5.3 |
Overall Rating |
5.0 |
Avengers (2023) | 1 issues |
5.0 |
Avengers (2023) #21
Dec 4, 2024 |
I enjoy reading the occasional issue where the talking and socialising take precedence over the action, however, it seems that not much is happening in this title at all, since I started reading it a few issues ago (yes, because of Storm).I’ve never been a big Avengers fan, but they have had several great runs over the years that I enjoyed, with great art and writing and interesting character dynamics. This isn’t one of those. The art ist very average in my opinion - readable, but very sketchy and just not very beautiful. And the writing - let’s just say X-Men and Avengers are my least favorite books right now, and it can’t be coincidence that McKay is writing both of them. Yes, something is happening, but it all feels very underwhelming, almost like a half-assed attempt at reviving a corpse. |
10 |
Batman & Robin: Year One (2024) | 1 issues |
10 |
Batman & Robin: Year One (2024) #1
Nov 25, 2024 |
Waid and Samnee perfectly capture Batman's broodiness and Robin's youthful exuberance. The book feels cinematic, atmospheric and nostalgic, but not dated, which is a huge feat to accomplish. I haven't read a Batman comic in decades, and this was a wonderful re-introduction. |
1.0 |
Dazzler (2024) | 1 issues |
1.0 |
Dazzler (2024) #1
Dec 2, 2024 |
I was always a Dazzler fan, but this is just identity cult indoctrination with some disco make-up. The art is decent, but I have to give the worst rating for this shameless sham. |
10 |
Detective Comics (2016) | 1 issues |
10 |
Detective Comics (2016) #1090
Nov 30, 2024 |
I haven’t read a DC title in many years, but with Marvel going downhill, I decided to give the competition another chance. The art in this book was the best I could find in the current DC titles, so I decided to start with Detective Comics 1090. Let’s just say, it blew me away. A perfectly written, perfectly drawn comic.I hope this team stays on the title for a long while. |
2.7 |
Exceptional X-Men (2024) | 3 issues |
2.0 |
Exceptional X-Men (2024) #1
Nov 25, 2024 |
2.0 |
Exceptional X-Men (2024) #2
Nov 25, 2024 |
Woke identity crap disguised as an X-Men comic. At least the art is solid. |
|
4.0 |
Exceptional X-Men (2024) #3
Nov 25, 2024 |
I found this issue a bit less annoying than the previous ones. However, it's still all about preaching identity politics and how not to be a bigot. The only thing I really like about this book is Carnero's art. She deserves a better book. |
7.0 |
Nyx (2024) | 1 issues |
7.0 |
Nyx (2024) #4
Nov 25, 2024 |
NYX is just as preachy as Exceptional X-Men, but where that book is dull and depressing, this one at least has some fun and excitement. |
5.0 |
Storm (2024) | 1 issues |
5.0 |
Storm (2024) #2
Nov 25, 2024 |
Storm is my favorite superhero, but her solo series haven't been great for one reason or another. Unlike previous series, this one has already introduced some intriguing ideas. However, it suffers from the decompressed pin-up-y art and storytelling. Werneck is a great costume designer, but in my opinion, he's not a great comic book artist. Spending four pages on a costume change in issue 1 was frustrating already. This second issue has a lot of empty space and large panels, which makes it an unsatisfying five minute read. |
7.0 |
Superman (2023) | 1 issues |
7.0 |
Superman (2023) #19
Dec 1, 2024 |
A solid story, but I’m not a fan of this Manga-influenced art, especially not for Superman |
6.0 |
The Rocketfellers (2024) | 1 issues |
6.0 |
The Rocketfellers (2024) #1
Nov 25, 2024 |
The concept of Rocketfellers (horrible name by the way) reminds me of Mark Millar‘s Chrononauts, but the writing and art are not on the same level. I like the family though, and with a more capable artist, it could draw me in. |
5.0 |
Uncanny X-Men (2024) | 2 issues |
7.0 |
Uncanny X-Men (2024) #5
Nov 25, 2024 |
What the heck is happening? Marquez's art is great as usual, but I don't get this story at all. What am I missing here? How did the Hag become what she is now? Who are these creatures suddenly appearing to fight the X-Men? For a conclusion to the first story arc, this issue doesn't provide a lot of answers. |
|
3.0 |
Uncanny X-Men (2024) #6
Nov 28, 2024 |
This issue was torture. While there is an attempt at actual storytelling, nothing really works. It’s particularly frustrating when Simone sets up an important character moment for Calico, but then makes her change her attitude completely out of the blue. Rogue credits Gambit’s people skills, but he did nothing to cause such a dramatic change from one panel to the next. Weird! There’s also a lot of hugging and cutesy victim mentality stuff that obviously caters to the younger woke generation of readers, but will most likely p*ss off older readers. I certainly have had enough of this title. |
8.0 |
West Coast Avengers (2024) | 1 issues |
8.0 |
West Coast Avengers (2024) #1
Nov 28, 2024 |
I really enjoyed this first issue. It has some great character moments, good dialogue and an intriguing story that makes me want to come back for more. Something about this series feels very nostalgic and charming, despite the fact that it’s an almost completely new team of West Coast Avengers. The biggest problem for me is the inconsistent art. It’s great in some places and quite horrible in others. Something tells me that with some more practice, Kim could become really good though. |
3.0 |
Wonder Woman (2023) | 1 issues |
3.0 |
Wonder Woman (2023) #14
Dec 2, 2024 |
I never read a Wonder Woman issue before, so I was hoping for this issue to be a great jumping on point, but this wasn’t it. The story definitely feels ambitious, but I understood literally nothing about what’s going on or who the characters are. Apparently WW’s lover died and it’s told in a way that is maybe very artistic, but not very welcoming to new readers. The art in this book is simply amazing, but it didn’t help making me care for the character. |
7.0 |
X-Factor (2024) | 1 issues |
7.0 |
X-Factor (2024) #4
Nov 25, 2024 |
This is the best of the current X-books in my opinion. It's not great, but at least I don't hate it. |
6.0 |
X-Force (2024) | 1 issues |
6.0 |
X-Force (2024) #5
Nov 25, 2024 |
With To's art and this line-up - Betsy, Rachel and Forge are all-time favorites of mine - X-Force has the potential to be a great book. However, it's very light on story, up to the point where I'm not sure if there's a story at all. Overall, it's just not very exciting. However, the death scene in this issue was handled quite well. |
2.0 |
X-Men (2024) | 1 issues |
2.0 |
X-Men (2024) #1
Nov 25, 2024 |
Both the writing and art are sub par. The art especially is just atrocious to look at. No. Just no. |