maelstron's Profile

Joined: Mar 04, 2020

Filter By:
6.2
Overall Rating

Super cringey moments

It is over
10
 Darkhold (2021): Omega #1 Jan 5, 2022

Weak end to Hickman ternure on X-men books

pepe Larraz art is great here, but it is wasted on bad plots. Cyclops being Captain Krakoa was very obvious, I'm not even sure how this work in universe like " Cylops died and then thi new guy show up from nowhere covering his face". Sunfire says that FeiLong can't stay on Phobos, but why? If mutants can claim Mars, he can be on Phobos

I'm very critical of the hype Al Ewing receives, but this issue was so good. Great plot twist and very consistent with the early issue.

8.5
 Wolverine (2020) #19 Dec 22, 2021

Really nice fanfic

Dissapointing ending that isn't even a ending

Cates wrote this to showcase Ottley art. The story is very decompressed, feel like we are on the second part of the pilot of a tv show. But it is really fun and there is a easter egg about Authority. The end really picked my interest. If you are a specuato, you may want to get this issue

Very dissapointing. Logan knew a woman for few hours and already had a deep connection with her
9.5
 Daredevil (2019) #36 Dec 3, 2021

Another boring white man representing krakoa Filler fight Bad art

8.5
 Venom (2021) #2 Dec 1, 2021

Trash Over the top characterizations, it was so funny when Wiccan exploded at Wanda saying he defended her his whiole life. It's incoherent stories and charcterizations. Wanda doesn't remember doing bad things because she was ressurrected with only younger memories. Wanda already accepted responsability for her actions and move on. This mini isn't adding anything interesting to Wanda. Also Magneto is so bad on this mini

Seems like Cates are taking ideas of "inside out" pixar movie, it is hilarious for sure. Not everything has to be so serious
8.0
 Wolverine (2020) #18 Nov 24, 2021

Disjointed issue. The only interestingplot is about Ben discovering the mutant ressurrection
7.5
 S.W.O.R.D. (2020) #10 Nov 19, 2021

Art is mostly awful. Story is very meh and decompressed

Just meh all around. So Logan has been a surfer all this time and he asks Forge to do a adamantium surfer board for reasons Quentin and Phoebe bore me even their break up.

More of a set up issue with slow pace, But it is very engaging
9.0
 Eternals (2021) #7 Nov 10, 2021
2.0
 Excalibur (2019) #25 Nov 10, 2021
7.5
 Hellions (2020) #17 Nov 10, 2021
8.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2018) #77 Oct 27, 2021
9.0
 Daredevil (2019) #35 Oct 27, 2021

Meh Some bad ploting here, really boring. So all this time non telepaths could use cerebro. mystique is a awesome player, we have to believe on that even if her play with other council members was mostly awful. Emma feel bad when they manipulate her, but have no problems to manipulate others

FILLER At least the members of the team did something, but is too late to fix this

Only liked the She-hulk story, Rest was from ok to meh

Ok. Enough to make me want to read next issue

Promising start of the new arc!
5.5
 Age Of X-Man: X-Tremists #5 Oct 20, 2021
5.0
 Batman (2016) #40 Oct 20, 2021

Crap. This is just filler crap. The story is full of plot holes and dumb contrivances

Nice to see that She-hulk being smart is coming back
2.0
 Strange Adventures (2020) #12 Oct 14, 2021

Allright issue. Feels like moving the plot forward

Another villain of the week. Duggan can't write Laura, she has a life on her own and doesn't need the memories of a man to feel complete

A very good jumping in point. Art is pretty good, writing is on point
9.0
 Dark Ages (2021) #2 Oct 6, 2021

All this fake mutant persecution is awful. They did crap on otherworld and arent victims
8.5
 Hellions (2020) #16 Oct 6, 2021

Would get a 9, if the story wasn't so long and chaarcters acted so dumb. Shadow king isnt a mutant
8.5
 Thor (2020) #15 Oct 1, 2021
8.5
 Thor (2020) #16 Oct 1, 2021

Solid first issue
6.5
 S.W.O.R.D. (2020) #8 Sep 30, 2021

It has a giant black cat with guns.

7.5
 Inferno (2021) #1 Sep 29, 2021

I really lost the interest for Solem. Te characte is a mary-sue, writer is trying to hard to sell this crap character too hard. The conclusion was dumb, just Call Emma to solve zzzzzzz
5.0
 X-Corp (2021) #5 Sep 23, 2021
8.0
 X-Men: Legends (2021) #7 Sep 23, 2021

End the run with a giant bullet, meh

Dumb fight starts so pages can be spend on the fight fight ends an then locals offer a meal to x-men. This same thing happened on the last issue. Synch gave the villain his body and Cyclops seemed ok because x-men very win. This is very meta, of course x-men have to win or x-men comics will have to end at some point if they keep losing at the end. Art is so great, very knect. The scene on the pir with the rain is so beatiful, the way larraz draw and Gracia colors is unique. Writing needs to improve on next issues

X-men writers can't see a White Straight male that is a complete asshole so that they can redeem him. Cortez redemption story is very comedic, no way there is a redemption for a little racist sh*t like him. he created the racist term flatscan. Worse part is that they used a black charater that Cortez killed her parents to redeem him. Seriously this is awful
8.5
 Fantastic Four (2018) #35 Sep 15, 2021

Duggan is phoning in so badly

Impressed how the writer get the characters wrong

First thing I noticed is how writer have a Roma chaarcter being acussed of stoling a kid. Doctor Doom is really badly written here

Seems like story is getting places even if the pace is slow

More of build up for the next issue
8.0
 Hellions (2020) #15 Sep 2, 2021
9.5
 Dark Ages (2021) #1 Sep 1, 2021

The story has been a drag. Of course Shadow king is a villain., no surprise here
7.0
 Cable (2020): Reloaded #1 Aug 27, 2021

Really not sure about Solem. Art was great, Percy writing is strongest with Kubert
8.5
 Guardians of the Galaxy (2020) #17 Aug 19, 2021

Plotless comics is trash
7.0
 Way of X (2021) #5 Aug 18, 2021

Hard to believe marvel published a comic as bad as this one

Writing is like a fanfic, characters talk like they are action figures controlled by kids. Art is not consistent, some pages are awful

Tis series is a mess all over the place. Last issue did very little for the series

The art is amazing. The writing could be better if Ewing did a more straight up story. Seriously he is good, but indulge himself too much. This will be a hard reading for mos readers. No surprise Incredible hulk is his big comercial success My grade is mostly for the art, but if second issue is like this the grade will be lower

The pace is slow and needs more meat on the issues.
4.0
 Batman: Urban Legends (2021) #6 Aug 10, 2021
8.5
 Immortal Hulk #49 Aug 8, 2021
9.0
 Avengers (2018) #47 Aug 7, 2021

Story is pretty good, but pace could be faster.
6.0
 X-Men (2021) #2 Aug 6, 2021

Ended 12 issues too late without building anything interesting
8.0
 S.W.O.R.D. (2020) #7 Jul 28, 2021
8.0
 Wolverine (2020) #14 Jul 28, 2021

Lots of uninterestings things and not enough of the team

The story is stretching too thin, also what is wrong with mutants, they simply go taking away kids without asking

Plants some seeds for futures issues, seems like interesting stuff gonna happen. Low score because character are bland AF
8.0
 Way of X (2021) #4 Jul 14, 2021
4.0
 X-Corp (2021) #3 Jul 14, 2021

Some fun moments, the art is the best thing. new vilains really looks lame Also needs to stop writing Laura as female Wolverine, she is not like Logan

Weirdest thing is you give a invite to the only mutant member of the team and the rest can't go because they are human. Really bad writing for Ororo

Best issue after a long time
4.0
 Cable (2020) #11 Jun 30, 2021
1.5
 X-Factor (2020) #10 Jun 30, 2021
7.5
 S.W.O.R.D. (2020) #6 Jun 23, 2021

ok. Kurt is completely out of character. krakoa is all messed up
8.5
 Venom (2018) #35 Jun 19, 2021

too much pointless filler

Meh. duggan witing is extremely boring, he is trying to imitate Hickman Eeryone already knew the plot

Cancel this book already

Little patience, The main plot barely moves.

Another mostly filler issue on the Gala. Boring zzzzzz

Very little going on, too many artists. It's more of a tease

Nothing really happens, this is so boring
4.0
 Marauders (2019) #21 Jun 2, 2021

At least it attempted to do a story instead of the boring meet and greet
7.5
 Heroes Reborn (2021): Magneto & The Mutant Force #1 May 29, 2021
7.5
 New Mutants (2019) #18 May 26, 2021

One of the best issues but just a teaser
8.5
 Way of X (2021) #2 May 21, 2021

There isn't soul on the characters, they look like robots saying bussiness jargons.Monet is he caricature of a angry black woman. Things happen just because... Art is very bad on the facs, Gho colors do a good job on backgrounds
8.5
 Heroes Reborn (2021) #2 May 12, 2021

Bring back PAD
8.0
 America Chavez: Made in the USA #3 May 7, 2021
7.5
 Hellions (2020) #11 May 6, 2021
9.0
 Heroes Reborn (2021) #1 May 5, 2021
4.5
 Marauders (2019) #20 May 5, 2021
9.0
 Black Widow (2020) #5 Apr 28, 2021

What is wrong with Scott? Old cable is also your son. Story is pretty dumb and boring
8.5
 X-Men: Legends (2021) #3 Apr 28, 2021

Wastes too much time with cortez shit-talking
9.0
 Way of X (2021) #1 Apr 22, 2021

Art is so awful, almost make simpossible to read
9.5
 Iron Man (2020) #8 Apr 16, 2021

Good work on the Gabriel chaarcter beats but the story is lacking. Same story from the last week and moved very little the plot
7.0
 Guardians of the Galaxy (2020) #13 Apr 14, 2021
8.5
 Thor (2020) #14 Apr 14, 2021
9.0
 Wolverine (2020) #11 Apr 14, 2021
3.0
 Excalibur (2019) #20 Apr 7, 2021
4.5
 Marauders (2019) #19 Apr 7, 2021

Complete waste of Laura
7.0
 X-Men: Legends (2021) #2 Mar 31, 2021

Basically nothing happens, super decompressed

Shit job at being a team book and a resolution for the story
9.0
 Eternals (2021) #3 Mar 20, 2021
3.5
 Wonder Woman: Earth One #3 Mar 20, 2021
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #27 Mar 19, 2021
7.5
 S.W.O.R.D. (2020) #4 Mar 17, 2021

Too much focus on Quire. Only that last pes are really important. Art was awful, they need to find a better fill-in artist
7.5
 Children of the Atom (2021) #1 Mar 10, 2021
6.5
 Green Lantern (2018): Season Two #12 Mar 10, 2021
3.5
 X-Factor (2020) #8 Mar 10, 2021
6.0
 Infinite Frontier (2021) #0 Mar 4, 2021
10
 Avengers (2018) #43 Mar 3, 2021

Now I have to care about a rapist's family? get less rapey pls x-books
9.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #26 Feb 25, 2021

Perfect art. Maverick and Logan interactions are perfect

Too decompressed. this could have been tol in half of the issue. Waited one years for this, not worthy Art is good but I think Silva + gracia could be better for this
3.0
 Savage Avengers (2019) #18 Feb 18, 2021
9.0
 Thor (2020) #12 Feb 18, 2021
7.0
 X-Men: Legends (2021) #1 Feb 18, 2021

Really lazy script, of couse the same restaurant that Cable goes is the same that he find the villain. Also stop giving us so little of the old Cable
10
 King In Black #4 Feb 17, 2021
4.5
 Marauders (2019) #18 Feb 17, 2021
9.5
 Eternals (2021) #2 Feb 11, 2021
4.0
 Excalibur (2019) #18 Feb 11, 2021
7.5
 S.W.O.R.D. (2020) #3 Feb 10, 2021
3.5
 Future State (2021): Superman/Wonder Woman #2 Feb 9, 2021
7.0
 Avengers (2018) #42 Feb 3, 2021
8.5
 Hellblazer: Rise and Fall #3 Feb 3, 2021
8.5
 Hellions (2020) #9 Feb 3, 2021
3.5
 King In Black: Marauders #1 Feb 3, 2021

Writer cant dialogue and doesn't understand how pheromones work
8.0
 Fantastic Four (2018) #28 Jan 30, 2021
2.0
 Excalibur (2019) #17 Jan 29, 2021

Dan Mora art is really shining on Batman. the back up is very generic
8.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #25 Jan 27, 2021
8.5
 Wolverine (2020) #9 Jan 27, 2021

WTF is the shitty art

RIP duck
3.0
 Cable (2020) #7 Jan 20, 2021
8.5
 King In Black #3 Jan 20, 2021
8.5
 X-Force (2019) #16 Jan 20, 2021
1.0
 Future State (2021): Superman/Wonder Woman #1 Jan 13, 2021

Pure bore and bad fan-service
7.5
 S.W.O.R.D. (2020) #2 Jan 13, 2021

A bit rough to read, but the hook is interesting
8.0
 Crossover (2020) #3 Jan 6, 2021
9.5
 Eternals (2021) #1 Jan 6, 2021
6.0
 Guardians of the Galaxy (2020) #10 Jan 6, 2021
8.0
 Hellions (2020) #8 Jan 6, 2021
8.5
 Thor (2020) #11 Jan 6, 2021

Jokes and references of pop culture, really boring book
10
 Power Pack (2020) #1 Dec 31, 2020

This book is so fun! great work by North and Leon

Great captain america issue
8.0
 Wolverine (2020) #8 Dec 30, 2020

16 issues , tons of boring worldbuilding

very mediocre writing, bunch of people talking terrible dialogues

Mostly a setup for the event and tie-ins.

8.5
 Immortal Hulk #41 Dec 16, 2020
9.5
 King In Black: Immortal Hulk #1 Dec 16, 2020
8.0
 New Mutants (2019) #14 Dec 16, 2020
8.0
 X-Force (2019) #15 Dec 16, 2020
7.0
 Excalibur (2019) #1 Dec 10, 2020
5.0
 Excalibur (2019) #2 Dec 10, 2020
5.5
 Excalibur (2019) #3 Dec 10, 2020
4.5
 Excalibur (2019) #8 Dec 10, 2020
7.5
 S.W.O.R.D. (2020) #1 Dec 10, 2020
9.5
 Avengers (2018) #39 Dec 9, 2020
9.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #24 Dec 9, 2020
2.0
 Guardians of the Galaxy (2020) #9 Dec 9, 2020
2.0
 Marauders (2019) #16 Dec 9, 2020
8.0
 The Union (2020) #1 Dec 8, 2020
2.0
 Savage Avengers (2019) #15 Dec 3, 2020

This issue has one of my favorite comics page. Delightful!!
9.5
 Thor (2020) #10 Dec 3, 2020
9.0
 Black Widow (2020) #4 Dec 2, 2020
6.0
 Hellions (2020) #7 Dec 2, 2020
10
 King In Black #1 Dec 2, 2020
3.0
 X-Factor (2020) #5 Dec 2, 2020
1.0
 Cable (2020) #6 Nov 26, 2020
1.0
 Excalibur (2019) #15 Nov 25, 2020

The thing tat gets me most is that Saturnyne gets to be all powerful, but still needs a man to comlete her. ow in being a multiversal entity sh never finds a brian to likes her. LOL

Lots of talking and kissing Cyclops's feet

Again a solid issue Best book of XOS

Mostly dumb fights to padding

So much for a fight and it lats 2 pages. LOL

what a complete joke of a event. The cliffhanger was just a fake and some relly dumb jokes.

Art is really great here. But the writing is all over the place
2.5
 Marauders (2019) #14 Nov 4, 2020

Recycle art, recycle 80% of the story. I don't even care about Arakko and Krakoa story anymore
9.5
 Immortal Hulk #39 Nov 1, 2020
7.5
 Batman: Three Jokers (2020) #3 Oct 30, 2020
7.0
 X Of Swords (2020): Handbook #1 Oct 28, 2020

The pace of this event really drags. 11 issues in and they are still talking. Only the art is good and it still had a fill in.

This issue was a mess, betsy chaarcter is all over the place

Really nice hooks on this issue. Love Grimm as a father
7.5
 Juggernaut (2020) #2 Oct 21, 2020

A laughable cheap retcon.

Just ok issue. barely had anything to do with XOS
7.5
 Hellions (2020) #5 Oct 14, 2020
7.0
 New Mutants (2019) #13 Oct 14, 2020

This is the weakest issue.

8.5
 Black Widow (2020) #2 Oct 8, 2020

The story is too contrived. I liked the voice for ororo, but the whole set up was crap
7.5
 Wolverine (2020) #6 Oct 7, 2020
7.5
 X-Force (2019) #13 Oct 7, 2020
7.5
 Avengers (2018) #36 Sep 30, 2020

Pace is really awful, they don't have story for fill a issue. So they have pages and more pages of characters talking with each other like idiots. So now they create a problem with ressurrection, completely nosense. X of swords is really awful and no-sense. The art is good.
7.5
 Batman: Three Jokers (2020) #2 Sep 29, 2020

The writer should go straight to what she wants. This remember me about Rucka rebirth first arc but worse. Diana still seems in doubt what is true or not and next issue seems to have nothing to do with that. This first arc could have been less issues
8.5
 Daredevil (2019) #22 Sep 25, 2020
8.5
 Immortal She-Hulk #1 Sep 23, 2020

Nice fanfic here This is a tournament event mehh

Nice fanfiction, seems like the witer wanted Scott to be autistic and trans

Read this issue and #0 it is like comic book heaven
8.5
 Captain America (2018) #23 Sep 16, 2020

Characters really act dumb here. In a moment Rictor is mad at apocalypse and moments later he does what he asks and kill mutants. betsy doesn't do anything and is bad at her job of being captain britain. Rogue do nothing. Gambit has the chance to screw apocalypse plans but does what apocalypse asks, gambit since first issue doesn't trust him. So they all helped Krakoa enter a war that will have a big costo to krakoa.
7.0
 Giant-Size X-Men (2020): Storm #1 Sep 16, 2020
8.5
 Hellions (2020) #4 Sep 16, 2020

A very engaging first issue, the best iron Man relaunch in years. Art is so good too

I like that this issue seemed to be a big filler, but it is really important and have some funny moments.

It is a info dump.

A bit directionless, as there is a lot to close. Thor is great here This is the reason FF exists: Family.

9.5
 Empyre: Aftermath: Avengers #1 Sep 9, 2020

It's a team book or justa Kitty/Emma book? Wolverine said more words than 3 chaarcter of the cast of the book? Lolli art is also not the best.

a bloody mess. There is really a lot of bloody on this issue. Basically no detective work was made again, only first issue had it. The whole cast seems to have 14

8.0
 X-Force (2019) #12 Sep 9, 2020

Solid first issue. pencils and color is on point

The writing for Cable continue to be dumb and awful.
8.5
 Empyre #6 Sep 2, 2020

Glob with the most generic mutant backstory. Also the book seems to forget that mutants can be ressurrected
8.0
 Wolverine (2020) #5 Sep 2, 2020
7.5
 Hellions (2020) #3 Aug 26, 2020

I really liked the costumes. But the writing is so forced to keep it fun, that forgets to get the story going.

Mostly a filler issue before the xover starts
8.5
 Captain America (2018) #22 Aug 25, 2020
8.0
 Wonder Woman (2016) #761 Aug 25, 2020
6.0
 Wolverine (2020) #3 Aug 21, 2020
8.0
 Wolverine (2020) #4 Aug 21, 2020

This is a crime, a book with deadpool that isn't funny. very little happens, lots o padding. BORING

Really fun.Chewie being cute Nice cliffhanger

Hickman is extremely misogynistic with Wanda.

They really so some dumb things and then are "oh why she shoot us?"

This issue deserves a 10.

9.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #19 Aug 12, 2020
8.0
 Dark Nights: Death Metal #2 Aug 12, 2020
7.5
 Dark Nights: Death Metal #3 Aug 12, 2020
9.5
 Empyre #5 Aug 12, 2020

I don't get why empyre is receiving bad reviews from critics, it is very obvious their bias and unprofessionalism

Better issue than last week.

Anti-climatic, lazy explanations, feels like a solo comic; and always pandering Also the problem of cremating a jewish on a viking cerimony

The end is a very predictable, but overall a good comic

again a invasion to the krakoa island mehhhhhhh good work on colossus

9.0
 Captain America (2018) #21 Aug 6, 2020

Nice to see Wade calling out the new era of x-men

Other issue, another plot twist

Art is so great But again bad writing just waste it, some really cringe twitter jokes

Art is really great, best from the one shots Story is really light here, a big waste for the excellent art from Reis
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #17 Aug 1, 2020

Art is very good But the books lakcs some direction. I like that they are rescuing mutants like they did on bendis run, but the book needs more. Also enough with Glob
9.0
 Immortal Hulk #35 Jul 31, 2020
4.5
 X-Men (2019) #3 Jul 31, 2020
7.5
 X-Men (2019) #5 Jul 31, 2020
7.0
 X-Men (2019) #6 Jul 31, 2020

Really boring. Full of cliches

Cory Smith art is pretty good seems the start of a interesting story
7.5
 Empyre #3 Jul 29, 2020

Boneyard It all reads like bad fanfic. There is some interesting bits, but it doesn't hold up
5.0
 X-Men (2019) #7 Jul 29, 2020

plot holes some awful characterization

This would work better if there was a x-corp ongoing, instead of just dropping the concept like a brick. of course Wanda screw up again. Wow such a new concept Art is pretty great
7.5
 Hellions (2020) #2 Jul 22, 2020

mostly 4 issues of nothing. A fair talk could had solved this; I doubt FF books will acknowledge anything from this
4.0
 Superman / Wonder Woman (2013) #28 Jul 19, 2020
5.0
 Superman / Wonder Woman (2013) #29 Jul 19, 2020
7.0
 Avengers (2018) #34 Jul 18, 2020
7.0
 FCBD 2020: X-Men #1 Jul 17, 2020
8.0
 Empyre #1 Jul 15, 2020

art was ok. Story was too decompressed and had some problems. Emma could had contacted Namor by telepathy. Lots of pages of only landscapes with nothing really happening, too little about the title character. 4 pages could had told this story
6.0
 Giant-Size X-Men (2020): Jean Grey And Emma Frost #1 Jul 15, 2020
7.0
 X-Force (2019) #8 Jul 10, 2020
1.0
 X-Force (2019) #10 Jul 8, 2020

Good ideas but bad execution.

Art is really good and trippy. Story is very ok, Brisson have to stop his glob obsession

I don't get why users are mad that people are voting this issue down. It's not a good comic, it has bad writing all over it. 1 is even generous for this
9.5
 Avengers (2018) #33 May 27, 2020
4.5
 Marauders (2019) #10 May 27, 2020
10
 Wolverine (2020) #2 Mar 26, 2020
4.5
 X-Men (2019) #9 Mar 26, 2020

Mostly filler too little nightcrawler

Bad chaarcterization for both teams.
7.0
 Excalibur (2019) #9 Mar 18, 2020
10
 X-Force (2019) #9 Mar 18, 2020
7.5
 X-Men (2019) #8 Mar 12, 2020

Book is fun, but the characters are generic and humor is also generic AF. It reads like a kids comic
7.0
 Excalibur (2019) #4 Mar 8, 2020
4.0
 Excalibur (2019) #5 Mar 8, 2020
5.0
 Excalibur (2019) #6 Mar 8, 2020
6.0
 Excalibur (2019) #7 Mar 8, 2020

Plot really slow and barely progresses. Lack of storm and Iceman mourning Kitty

Very dissapointing first issue, I expected more from zdarsky

Dumb fights for the sak eof moving the plots.
1.0
 Marauders (2019) #3 Mar 4, 2020
3.0
 Marauders (2019) #4 Mar 4, 2020
4.5
 Marauders (2019) #5 Mar 4, 2020
6.5
 Marauders (2019) #6 Mar 4, 2020
5.0
 Marauders (2019) #7 Mar 4, 2020
7.0
 Marauders (2019) #8 Mar 4, 2020

This is a great #1. Really like the direction of this series
9.5
 Thor (2020) #2 Mar 4, 2020
9.0
 Thor (2020) #3 Mar 4, 2020

Reviews for the Week of...

November

27th 20th 13th 6th

October

30th 23rd
More
© 2024