOOTH & THE EXILES #5is a lukewarm finale that, given its previous issues, finds its footing with an unsatisfying barrage of convenience and future setup. At the very least, the series is competently written and well-drawn, so it's far from the worst comic in existence, but does hang its hat on some of the worst modern comic finale tropes.

View Issue       View Full Review

ACTION COMICS #1053is representative of what the best superhero comics in the modern day can be. Its narrative, a blend of plot decompression and precise character storytelling, is rife with deep themes that lay just under the surface of beautiful art and bombastic superhero action.

View Issue       View Full Review

If you're a lapsed Marvel reader, or just looking for a simple book that manages both beautiful art and brilliant simplicity with it's storytelling, I couldn't recommend this issue more.

View Issue       View Full Review

At its core, Local Man has been growing into a deeply human series that explores identity in the fly over states by way of 90's superhero tropes, an unexpected yet completely genius premise.

View Issue       View Full Review

SPIDER-MAN: THE LOST HUNT #5is a solid trip down memory lane that does some interesting things with its characters with a thematic plot that, sadly, holds zero weight on it's own thanks to it's instantaneous invalidation by future stories.

View Issue       View Full Review

X-Treme X-Men #4is classical X-Men suspense done right. Choked with action and great character moments, this issue rectifies some of the pacing shenanigans in previous issues for an all around great time.

View Issue       View Full Review

THE NEIGHBORS #1is a promising start to what may wind up being one of the most haunting horror comics this year from Boom Studios. With a folk-horror hook and its contemporary themes, this issue is just the right mix of uneasy and endearing needed to enrapture readers everywhere.

View Issue       View Full Review

VANISH #5 is the return of Ryan Stegman & Donny Cates' new age superhero fantasy, continuing the story that started in issue #1 more so than paving the way forward with a new arc. However, this issue is the best so far with a gripping pace and narrative that concludes sharply with a worthwhile cliffhanger.

View Issue       View Full Review

All in all,WASP #3offers an interesting insight into what a modern day Wasp should be viewed as, tying up some loose story lines just before the final chapter begins. It's a perfectly safe series for Wasp fans, and if you aren't onboard yet you definitely should be now.

View Issue       View Full Review

The Last Barbarians #2is good ol' fashioned sword & sorcery fun. In a comics market devoid of classical fantasy comics, it does scratch, but fails to stand out with this issue. It's a fine read, but nothing you haven't seen before.

View Issue       View Full Review

While NOCTERRA #12 undercuts its potential character drama for the sake of plot, everything turns out solid in the end as Scott Snyder continues to prove himself as a master of momentous and exciting narratives that fall nowhere short of pulse-pounding.

View Issue       View Full Review

MILES MORALES: SPIDER-MAN #4is a well-done setup chapter for what's to come in the finale forTrial By Spider. Ziglar and Vicenti continue to deliver exciting and plot-rich superhero comics that are bolstering up Miles and his world.

View Issue       View Full Review

It is one of the best books the Spider-Man world has to offer right now, and deserves every morsel of attention and praise it receives.

View Issue       View Full Review

BLOOD TREE #2continues to grow as high-tier pulp fiction. The plot moves at a quick pace balanced out by character exploration done neatly. While it may feel a little basic and bare in its execution, it's a classical serial killer mystery that is sure to tickle fans of the genre's fancy.

View Issue       View Full Review

Its safe to say thatCLEAR #1is nothing short of excellent, a story that not only nails style with its visual flair and writing choices, but brings something new to the table with an overarching them of expatriation.

View Issue       View Full Review

While KOSHCHEI IN HELL#3 might be a Hellboy Universe book following up on and wrapping up plot lines from previous series, it itself still has a lot to say about the nature of a mythological figure and their unending life of pain and battle. Excellently written with outstanding artwork, Mignola and his team continue to be one of the best in comics to date.

View Issue       View Full Review

CASTLE FULL OF BLACKBIRDSis a grab bag of well-mixed ideas executed in a page count too small for what it needed. While not offensively bad, I can recommend it only to Hellboy Universe completionists, as to anyone else it'll lack the substance or atmosphere many come to narrative fiction for.

View Issue       View Full Review

Is it yet another retread of the Spider-Clone concept? Sure, but I think the style and tone being brought to the table gives SPIDER-GWEN: SHADOW CLONES #1just enough oomph to remain an enjoyable and light read.

View Issue       View Full Review

COSMIC GHOST RIDER #1is a promising start to a new Marvel ongoing that promises mystery and the ever enticing setting of a 'Western Space Opera'. However, it is skimpy on character history details that may be difficult for any new readers jumping into the character for the first time.

View Issue       View Full Review

While the ride for this story has been entertaining and without any major contradictions, its existence and lack of anything meaningful to say seriously drags it down. SPIDER-MAN #6 at the very least brings the ride towards the finish line in a way that is completely fine, but offers nothing of note or particular excitement to be yet another book that won't matter in a few months.

View Issue       View Full Review

I AM IRON MAN #1is the earnest start to honest celebration of Tony Stark that isn't attempting to appropriate and regurgitate stories of the past. With their own narrative stepped deeply within the eras of Tony and an art style that idealizes the character, its a validating showcase of why Iron Man has room to still be a compelling hero in 2023.

View Issue       View Full Review

Phillip Kennedy Johnson continues to execute emotionally grounded, action packed, and well-constructed Superman stories of heroism, pain, and family in near perfection.Action Comics #1052 is another fantastic step forward for the Dawn of DC, living up to the promise of new stories reminiscent of the old, but a step forward into a DC Universe with new interpretations and fresh ways of telling stories.

View Issue       View Full Review

Gods Against Groo #3 is a smart slice of comedic social commentary that struggles to find a character or plot worth caring for. Whether this be a victim of its Sunday strip tone or the nature of Groo as a character, there is still a lot to be enjoyed about this series. For fans who desire an older, newstrip style book, this might be the closest you'll get on the spinner rack.

View Issue       View Full Review

Great for both young and ageing readers,SPIDER-MEN: DOUBLE TROUBLE#4 makes for a consistent wrap up to this well-illustrated series. For those wishing superhero comics were a little more whimsical, and that their Spider-Man comics were a little more classic, than trying out this series might be the break if fresh air you've been looking for.

View Issue       View Full Review

Like those before me at Comic Watch have said, it's become increasingly difficult to take any critical shot at our boy in red. Hellboy in Love is a good series for readers old and new alike. This issue was a blast to read, and an absolute recommendation for all.

View Issue       View Full Review

If you have extra room for new books this week, this is a definite pick up.

View Issue       View Full Review

Local Man has set itself up with a main character under the lens of earnest exploration with a murder mystery brewing in the background that has left me hungering for what comes next. Fans of what Image once was and fans of what Image have become will both find something to love within the pages of this brand new series.

View Issue       View Full Review

LaVelle, as a writer, had struggled in previous issues to balance out all the characters within this book, but as we cross the finish line, he's found his footing. An excellent job has been done balancing entertainment with commentary, and we've been set up for a stellar conclusion. Not only is issue #4 the best so far, but it has me looking forward to the next in a way I hadn't before.

View Issue       View Full Review

Overall, this issue doesn't re-contextualize the rest of the mini-series in a way that would have me yelling from my soapbox to go back and pickup the previous two issues. However, for fans of Monica Rambeau who may have been hesitant about picking up this book, I can strongly recommend it on the character front alone. Whatever I may find disengaging about the story's structure, Ewing does have such an excellent way of presenting Monica and her struggles that I will continue reading the book until its end.

View Issue       View Full Review

Reviews for the Week of...

November

October

More