Tree Fingers's Profile

Joined: Jun 17, 2015

Filter By:
8.5
Overall Rating

For once I agree with the haters. Shameless cash grab. I wish Bendis would admit it.

regret buying it. At least I know what series not to waste my money on in the future. Ill give it 4 for some good art.

Pretty pointless issue. Bobby is learning how to be himself, we get the point; did we need a whole issue of him flirting with randos???....uh no

Crazy that even in her own book Carol's character is being thrown under the bus. That said,I enjoy the focus on Alpha Flight. Give them their own book and get them out of this runaway train. Also where is Anka?

Somehow I enjoyed the 0 issue, but not this one. All of the story elements were rather contrived and the art wasn't enough to save it. Nice covers at least.

I do like Superior Octopus. But.... After Slott has built this story for the last few years, it really has never paid off, we have this Peter who isn't comfortable in his own skin (or suit) anymore, and what? now the whole payoff of Parker Industries is it's going to be torn down in a tie-in book? At least Superior Spider-man was worth the journey, this is just blerghh..when can we get back to a good story with some emotional weight and investment? ....despite having some fun action scenes. I have no problem with Dan Slott. Just look at the Silver Surfer books, they are heart wrenching right now. When can we get that here, Dan?!

This book started out so great and then civil war just destroyed it and her character. Alpha Flight has been great but I wont be continuing with the Mighty Captain Marvel.

Not an interesting tie in so far. Despite some voluptuous art. I think I will drop this book at least until civil war is over.

6.0
 All-New All-Different Avengers #8 Apr 20, 2016

I am probably one of the few that enjoys the clone storylines but introducing a virus is pretty damn lame!

Ugh the price. Cant, in good conscience, give it a high rating, despite some promising developments and art.

Get on with it already... Another kinda one-off/set up adventure, that kept referencing things I didnt read from the Annual and Venom inc, that I don't care about, as if they were trying to give relevance to the random plot points. Cool to finally see MJ and Peter trying to work things out, hopefully a sign of things to come, and not just wiped out by the new writer(s). If I had to guess, judging from Dan Slott's basic ambivalence towards the MJ relationship for most of his run, I would hope that Marvel told him to put MJ in to set up things to come in the next arcs. The art was OK, except for MJs face, unless Hawthorne was trying to make it look like she had really bad cosmetic surgery, if in which case total success! Ok, done, my ranty/mean review. ...Oh wait no Im not!.. LMAO off all the speculators buying multiple issues of this and then trying to sell them for $15-20 on ebay, when it still doesnt have the first app of the Goblin/Carnage hybrid. Maybe they should have read it first....smh.
6.0
 Civil War II: X-Men #4 Oct 15, 2016

Not very intriguing. Also wish it were more mature. Seems like a missed opportunity. Great cover though.

I always enjoy my time with Bendis' Guardians...but this book had no plot whatsoever...blablabla who's side should we take mixed in with some Rocket wisdom and jokes.

Civil war 2 blaaa

Wait, why doesn't Rocket like Spider-Man so much as to not want to ever return to earth? Cause he called him a Racoon?

Great art and style. Fun character. Super weak story that doesn't grab me at all.

First Inhumans book I've ever read. Didn't grab me.

started good, then jarring artist change like 5 pages in, and weak shoe-horned ending. How did she defeat the phoenix? She talked it down saying she needs to be given the chance to live, blablabla. I mean it was still an OK issue, just such a weak resolution. The interaction between Logan and Jean was A+ though.
6.0
 Spider-Island (2015) #5 Oct 12, 2015

Strangely weak issue

I'm a big starkat fan, but this 3 issue second arc offered nothing. A story any of us could have thought up and if anything I'm less excited about the couple's future now that I've seen how boring they can be. I hope the main GoG books builds on the relationship where this one did nothing other than leave them where they already were (albeit not engaged)

What happened to the beauty? :'( 2nd arc seems to have very little to do with the disease at all, which I thought was the driving force of the story. 2nd arc is not living up to the 1st, which I loved so much. IF they have a third arc I hope they forget about this arc and build off the first.

6.0
 The Clone Conspiracy #5 Feb 21, 2017
6.0
 Uncanny X-Men (2016) #13 Oct 16, 2016

dropping... I mean its not baaaad, but I could be spending my money on so much better comics. Ill just stick with extraordinary and drop the other x-titles.

Kitty's such a playa lol
6.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #26 Apr 29, 2017

Very unbelievable motivations. But the art is great. I also like how Bendis features the characters he writes in other books.

Im conflicted with whether or not to continue with this series. Pros: great art, Chewbacca!, Imperials will be coming next issue. Cons: weak supporting cast, mediocre plot, 5 issues is really stretching it for this story so far. Well I'll decide in 2 weeks if my money is better spent on something else...

What did you 3.0 reviewers expect from an adaptation??

Waiting for a hook and something original...

Not sold on the title yet. Was good enough to keep me for at least 1 more though. The end confrontation was pretty cool.
7.0
 All-New X-Men (2015) #5 Feb 27, 2016
7.0
 All-New X-Men (2015) #11 Aug 4, 2016
7.0
 Civil War II: X-Men #1 Jun 18, 2016

At least theres action
7.0
 Generations (2017): Miles Morales Spider-Man & Peter Parker Spider-Man #1 Sep 27, 2017
7.0
 International Iron Man #1 Mar 16, 2016

What you expect for $5 #0 issue.
7.0
 Marvel Two-In-One (2017) #10 Sep 26, 2018
7.0
 Star Wars: Darth Vader #9 Sep 11, 2015
7.0
 Star Wars: Darth Vader #12 Nov 15, 2015
7.0
 X-Men '92 #1 Jul 1, 2015
7.0
 Years of Future Past #2 Jul 1, 2015

Picked it up to give it a try, but didn't hook me.
7.5
 All-New All-Different Avengers #9 May 16, 2016
7.5
 All-New Wolverine #5 Feb 15, 2016
7.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #1.1 Dec 19, 2015
7.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #6 Jan 6, 2016
7.5
 Amazing Spider-Man: Renew Your Vows #4 Aug 19, 2015

Well written and drawn but getting bored s of the same ethical discussion over and over again (across the Marvel U, not just this book)

OK, I think we've all accepted that the premise of this story is fucking stupid and the character motivations are extremely unbelievable. That said, this issue provided strong emotional interactions between the characters that was somewhat satisfying. And the artwork is mind-blowingly good. I feel safe giving this individual issue a 7.5. Might've even given it an 8 if not for the inflated price.
7.5
 Civil War II: X-Men #2 Jul 7, 2016
7.5
 Extraordinary X-Men #13 Aug 28, 2016
7.5
 Invincible Iron Man (2015) #7 Mar 4, 2016
7.5
 Invincible Iron Man (2015) #10 Jun 1, 2016
7.5
 Invincible Iron Man (2015) #14 Oct 21, 2016

Hmmm to add to pull list or drop, that is the question...still undecided at this point. No plot is set up in this issue, it's just a little back story and intro of Tony's role, wish there was more to convince me.

Love it, but super short, filler issue.
7.5
 Silk (2015) #17 Feb 21, 2017

Still like the event. But i won't be adding this to my pull list thereafter.

Was waiting to see MJ the whole time lol
7.5
 Spider-Island (2015) #4 Sep 17, 2015
7.5
 Star Wars: Darth Vader #15 Jan 6, 2016
7.5
 Star Wars: Kanan #12 Mar 17, 2016

Satisying conclusion. Liked the art more in this issue with the new artist. Couldn't get into the last guys. Still doesn't live up to the first arc though

Was OK.great art. mediocre issue for story. Renew your Vows is the spider-book everyone should be reading.

7.5
 The Discipline #3 May 14, 2016
7.5
 Uncanny X-Men (2016) #3 Feb 9, 2016
7.5
 X-Men: Blue (2017) #1 Apr 14, 2017
7.5
 X-Men: The Wedding Special #1 May 18, 2018
7.5
 X-Tinction Agenda #1 Jun 17, 2015
8.0
 A-Force (2016) #1 Jan 11, 2016
8.0
 A-Force (2016) #2 Feb 9, 2016
8.0
 A-Force (2016) #3 Mar 12, 2016
8.0
 Age of Apocalypse (2015) #1 Jul 8, 2015
8.0
 All-New All-Different Avengers #1 Nov 11, 2015
8.0
 All-New All-Different Avengers #2 Dec 2, 2015
8.0
 All-New All-Different Avengers #7 Mar 27, 2016
8.0
 All-New All-Different Avengers #14 Oct 27, 2016
8.0
 All-New Hawkeye (2015) #4 Mar 27, 2016
8.0
 All-New Hawkeye (2015) #5 Mar 27, 2016
8.0
 All-New Wolverine #2 Nov 25, 2015
8.0
 All-New Wolverine #3 Dec 30, 2015

Old man logan was a bit out of character compared to his main book.
8.0
 All-New Wolverine #19 Apr 7, 2017
8.0
 All-New Wolverine #22 Jul 7, 2017

Fun(ny).

8.0
 All-New X-Men (2015) #3 Jan 16, 2016
8.0
 All-New X-Men (2015) #7 Apr 3, 2016

Im enjoyjng this exploration of Evans character.

Demons are fun!

Im taking off .5 for the 30 pages of ads they stacked on and charged us $2 for. Still very much enjoyed the comic. Picking up where Superior Spider-Man left off. Nice.
8.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #2 Oct 22, 2015
8.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #4 Dec 10, 2015
8.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #5 Dec 23, 2015
8.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #7 Feb 9, 2016
8.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #10 Apr 13, 2016

Well, Im looking forward to something new. I wont miss PI
8.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2018) #3 Aug 8, 2018
8.0
 Archie (2015) #5 Jan 7, 2016
8.0
 Archie (2015) #6 Feb 17, 2016
8.0
 Avengers (2018) #6 Aug 23, 2018

it was fun. Although he kinda seems a lot like Deadpool right now with the sass, loose morals, and scarred face though. Let's see what they do with him. The split personalities is interesting.
8.0
 Betty & Veronica (2016) #1 Jul 20, 2016
8.0
 Black Panther (2016) #4 Aug 12, 2016

I mean, I liked it - was a fun read. But it was just all action. Barely any story or dialogue. Not the best #1 comic for new readers.
8.0
 Bloodshot: Salvation #4 Dec 13, 2017
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2016) #4 May 12, 2016
8.0
 Civil War (2015) #4 Sep 11, 2015
8.0
 Civil War II #3 Jul 20, 2016
8.0
 Civil War II: Amazing Spider-Man #3 Aug 23, 2016
8.0
 Death of X #1 Oct 10, 2016
8.0
 Doctor Strange (2015) #1 Oct 9, 2015
8.0
 Doctor Strange (2015) #11 Sep 9, 2016
8.0
 Fairlady #1 Apr 12, 2019

This issue was a solid 8; just back story/set-up. But the next issues are gonna be b-b-b-bonkers

Good..but nothing happened
8.0
 Guardians of the Galaxy (2015) #3 Dec 10, 2015
8.0
 Guardians of the Galaxy (2015) #16 Jan 11, 2017
8.0
 Hawkeye (2016) #5 Apr 5, 2017
8.0
 Infamous Iron Man (2016) #2 Nov 16, 2016
8.0
 Inferno #2 Jun 17, 2015
8.0
 Infinity Gauntlet (2015) #2 Jul 1, 2015
8.0
 Invincible Iron Man (2015) #6 Feb 9, 2016
8.0
 Invincible Iron Man (2015) #13 Oct 21, 2016
8.0
 Iron Fist (2017) #7 Sep 7, 2017
8.0
 IvX #2 Jan 11, 2017
8.0
 IvX #3 Jan 25, 2017
8.0
 IvX #5 Feb 22, 2017
8.0
 IvX #6 Mar 8, 2017

This book is a bit of a mess, clearly an "indie" comic, but it's kind of my guilty pleasure. I love the setting and ideas, and the art reminds me of that from LOW.
8.0
 New Mutants: Dead Souls #4 Jun 14, 2018
8.0
 Old Man Logan (2016) #1 Jan 27, 2016
8.0
 Planet Hulk #2 Jul 1, 2015

Great art and covers in this series. Story was just fun. No real emotional connection to Cap's journey.

8.0
 Redlands #4 Nov 8, 2017
8.0
 Rom (2016) #1 Jul 27, 2016

Solid. Still love the art. Great to see all the pairings (Tchalla/Namor, Peter/Miles, Reed/Reed...)
8.0
 Secret Weapons #1 Jun 28, 2017
8.0
 Silk (2015) #2 Dec 17, 2015
8.0
 Silk (2015) #4 Feb 14, 2016
8.0
 Silk (2015) #15 Dec 14, 2016
8.0
 Silver Surfer (2016) #1 Jan 20, 2016
8.0
 Spider-Man (2016) #3 Apr 10, 2016
8.0
 Spider-Man (2016) #4 May 26, 2016

An average opening issue with great art where not much happens. But I have really high hopes for this series, and I think this is a decent set up issue.

Good, but I need to catch up on the back story. I really like how it focuses on her struggles rather than the plot.
8.0
 Star Wars: Chewbacca #1 Oct 18, 2015
8.0
 Star Wars: Chewbacca #4 Nov 26, 2015
8.0
 Star Wars: Darth Vader #19 Apr 14, 2016
8.0
 Star Wars: Doctor Aphra #1 Dec 8, 2016
8.0
 Star Wars: Kanan #7 Nov 8, 2015
8.0
 Star Wars: Obi-Wan & Anakin #1 Jan 6, 2016
8.0
 Star-Lord #3 Jan 25, 2016
8.0
 Star-Lord #5 Mar 22, 2016
8.0
 Star-Lord #7 May 20, 2016
8.0
 Star-Lord (2016) #2 Jan 18, 2017
8.0
 Thanos (2016) #13 Nov 24, 2017
8.0
 The Beauty #4 Nov 21, 2015
8.0
 The Beauty #9 Jul 31, 2016
8.0
 The Clone Conspiracy #3 Dec 11, 2016
8.0
 The Discipline #2 Apr 8, 2016
8.0
 The Discipline #4 Jul 7, 2016
8.0
 The Discipline #6 Aug 4, 2016
8.0
 The Mighty Thor (2015) #6 May 12, 2016
8.0
 The Mighty Thor (2015) #7 May 31, 2016
8.0
 The Mighty Thor (2015) #8 Jun 24, 2016
8.0
 The X-Files (2016) #1 May 23, 2016
8.0
 Thors #1 Jun 17, 2015

Good, but reveals almost nothing more than last issue.

8.0
 Thors #4 Nov 12, 2015

Unfortunate about the artist shift. Completely different styles just didnt work together. Wonder why that had to happen
8.0
 Uncanny X-Men (2016) #1 Jan 11, 2016
8.0
 Uncanny X-Men (2016) #2 Jan 25, 2016
8.0
 Uncanny X-Men (2016) #4 Mar 12, 2016
8.0
 Uncanny X-Men (2016) #9 Jul 7, 2016
8.0
 Uncanny X-Men (2016) #12 Sep 15, 2016

Pretty cool psylocke issue. Apparently she is powerful enough to [spoilers] cure Mystique's schizophrenia? Ok whatever lol
8.0
 Underwinter: A Field of Feathers #5 Mar 2, 2018
8.0
 Unnatural #2 Aug 10, 2018
8.0
 Unnatural #3 Sep 7, 2018

I mean Ill give it an 8. Lets not get carried away people lol
8.0
 Where Monsters Dwell #1 Jun 17, 2015

It was good for sure, but I wouldn't go so far as the 9.5 rating it currently has from reviewerss.
8.0
 X-Men '92 (2016) #5 Jul 31, 2016
8.0
 X-Men: Blue (2017) #3 May 10, 2017
8.0
 X-Men: Blue (2017) #36 Sep 26, 2018

Good art, fun story.

8.5
 A-Force #1 Jun 17, 2015
8.5
 A-Force #5 Oct 14, 2015
8.5
 A-Force (2016) #6 Jun 8, 2016
8.5
 All-New All-Different Avengers #0 Oct 10, 2015
8.5
 All-New All-Different Avengers #3 Jan 16, 2016
8.5
 All-New All-Different Avengers #5 Feb 14, 2016
8.5
 All-New All-Different Avengers #6 Feb 27, 2016
8.5
 All-New All-Different Avengers #11 Jul 1, 2016

Fun, as always. edit: so I just saw the movie, and this comic very much has a similar tone. I wonder if they got to see a pre-screening or something!
8.5
 All-New Wolverine #1 Nov 12, 2015
8.5
 All-New Wolverine #9 Jun 1, 2016

Really enjoyed the new artist and love seeing the wolverines together. Albeit nothing rwally happened this issue.

8.5
 All-New Wolverine #13 Oct 22, 2016
8.5
 All-New Wolverine #18 Mar 9, 2017

Very cool

Super cool story, art is a little stiff.
8.5
 All-New X-Men (2015) #2 Dec 19, 2015
8.5
 All-New X-Men (2015) #16 Dec 14, 2016

The pacing was a little weird, but good moments.
8.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #16 Aug 13, 2016
8.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #17 Sep 6, 2016

This was surpsingly good. SPOILERS: .... Funny how they tease Zodiac as maybe the focus of this arc, and then bang crash he's done. lol. I think Dan Slott was kinda paying service to the fans who most all said no one gives a shit about Zodiac. haha I mean I found the original arc entertaining, but certainly didn't need a second arc in as many years.
8.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2018) #4 Aug 22, 2018
8.5
 Amazing Spider-Man: Renew Your Vows #2 Jul 8, 2015
8.5
 Amazing Spider-Man: Renew Your Vows #5 Sep 11, 2015
8.5
 Archie (2015) #4 Nov 25, 2015
8.5
 Archie (2015) #8 May 14, 2016
8.5
 Archie (2015) #10 Jul 27, 2016

I hope the show takes these same vibes on
8.5
 Avengers (2016) #7 May 11, 2017

The story takes off this issue..really satisying issue! Art was good, but not great.

psycho batman is the only batman I like lol (see: White Knight as well). The writing was a little confusing, but that was also clearly the point. Art was amazing and enjoyed the first appearance of Batcock

Good issue, wish it was longer.
8.5
 Black Hammer #4 Oct 22, 2016
8.5
 Black Panther (2016) #3 Jul 7, 2016
8.5
 Black Panther (2016) #5 Aug 12, 2016
8.5
 Black Widow (2016) #2 Apr 8, 2016
8.5
 Captain Marvel (2016) #1 Jan 20, 2016
8.5
 Captain Marvel (2016) #2 Feb 9, 2016
8.5
 Captain Marvel (2016) #5 May 31, 2016

So far, so good.

The good: -jaw dropping art -great character line up -I actually don't mind the writing. The issue was actually more direct because we had issue #0 and the FCBD issue. Maybe pacing was an issue if you didn't read either of those The bad: -price

8.5
 Civil War II #4 Aug 4, 2016

Very much warming up to the stylistic art which reminds me of the New X-Men run back in the 2000s.
8.5
 Defenders (2017) #3 Jul 12, 2017
8.5
 Doctor Strange (2015) #3 Dec 4, 2015
8.5
 Doctor Strange (2015) #8 May 31, 2016

If only the movie were this Strange! Love it.

good set up issue. now sure how it related to uncanny x-men #600 lol

Love the discussion between Jean and Logan about fate and choice, one being from the future the other from the past. Alas, not particularly a fan of Ramos. Some good moments though. Sweet action at the end.

Starting to warm to Ramos' art style

8.5
 Extraordinary X-Men #6 Jan 30, 2016
8.5
 Extraordinary X-Men #7 Feb 27, 2016
8.5
 Extraordinary X-Men #9 Apr 20, 2016
8.5
 Extraordinary X-Men #10 May 26, 2016

Good, but felt like it was missing any real stakes. Kinda knew collosus had to turn back and apocalypse had to go, and we barely knew Sapna, so no great loss?
8.5
 Extraordinary X-Men #18 Jan 25, 2017

Lemire doing his best work with these one shots at the end of his run. Sad! :(

Every time this series started to gain momentum, an event shoved it off the tracks....and now it's done. I feel slightly disappointed, because Lemire is my favourite writer. If only he had gotten the series at a different time. Somehow I doubt he will come back to it after this.

8.5
 Fantastic Four (2018) #1 Aug 10, 2018
8.5
 Generations (2017): Phoenix & Jean Grey #1 Aug 9, 2017
8.5
 Guardians of Knowhere #4 Sep 17, 2015

Very good start
8.5
 Guardians of the Galaxy (2015) #4 Jan 16, 2016
8.5
 Guardians of the Galaxy (2015) #7 Apr 20, 2016

Guardians of the galaxy is really great
8.5
 Hawkeye (2016) #6 May 3, 2017
8.5
 Infamous Iron Man (2016) #1 Oct 21, 2016

Pleasantly surprised. Huge Secret Wars spoiler...

Very entertaining. Nice cover ;) Gotta love MJ.

Great art and a strong introduction to the arc, I just find t a bit jarring having such different versions of the character (Power Man and Iron Fist vs this)
8.5
 Isola #3 Jun 7, 2018
8.5
 Jean Grey #3 Jun 28, 2017
8.5
 Jean Grey #5 Aug 13, 2017
8.5
 Jessica Jones #7 Apr 5, 2017

I almost thought he was going to leave it unexplained when Maria says to her "you solved the case" and we still dont know whats going on. But then in Bendis fashion it is casually revealed a few speech bubbles later lol. The resolution was indeed satisfying and the art as always was top notch.
8.5
 Mister Miracle (2017) #1 Aug 9, 2017
8.5
 Moon Knight (2016) #1 Apr 13, 2016
8.5
 Moon Knight (2016) #2 May 14, 2016
8.5
 Moon Knight (2016) #7 Oct 15, 2016

paranormal investigation team starring my favourite mutant? count me in!
8.5
 Old Man Logan #2 Jun 17, 2015
8.5
 Old Man Logan #5 Oct 12, 2015
8.5
 Old Man Logan (2016) #2 Feb 10, 2016
8.5
 Old Man Logan (2016) #5 Apr 28, 2016

Rawrg
8.5
 Old Man Logan (2016) #19 Mar 9, 2017

I think Quinones is my favourite spider-man artist.

promising. great art. cool cover.

8.5
 Phoenix Resurrection: The Return Of Jean Grey #2 Jan 4, 2018
8.5
 Plutona #1 Sep 17, 2015
8.5
 Plutona #4 Feb 29, 2016
8.5
 Regression #2 Jun 15, 2017
8.5
 Rom (2016) #2 Aug 24, 2016
8.5
 Royal City #4 Jun 26, 2017

Preface: I love Jeff Lemire, he is my favourite writer. Review: This finale fizzled for me. Felt like he kinda phoned it in, and there werent any big revelations. Last issue when he wrote the letter saying that the story just came to a natural conclusion for him, I thought OK and was expecting a really satisfying conclusion. In the letter at the end of this issue, he kinda re-states the same thing but then adds that at one point he had hoped to revisit Royal City for many years, but recently it felt like more restrictive than anything (I forget the exact words, but that was the idea), and this sentiment is what comes through in this issue. I feel like he is just letting it end, rather than this being some well formed conclusion. Still... great series, just hoped for more from the finale.

8.5
 Saga #52 May 31, 2018

Still getting the feeling while reading this series that this will be a very important event in the history of Marvel. Very special.

Probably the first of 2 battle issues. Decent.
8.5
 Sentry (2018) #1 Jun 28, 2018
8.5
 Sentry (2018) #4 Sep 26, 2018
8.5
 Silk (2015) #7 Apr 21, 2016

Great art, dialogue, silks character is still growing.
8.5
 Silk (2015) #13 Oct 29, 2016
8.5
 Silver Surfer (2016) #2 Feb 20, 2016
8.5
 Silver Surfer (2016) #4 May 20, 2016
8.5
 Spider-Man (2016) #2 Mar 4, 2016
8.5
 Spider-Man (2016) #5 Jul 1, 2016
8.5
 Spider-Man (2016) #7 Sep 9, 2016
8.5
 Spider-Woman (2015) #2 Dec 23, 2015

Great art. Cool little story.

8.5
 Star Wars (2014) #15 Jan 20, 2016
8.5
 Star Wars (2014) #19 May 26, 2016
8.5
 Star Wars (2014) #20 Jun 23, 2016
8.5
 Star Wars (2014) Annual #1 Dec 10, 2015
8.5
 Star Wars: Darth Vader #10 Oct 18, 2015
8.5
 Star Wars: Darth Vader #11 Nov 8, 2015
8.5
 Star Wars: Darth Vader #16 Feb 14, 2016
8.5
 Star Wars: Han Solo #1 Jun 17, 2016
8.5
 Star Wars: Kanan #11 Feb 26, 2016

Solid series. Great writing and art.
8.5
 Star-Lord (2016) #4 Mar 15, 2017
8.5
 The Beauty #2 Sep 17, 2015
8.5
 The Beauty #5 Dec 22, 2015

shame that this is a one off issue!
8.5
 The Beauty #8 Jun 17, 2016
8.5
 The Black Monday Murders #6 Jun 26, 2017
8.5
 The Discipline #1 Mar 2, 2016

nice set up for the future. I hope we see more of the future Thunder gods.

Strong start.
8.5
 Ultimates (2015) #1 Nov 12, 2015

Hopefully they leave behind the lame civil war drama and get back to work quickly!

Im easily satisfied lol
8.5
 Uncanny X-Men (2016) #11 Aug 4, 2016

although confusing, the art and design are killer.
8.5
 We Stand On Guard #2 Aug 5, 2015

Like the first issue, surprisingly good.
8.5
 Weirdworld #1 Jun 17, 2015
8.5
 Weirdworld (2015) #1 Dec 22, 2015
8.5
 Weirdworld (2015) #2 Jan 8, 2016

pretty funny
8.5
 Witchblade (2017) #1 Dec 6, 2017
8.5
 X-Men '92 (2016) #1 Apr 2, 2016
8.5
 X-Men: Blue (2017) #5 Jun 15, 2017
8.5
 X-Men: Blue (2017) #9 Aug 17, 2017

boring villains, but loving the melodrama lol.

Still awesome, but this issue will need to be part of the bigger whole. Not a great stand alone or jump on point. It abruptly starts and abruptly ends.

I dig it.
8.5
 X-Men: Red (2018) Annual #1 May 30, 2018

Well, I'm surprised to see the low critic reviews for this issue. I loved it. Great art, great action. I don't think the reveal was supposed to be a surprise, Loki is on the cover afterall.

9.0
 Aliens: Dead Orbit #1 Apr 26, 2017
9.0
 Aliens: Dead Orbit #4 Dec 13, 2017
9.0
 All-New All-Different Avengers #10 Jun 10, 2016

Love me a vision centric book

Very cool story.

Oh comics, I love you
9.0
 All-New Wolverine #11 Aug 18, 2016

Dat cover though. Also! A very cool issue. I wish Yu was doing the interior art too though. But the art was still good, kinda charming-cartoony. Rocket was both hilarious and hardcore this issue.
9.0
 All-New X-Men (2015) #18 Feb 1, 2017

A spidey storey with heart. The art/colour duo worked better this issue than last. Was great actually.
9.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #14 Jun 23, 2016
9.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #15 Jul 6, 2016
9.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #23 Jan 24, 2017

What a nice surprise seeing Smallwood and Bellaire as guest artists this issue. Great one shot.
9.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #800 May 30, 2018

Fuuuun
9.0
 Archie (2015) #9 Jun 24, 2016
9.0
 Astonishing X-Men (2017) #1 Jul 21, 2017
9.0
 Astonishing X-Men (2017) #6 Jan 4, 2018
9.0
 Astonishing X-Men (2017) #7 Jan 4, 2018

You know, I didn't consciously realize there was no text until after I finished. Now that's good storytelling!
9.0
 Barrier (2018) #5 May 31, 2018

I dont like batman. There I said it. I find the strength of his stories revolve around the supporting cast and villains, they all make him a better character. And this story was kind of the epitome of that. Long live BatCat.

Da fuq
9.0
 Black Hammer #10 Jun 26, 2017
9.0
 Black Hammer #11 Jul 28, 2017
9.0
 Black Hammer Annual #1 Jan 18, 2017
9.0
 Black Hammer: Age of Doom #5 Sep 19, 2018

Pretty awesome world building going on here.
9.0
 Black Panther (2016) #6 Sep 15, 2016
9.0
 Black Panther (2018) #3 Aug 22, 2018

oooo Jen Bartel art
9.0
 Black Widow (2016) #4 Jun 17, 2016

Comics at its best.

Damn. Truly showing us the nature of Natasha. Great comic. Always feels too short.
9.0
 Black Widow (2016) #9 Jan 2, 2017
9.0
 Black Widow (2016) #10 Jan 18, 2017

It's like a really awesome 90s action movie.

I don't understand why y'all hate it. Art alone makes this issue worth the money.

Awesome art

Alpha Flight part was awesome. Didnt care about the rest. But Ill still give it 9 just for Alpha Flight.

Wow Im so happy to say this is actually good. It looks like emma may be playing behind the scenes somehow which is really cool. Maybe Scott isnt the bad guy here aftetall

Am I the only one that really enjoyed this event?
9.0
 Death or Glory #2 Jun 7, 2018
9.0
 Defenders (2017) #2 Jun 28, 2017
9.0
 Descender #23 Aug 16, 2017

What, is no one reading this anymore?! Epic issue! Great finale.

so cool how this keeps growing.

Great writing
9.0
 Doctor Strange (2015) #6 Mar 22, 2016
9.0
 Doctor Strange (2015) #9 Jun 29, 2016
9.0
 Doctor Strange (2015) #10 Aug 12, 2016
9.0
 Doctor Strange (2015) #12 Nov 16, 2016

9. Cuz Jeff Lemire. Fuck the shitty ratings this book is getting, it's great. Stop comparing it to past X-men.

I really liked it and the magik story at the end. Ramos art is finally growing on me.

I'm glad readers are finally warming to Lemire/Ramos X-Men. Wish critics would feel the same. It's annoying seeing a critic score of 6.9 on an immensely entertaining issue.

Wow.. Awesome book
9.0
 Extraordinary X-Men #14 Oct 15, 2016
9.0
 Extraordinary X-Men #15 Nov 10, 2016

Strong emotional interactions and the art seemed to get better with each page (or else I warmed to it over the issue).
9.0
 Faithless #1 Apr 12, 2019
9.0
 Generations (2017): Wolverine & All-New Wolverine #1 Aug 17, 2017
9.0
 Grass Kings #1 Jul 12, 2017

deeper down the rabbit hole! love exploring this world
9.0
 Grass Kings #14 Apr 26, 2018

Love me some Starkat

This issue was exceptionally good! Action packed and a ton of fun.
9.0
 Guardians of the Galaxy (2015) #10 Jul 25, 2016

Why do I love this book so much and everyone else seems indifferent to it?

Great art, great action; looking forward to the conclusion.
9.0
 Hawkeye (2016) #8 Jul 5, 2017
9.0
 Hawkeye (2016) #10 Sep 7, 2017
9.0
 Head Lopper #9 Sep 12, 2018

Best issue yet.

Great.
9.0
 Invincible Iron Man (2015) #5 Jan 7, 2016

Surprisingly good. Better than the first issue. Gives us a hint of what we can expect for the rest of the arc, and great to see Danny getting his mojo back, he was just depressing in the first issue.

neeeeeed moooore
9.0
 IvX #1 Dec 14, 2016

Great team on this one.

This is the Phoenix Resurrection finale you are looking for. Skip the other one lol. Great writing here. Also an annoying artist change mid book.

Great counter take on the current marvel landscape. Seems JJ is fed up with all the superhero antics and probably hiding her daughter from it. The mysteries make it feel like a real detective book too.
9.0
 Jessica Jones #14 Nov 9, 2017

Glad I kept with this.
9.0
 Maestros #3 Dec 13, 2017

Im on board.
9.0
 Marvel Two-In-One (2017) #4 Mar 14, 2018
9.0
 Mister Miracle (2017) #3 Oct 11, 2017
9.0
 Mister Miracle (2017) #9 Jun 14, 2018

action-packed issue.

9.0
 Moon Knight (2016) #4 Jul 6, 2016

Whaaaaaaaaaaaat....tf
9.0
 Moon Knight (2016) #10 Apr 15, 2017
9.0
 Oblivion Song #3 May 10, 2018

Wide-eyed the entire issue.
9.0
 Old Man Logan (2016) #3 Mar 4, 2016
9.0
 Old Man Logan (2016) #4 Apr 10, 2016
9.0
 Old Man Logan (2016) #8 Jul 31, 2016
9.0
 Old Man Logan (2016) #9 Jul 31, 2016
9.0
 Old Man Logan (2016) #22 Apr 26, 2017
9.0
 Peter Parker: The Spectacular Spider-Man (2017) #297 Nov 16, 2017
9.0
 Peter Parker: The Spectacular Spider-Man (2017) #300 Mar 1, 2018

great art change

The production quality of this book is outstanding. The ink, the paper, just great. Oh! and the story and art are great too!
9.0
 Plutona #5 Jun 30, 2016
9.0
 Reborn #1 Oct 12, 2016
9.0
 Reborn #2 Nov 16, 2016
9.0
 Reborn #6 Jun 8, 2017
9.0
 Redlands #1 Aug 9, 2017
9.0
 Redlands #3 Oct 11, 2017
9.0
 Redlands #5 Dec 20, 2017
9.0
 Regression #3 Jul 12, 2017
9.0
 Regression #4 Aug 17, 2017
9.0
 Royal City #5 Jul 19, 2017
9.0
 Royal City #6 Oct 11, 2017
9.0
 Royal City #7 Nov 8, 2017
9.0
 Royal City #8 Dec 13, 2017
9.0
 Saga #44 Jun 28, 2017
9.0
 Saga #49 Mar 1, 2018

It seems like we've been having 3 issues of beach showdown now lol Its like Dragon Ball Z style or something. Don't get me wrong, I still love it, but not sure I love the pacing.
9.0
 Sea of Stars #1 Jul 4, 2019
9.0
 Secret Wars (2015) #3 Jun 17, 2015

Awesome. Honestly though, wish it was rated Mature, but I understand the choice for a wider audience I guess.

Love Silk
9.0
 Silk (2015) #1 Nov 29, 2015
9.0
 Silk (2015) #3 Jan 15, 2016
9.0
 Silk (2015) #5 Feb 26, 2016

I don't dislike ford's art,but I hope we see more Stacey Lee in the future.
9.0
 Silk (2015) #12 Sep 9, 2016
9.0
 Silk (2015) #16 Jan 11, 2017
9.0
 Silver Surfer (2016) #3 Apr 14, 2016
9.0
 Silver Surfer (2016) #6 Sep 6, 2016

Most fun in the stands!
9.0
 Silver Surfer (2016) #9 Mar 9, 2017
9.0
 Spider-Man (2016) #1 Feb 3, 2016

Myfavourite civil war tie in yet. Like everyone always says Bendis can really write well when he wants to. Now if only the event books were this good....
9.0
 Spider-Woman (2015) #3 Jan 30, 2016
9.0
 Spider-Woman (2015) #6 May 12, 2016
9.0
 Spider-Woman (2015) #8 Jun 8, 2016

MY favourite issue since the first story line.

Amazing but certainly drawing out this arcs climax...
9.0
 Star Wars (2014) #12 Nov 21, 2015
9.0
 Star Wars (2014) #14 Jan 6, 2016
9.0
 Star Wars (2014) #17 Mar 27, 2016
9.0
 Star Wars (2014) #40 Dec 13, 2017

Really excellent. Art is on point.

It took me about 15 issues to start really appreciated Larroca's art, but I really love it now. Or maybe he's just getting better ;) Anyway, series is as strong as ever.

sad to see it go
9.0
 Star Wars: Darth Vader Annual #1 Dec 19, 2015

Wow!

9.0
 Star Wars: Shattered Empire #1 Sep 11, 2015

Another blast.

I feckin love Star-Kat
9.0
 Star-Lord (2016) #1 Jan 18, 2017

Bar-lord forever.

Awesome creative team. Hope they work together again. Too bad it wasn't selling...

Loved it. Great art, great characters. Charming comic.
9.0
 Star-Lord And Kitty Pryde #3 Sep 11, 2015
9.0
 Strangers In Paradise XXV #6 Sep 19, 2018
9.0
 Thanos (2016) #16 Mar 1, 2018

Masterful.

Feels special so far. Tugging the heart strings too, which has been seriously lackong this volume. P.s. I think the 1.5 rating guy had a problem with the Gwen characterisation lol

Best issue yet

My first Thor comic. Loved it.
9.0
 The Mighty Thor (2015) #11 Oct 17, 2016
9.0
 The Mighty Thor (2015) #700 Oct 18, 2017

so creepy...

love the future thor story
9.0
 Ultimates (2015) #2 Dec 10, 2015

dope story. dope art. That's my very professional review.
9.0
 Ultimates (2015) #4 Feb 14, 2016

A return to true x-form.

Love the current state of this book. Getting stronger every issue. A slow burn I can respect.

Dayum
9.0
 Uncanny X-Men (2016) #19 Mar 16, 2017

What da fuq did i just read
9.0
 Underwinter #4 Jul 13, 2017

fun and intriguing.
9.0
 Venom (2018) #3 Jun 28, 2018
9.0
 Vision (2015) #1 Apr 5, 2016
9.0
 Vision (2015) #8 Jun 8, 2016
9.0
 Vision (2015) #9 Jul 20, 2016

Gonna be a sad day when this series ends.

I may be a little bias ;)

The art sure does grow on you in this series
9.0
 We Stand On Guard #6 Dec 10, 2015
9.0
 Weirdworld (2015) #3 Feb 14, 2016
9.0
 Weirdworld (2015) #6 May 26, 2016

found this story scarier than the first arc. Also it was huge, not sure exactly how many pages, but felt like a full arc almost. Well worth $8

+0.5 for that cover

9.0
 X-Men Prime #1 Mar 29, 2017
9.0
 X-Men: Blue (2017) #2 Apr 26, 2017

Ah, finally the strong issue Ive been waiting for. Love having Kitty as the leader, and this issue packed in some emotion and grit. Syaf draws great back muscles haha
9.0
 Years of Future Past #1 Jun 17, 2015
9.5
 A.D.: After Death #1 Nov 24, 2016

Super cool. Cant imagine how they will wrap it up in one more issue.
9.5
 All-New X-Men (2015) #17 Jan 18, 2017
9.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2018) #1 Jul 12, 2018

This is my ideal Spider-Man, so happy with this. I find myself hearing spidys dialogue with his 90s tv show voice in my head
9.5
 Amazing Spider-Man: Renew Your Vows #1 Jun 17, 2015

Yesssssss. This is the Spider-Man (Family) book I want! Also a $5 book that is actually worth it for once. 2 cute and funny bonus stories at the end.

So rad
9.5
 Black Hammer #1 Jul 20, 2016

Wow. So good.

sign me up.
9.5
 Black Panther (2018) #2 Jun 28, 2018
9.5
 Black Science #26 Dec 7, 2016
9.5
 Black Science #27 Jan 5, 2017
9.5
 Black Science #34 Jan 29, 2018
9.5
 Black Widow (2016) #12 Mar 29, 2017

I remember feeling slightly disappointed that the last arc wasnt quite as epic as they seemed to be hyping it as with the whole "Rise of the Robots" summer event thing last year...but this current arc, which is undoubtedly the climax, has been non-stop epic.

Possibly the first time Ive yelled out loud while reading a comic.
9.5
 Fantastic Four (2018) #2 Sep 12, 2018

The next Saga? probably not, but still REALLY good.
9.5
 Jessica Jones #2 Nov 16, 2016
9.5
 Low (2014) #19 Aug 9, 2017

Hilarious and fantastical, go buy it!
9.5
 Maestros #6 May 10, 2018
9.5
 Marvel Two-In-One (2017) #1 Dec 20, 2017

who knew Zdarsky had these kind of writing chops?!
9.5
 Mister Miracle (2017) #5 Dec 13, 2017

great start. hope we see more of these new characters

This should be an action movie haha

Awesome. Violent, beautiful, emotional.

9.5
 Old Man Logan (2016) #11 Sep 15, 2016
9.5
 Old Man Logan (2016) #12 Oct 15, 2016
9.5
 Old Man Logan (2016) #13 Nov 28, 2016
9.5
 Old Man Logan (2016) #18 Feb 22, 2017
9.5
 Peter Parker: The Spectacular Spider-Man (2017) #310 Sep 26, 2018
9.5
 Regression #1 May 10, 2017

I feel like this is/will be Lemire's best work yet.

9.5
 Royal City #10 Mar 1, 2018

WHAT?! Its ending at issue #14?!!! lame! Felt like he was going to continue exploring this story for a long time, and he even admits that in the note on the last page, but says that the story just came to a natural end for him.

Wow, hardcore. I am Groot.

+.5 for the ridiculously naughty variant cover lol

Beautiful art and great continuation to black hammer. I wouldnt even call it a tie in or a spin off, this book is filling out and furthering the story. Makes me want to go back and read Black Hammer from the start to see if I missed anything.
9.5
 Silk (2015) #11 Aug 12, 2016

Silk grew into one of my favourite characters, and I loved how Tana Ford got better and better with each issue. This finale you can tell was probably an idea for an entire arc but since they knew it was ending they crammed into one issue. The villain would've been more impactful if we had more reference for her. But to echo that other user's comment "fuck Marvel for cancelling this book." They better start a new volume within a year.
9.5
 Silver Surfer (2016) #10 Apr 13, 2017

Near perfect.
9.5
 Spider-Woman (2015) #4 Feb 20, 2016
9.5
 Spider-Woman (2015) #5 Mar 17, 2016

Wowza

Love
9.5
 Star Wars: Darth Vader #24 Aug 16, 2016

Very impressive in all aspects.

fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuck
9.5
 Thanos (2016) #18 Apr 13, 2018

Just re-read this book from issue #1, and what an amazing first arc. Near perfect, imo. Count me in for the next arc. I just hope more people start buying it so it will continue.

Dayum, now this is comics at is best.

Jesus. I mean Mammon!

Probably my favourite comic being published right now.
9.5
 The Mighty Thor (2015) #3 Jan 20, 2016
9.5
 The Mighty Thor (2015) #5 Mar 17, 2016
9.5
 Ultimates (2015) #5 Apr 8, 2016
9.5
 Ultimates (2015) #12 Oct 27, 2016

Well I thought it was great. But I just hopped on with this issue lol
9.5
 Venom (2018) #2 Jun 14, 2018
9.5
 Vision (2015) #6 Apr 15, 2016

new story and still amazing. One of my favourite comics...ever? :O

I almost want to give it a perfect 10, Ill reserve that for the last issue though ;)

love her
9.5
 X-Men: Grand Design #1 Dec 20, 2017
9.5
 X-Men: Red (2018) #8 Sep 26, 2018
10
 A.D.: After Death #3 May 11, 2017
10
 All-New Hawkeye (2015) #6 Apr 21, 2016
10
 All-New X-Men (2015) #4 Feb 15, 2016

Promising. Edit: guess Ill give it 10 to counteract the guy who keeps lowering his score to mess with the average

Ah, so people are going to bomb the user ratings just to be douchebags. I can play that game too.
10
 America #3 May 11, 2017

Great idea. Pay what you want. Great writing/art. 10/10

Great exploration of the character

10
 Grass Kings #15 May 30, 2018

Giving this 10 just to offset the guy who gave the ridiculous failing grade of 3.0. Seriously? What is your scale based on.
10
 Guardians of the Galaxy (2015) #19 Apr 12, 2017
10
 Heroes In Crisis #2 Nov 1, 2018

One of the best issues I have read....ever

Holy shit! Really good! The writing is A+, super funny. Art is great too.

Maybe the my favourite issue of any Spider-Man series ever.....only time will tell if I remove the 'maybe'

Wow. Everyone, buy this book! Jeff Lemire in his prime, both as an artist and writer.

Probably the most intense comic I have ever read. To be fair, I'm fairly new to comics. But still gotta give this one a 10!

Favourite comic. 10.
10
 Silver Surfer (2016) #13 Aug 16, 2017

a perfect series.

This series is too good to be ending! Seriously though Ill read whatever he writes next.
10
 Spider-Woman (2015) #17 Mar 29, 2017

Amazeballs
10
 The Mighty Thor (2015) #706 Apr 25, 2018

Tear.

Reviews for the Week of...

November

27th 20th 13th 6th

October

30th
More
© 2024