-
10
I absolutely loved everything about this! As usual with Tynion I loved the writing and this book was a joy to look at the artwork is beautiful
-
10
Very good start and I really liked Tom King's run too
-
10
Yes. Tynion finally gets to take control of Batman
-
9.5
I enjoyed this issue of Batman for the most part. I didn't totally like the art. This artist tends to draw people a bit oddly. Their features lean more on the side of cartoon-ish rather then real life. But other then that I liked it. It touched on Alfred's loss without being to much in it. I enjoyed seeing Catwoman/Selena being a major player in Bruce's life still. It's a interesting twist in the story that this seems to going to be a plan she had a part in to bring Bruce/Batman down. In the past Batman has had some of his secret plans played out by villains. Both in his comics and a few times in the Justice League comics. This time it's going to be one of Selena's plans. I hope this is not going to lead to the down fall of them being together. I'm so so sick of that card being played out with them.
One thing that did confuse me though is that Selina is known to be Catwoman by the authorities and world which was why they were going to have that secret wedding to begin with. So no one would put Selina/Catwoman together with Bruce Wayne being Batman. Yet here she is openly showing ties to Bruce Wayne to the Mayor no less. So is she no longer a wanted criminal now? And is it now no longer known to the world that she is Catwoman? I wish it wasn't and also that Batman's identity was less known to so many people as well. Now it seems like just about all his villains know Bruce Wayne is Batman.
The one problem I had with the issue was this ridiculous idea that Bruce could make his city into a safe heaven where Batman is no longer needed. That is not a possibility on any level. What do you think if Wayne built enough buildings and what not that the criminals are going to take one look an say Gotham is to bright, new and shiny to mess with and just move out of the city never to bother it again?
Also I really would have like more of the fight with Deathstroke shown. more
-
9.0
Thank goodness Tom King is finally gone. It's great to have a good Batman comic again. This one was good and I'm looking forward to more.
-
9.0
I originally gave this an 8, but I changed my score upon a second reading. MUCH much better the second time around. I'm very interested about this mysterious new "design" for Gotham City and how the assassins in this issue tie into that design. Tynion delivers a formulaic, albeit entertaining opening and I can't wait to see where he goes from here. I followed his Detective Comic run from beginning to end and I loved it. So I'm excited to see what direction he takes this story.
-
9.0
A promising start with an interesting set-up and some wonderful action scenes.
I liked how Tynion didn't just ignore King's run and that we can see how Alfred's death affects Batman. I'm also pleased to see that Selina is still a major supporting character.
Another thing that I enjoyed was the epilogue. I really like how Tynion is setting up the Joker. I hope this will pay off.
Tony Daniel did an excellent job as usual and I hope that we'll see more of him in the future.
Overall, this issue was a solid start to the run. I'm interested to see what Tynion has in store for us. Hopefully, it will be good.
-
9.0
Prelude:
King's 85 issue Batman run is now over. After three and a half years of King, let's see how Tynion's Batman goes.
The Good:
I like the idea of Bruce using Alfred's death as a motivation to improve Gotham.
It feels like a Batman book.
It's good seeing how tactical smart Bruce is but also how he is still reeling from City of Bane.
Selina's part of the story was interesting.
Tony S. Daniel's art was great.
The Bad:
Nothing.
Conclusion:
Nothing too revolutionary but it didn't need to be. It's getting the main Batman book back to being just that and Tynion has done a great job so far.
-
8.5
I completely skipped the last part of King's run as I was literally falling asleep. But this, this looks fun!
-
8.5
Good start with the new creative team.
-
8.5
A very promising start
-
8.5
" You have a design for Gotham City, Master Bruce. Isn't it time the world saw it ? "
- BATMAN
-
8.5
Gorgeous art by Tony Daniel. The writing is solid and the story is mostly set-up for what's to come. Selina looks stunning in that dress and I love the panel where Deathstroke is being pulled through the wall. There's a nod to Nolan's Dark Knight in the Joker scene at the end.
Overall, it felt like an issue of Batman. And. The lines. Of dialog. Were not. Written by Tom King. Thank the Maker! I am looking forward to seeing where Tynion takes us with his run on the title.
-
8.0
Solid, intriguing book with fantastic art.
Feels great just to be reading a proper issue of Batman again, now that everyone's favourite divisive 'auteur' has been herded away to finish off his Bat/Cat fiasco under DC's Black Label.
-
8.0
Solid start
-
8.0
This ain't bad at all, and I'm definitely sure that this story will be liked by a lot more people than King's stuff was.
-
8.0
It feels very plain after Tom King's run, but I still dig it.
-
8.0
Finally, a Batman comic with Daniel's great art that has good writing???
I've been waiting for this. It is a good start, and I've always liked how Tynion handled Bruce.
But I'm a bit skeptical. I liked King's first 30 issues too, and hated the last 30 issues.
-
8.0
It's a hell of a lot better than Tom King's trash run.
-
7.5
Tynion iyi bir başlangıç yaptı. City of Bane bittiği içinde mutluyum bir yandan. Gerçekten çok kötüydü. Tom King'in hakkını da yemek istemiyorum. Sonuçta kaç sayıdır Batman yazıyor. İyi veya kötü Batman'e bir şeyler kattı. Tynion ise gayet iyi bir başlangıç yaptı dediğim gibi. Bana kalırsa sayı oldukça hızlı başladı ve oldukça hızlı ilerledi. Diyalogları ise beğendim. Tynion, biraz daha mutlu olmaya çalışan ve Batman'e ihtiyaç duymayan bir Gotham için çalışan bir Batman tasviri sunuyor. Eksik bulduğum ufak taraflarına rağmen beğendimi söyleyebilirim.
-
7.5
I didn’t love this as much as I expected (hoped?) but I also didn’t hate it, which is a great improvement.
-
7.5
Hopefully start of something good
-
7.5
I havent read a Batman issue since #50 as I just couldnt take Tom King anymore. I got this issue and it was definitely a step up. It laid the ground work and ill be back for the next issue.
-
7.5
This was a pretty good first issue. A godsend after Tom King, but not all that exciting on its own. I don't know, hopefully it will pick up next issue. I was excited for this one, so maybe my expectations were too high. Also, ironically, the Joker tease in this issue makes me less excited than last issue's tease. Guess that shows how fickle I am about the character.
This was an insignificant glimmer of absolute "meh" in the world where arson burned down Australia, corruption bleeds into the Amazonia and Iran can't hit anything except the send button on a sheepish declaration of even-stevens. At least we'll have moderately okay comics to tide us over while the world continues to spin on its ever-boring axis.
Wink-wink.
-
7.5
"I believe"
Tony Daniel certainly knows how to open an issue. Along with Miki's inks and Morey's excellent colors, he can make something great. That opening double-page spread is truly amazing. The rain, the lights, Gotham's skyline in the background... Yeah, the art in this issue is top-notch.
Thankfully, the story doesn't fall short either. Tynion proved before in Detective Comics that he can write a nice Batman. It might be considered a tad narration heavy, but it's the hero narrating rather than some omniscient narrator, which is the way I prefer. The story itself is that someone is planning something big and this someone is the Joker, who takes a page right out of Heath Ledger's Joker book.
Batman here is smart, brooding, precise and basically seems to be the smartest guy in the city. It's been a while since we saw that in this book.
It's been a few months since I've given a rating like this in this book. Definitely worth checking out, now that King's reign of terror is over. more
-
7.5
A good Batman comic? Could it be?! Well, considering it's Tynion who took over the series, I expected nothing less, but still, I was afraid Tom King's awfulness preceeding this new run could affect it more, dragging it down. That didn't happen for the most part, naturally not including Alfred's death, which up to this point, has been just pointless, it was merely shock for the sake of shock.
Tynion, in comparison, just laid down everything important, set up the big mystery, and even more. That's what we call a plan, which can't be said about King's nonsensical gibberish with no purpose and endgoal. Whether it's a good plan or not, time will tell, but at least there's something we can follow now.
The art is beautiful, once again, not surprising, since DC wants to sell this flagship comic, and attract those who turned their backs on King's run. Good art sure is a good selling point, and this issue truly is something you could analyze for hours, focusing on every little detail.
What I enjoy is how Catwoman and Lucius Fox play bigger roles in the adventure, from the get go. Tynion undertands that Batman can be monotonus as a character, and needs company. People who would be more than cannon fodder to get killed off/shot in the head, or to appear only when a deus ex machina magical knife is needed. He did that already with Rebirth's Detective Comics series, establishing a team and giving each member purpose. I hope this continues, and we'll see Bruce developing some fleshed out relationships in this new era of Batman comics. Well, that's a glimmer of hope, at least, in the world where half of Australia and Amazonia are in flames, and the US government oes anything in it power to start world war 3 with Iran, so the current president gets re-elected. At least we won't experience all this horror without decent comics to read. more
-
7.0
This was just fine. It's as by the numbers as you can get for a new run, and it also doesn't help that tynion is writing and we got a Batman run from him in detective that ended just a little more than a year ago. The art is fantastic, and that saves the issue for me since I was finding myself bored with the plot throughout.
-
7.0
Standard Tynion nothing Great, but passable. Only problem is that The end rehashes count of owls.
-
6.5
Rome wasn't built in a day, and course corrections after 85 issues and 3 years don't happen in one month. That said, James Tynion takes a thematic broom to the Bat-world of Tom King and starts over.
The book is the opening stanza of a longer (presumably 15 or so issues, culminating with issue 100) arc. As such, you can't read a ton into it. But it's a strong statement of purpose, suggesting a Batman that will be operating on a number of fronts both as Bruce Wayne and as Batman, using every tool (some yet to be created) and person at his disposal. The villains are varied and colorful.. And the future - through Lucius Fox, father of presumed 5G Batman Luke Fox - is foreshadowed.
I've read Batman in its various incarnations on and off over 40-ish years. Truthfully, the character is over-exposed and has been written and rewritten every possible way. Batman sells comics, however, so DC will whip that horse until the end of time. Tynion's Batman doesn't represent anything NEW or DIFFERENT than what I've seen from so many writers previously...no, it instead delivers a familiar, classic, accessible Batman that readers surely will enjoy. Well, at least the ones not wrapped up in King's mind games melodrama.
Artwork fits the writing...very strong, especially with the cityscape shots and Batman figures. I wasn't as thrilled with the human character imagery in the Selina Kyle scene, but I've also seen so much worse. (The artist can draw hands and feet!)
If you've been away from Batman for whatever reason, this is an excellent jumping on point. Tynion has set the course for a Batman book that will be above average at minimum. If the story develops as it could, this could be something special. more
-
5.5
Standard fill-in stuff. Don't use Deathstroke like that.
-
5.5
It was ok, but not great. At least Tynion is writing dialogue, that actually is readable. However I hate, that Catwoman is still a part of the story. She is just pointless. Deathstroke was beaten pretty fast by Batman & while I don’t really think Deathstroke to be an interesting villain, he shouldn’t be beaten so easily. The D Villains in this issue also were pretty boring& I am wondering, why they were even in it. I liked the Bruce missing Alfred part, but I still hate, that DC actually goes through with his death. So overall it’s an ok issue, but nothing outstanding.
-
5.0
There’s nothing bad, but there’s nothing that makes it good either. What should have been an exciting start to the first new run on the title since Rebirth started is just another mediocre Batman comic.
-
5.0
What to say, what to say? The art is good. Tynion definately is taking the book in a new direction, but is it really a new direction? We see Bruce at Bats being ever so dedicated to fighting crime that he neglects his guests at a Wayne Enterprise event. That's not new.
We see him fighting an unnamed evil organization with a secret goal. That's not new. We see Selina acting at "Mrs." Wayne at said event and still looking at shiny objects with lust. Could be interesting. She loves Bruce and wants to help Gotham, but she's still, at heart, a thief. Has potential if done right, but it's a tricky road to walk.
Some point I bring up that could be exploited, but the writer will probably miss. The mayor says that thanks to Bruce's efforts Gotham is a boom town again, growing faster than any other American city and how did Bruce push his agenda to build a new campus through the city government so quickly?
We don't know and that's a good question. Is Bruce actually being as corrupt as the people he fights pushing his agenda? Did he bribe people, make promises that are "iffy"? We don't know and I hope Tynion explores this idea - that in the end Bruce is as corrupt in his own way as others. Democracy must be run democratically and not by an oligarch.
Bruce calls Lucius Alfred by mistake, so that shows he misses Alfred. So do I. He'll be back, but I do believe having a black CEO of a billion dollar company act as the servant of a rich white man is just bad optics. Also, running a billion dollar company is time consuming. Lucius has better things to do.
But the art was really good. I liked Selina's slightly off-modal haircut. There's a lot of potential here to be good and be bad and just hit notes that have been hit in other stories. Hence the rating of 5. I will wait and see.
Or I could be wrong. more
-
5.0
I was expecting this issues for a long time. Unfortunately Batman still fails to deliver. This is a bread and butter issue, nothing really exciting. No strong points. It's definitely better than King's emptiness but for it's price it's not good value for money. I'll give it three more issues but if things don't drastically change to the better, I think this will be my goodbye to the book till the next writer.
I don't blame Tynion. The book was burned to the ground by King and he has to rebuild everything. But I don't have the time or patience to follow it.
-
3.0
Very bland.
-
3.0
THE GOOD:
-Good art. Daniel did not disappoint, for me at least.
-The epilogue was the only interesting part for me, and it was basically the opening scene of the Dark Knight.
THE BAD:
-Maybe it's because it's been so long since I read a Batman comic, but I was not interested in this at all.
-I've always been opposed to Tynion's writing. This issue was no different.
-The mercenaries were interested, but the fact that they were shrugged off so easily was disappointing.
-Man, Lucius and Batman have almost no chemistry.
-Wow. They just threw Deathstroke right in there, huh?
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
9.5
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
6.0
-
6.0
-
6.0
-
1.0