Williamflipper's Profile

Joined: Feb 16, 2023

Filter By:
6.8
Overall Rating

Embarrassing. Scott Cavan doesn't know how to plot a story nor write human dialogues.

The art is serviceable but the panels are boring and static. As a first issue the story feel generic and pointless.

Blwhaaarg! Jose Lus is a talented drawer. Cavan Scott is not a writer, he may be not a real person either. I'm almost sure that the plot and the dialogues are software generated. (I'm copying and pasting my own thought at this point)

It is getting dumber and dumber, luckily I bought the issues on a heavy discount...

Waste of time and paper. It is not an opinion, just a fact.
2.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #20 Feb 24, 2023

Jose Lus is a talented drawer. Cavan Scott is not a writer, he may be not a real person either. I'm almost sure that the plot and the dialogues are software generated. (I'm copying and pasting my own thought at this point)
3.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #17 Feb 24, 2023
3.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #18 Feb 24, 2023
3.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #19 Feb 24, 2023

Imagine the worst vampire/action anime from the early'90. Now imagine that someone at Marvel went thrift shopping and found that forgotten anime script, added some "dialogue" some colours.. and here we go.

The Beyonder, again. This month we got the of The Defenders Beyond (with the beyonder), we got also All Out Avengers (with the beyonder in it) and so on.

Please Millar kill the main characters,give us a nice payoff. Ramirez art is solid. I'm going to keep buying it just because of the low cover price and the visuals

Massive disappointment. The art is rushed and plain. The dialogues are laughable. The plot is so overplayed and lazy.

Jose Lus is a talented drawer. Cavan Scott is not a writer, he may be not a real person either. I'm almost sure that the plot and the dialogues are software generated.

3.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #14 Feb 24, 2023
3.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #15 Feb 24, 2023

I loved this she-hulk until the previous issue but clearly the artist had just 8 pages of material to fill up this particular issue. The art is rushed and small panels are enlarged to fill up pages. Even the captions are enlarged. I'm not joking, you can clearly see how small panels are used as full pages.

4.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #16 Feb 24, 2023

Pointless and boring first issue, good art but nothing really happened.

Of course another multiversity plot.

Out of the left field. How does the scientist know that spider man got is power from a bite of a spider escaped from a lab? The art is flat, the plot is dumb.

Great arts by Jose Lus. Atrocious writing. Everyone on the Titans team act and speak like a 14 years old and the plot is contrived and absurd.

The art is great the plot is generic and the dialogues are cringe inducing, most likely an high school pitch made reality a decade later.
4.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #6 Feb 16, 2023

I loved the first 2 issues but I would not read this issue again. The art is good but the story is weak and feel like a worker right awareness campaign issue wrote by committee. The subject matter should be treated with intelligence and talent.

The dialogues are awful. A level on Megaman has more character development than this issue. Here you can observe a fight with a generic wolfman and enjoy the company of your annoying sidekick and some dumb kids. The art still good.

The only redeeming part is Ramirez kinetic art. The protagonist is a lame moron and his friends are a bunch of demented loosers.

I'm in for the art and the bargain cover price. I wish to the main characters to be killed in the next few issues. I hope it is wath Millar is going for.

Lazy writing, there is not enough material to justified these 20 pages. The actions feel forced and contrived. Art is fine.

I like the romance and the interaction between Jen and Jack but the art is rushed and phoned in

Another waste of paper and ink. Useless tie-in.
5.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #7 Feb 16, 2023

Art still stiff and repetitive. Plot is dumb

Some really great pages to look at...but still boring dumb and stiff for most of the issue

Part of the worthless fear state event. Just skip it is getting dumber.

Massive drop in writing... the first 6 issues were amazing... it's been up and down since then...I just realised that it's been a year since I actually truly enjoyed this run... I'm done

Great art and beautiful colours. Lazy story and strangely awkward dialogues.

Forgettable issue with some awful short stories at the end. Waste of paper and ink.

Weak issue. Throwback '80 avengers and wolverine poker night story.

Art is stiff plot is dumb

Cross over issue. Skip it.

Part of the worthless fear state event. Just skip it

Wrong format for the content. Intriguing prologue, not enough reading material and visually muted. It may be a great graphic novel but as a monthly floppy it doesn't work.

Here we are at the level 3 of the Marvel Ultimate Alliance 4 video game for your Switch.

The art is good but there is a proper story yet. It feel like a prologue but the main characters are not interesting and without a personality. Kind of generic schlock.

6.0
 Almighty (2023) #1 Feb 19, 2023
6.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #10 Feb 24, 2023
6.0
 Arkham Horror (2024): The Terror at the End of Time #1 Oct 15, 2024

Enjoyable enough nostalgia trip. Weirdly I found myself quite bored and I was relived when I finally turned the last page. I like the Kirby/Lee avengers, I found this issues enjoyable and pointless at the same time. Sadly just forgettable. I will still buy every following issue because, weirdly enough, it is the best monthly Avengers comic right now

I'm fighting with myself. I still think that this series is enjoyable and pointless at the same time. Mildly unnecessary. I will still buy every following issue because, weirdly enough, still is the best monthly Avengers comic right now

13 issues without a satisfying ending. Wasn't bad, cute but forgettable. No reason to buy a physical copy.

Odd writing.. not as good as the previous issues..lost some steam and urgency..

This issue could be easily contained in two pages. Nice slice of life moment stretched too thin that feels like parody.
6.0
 Poison Ivy (2022) #17 Nov 9, 2024

I'm not sure. The art is fine but somehow lazy in his storytelling. The plot is similar to an arcade video game.

Again, the art still fine but the layout are boring. It feel like an adaptation of an arcade video game ( Marvel ultimate alliance style )

Messy first issue, it's more of a prologue for the things to come. It is not a satisfying read.

The story is getting really slooooow and repetitive repetitive repetitive. Art is passable.

It start to drag a little bit, of course doctor strange is coming back, I knew it already but there is no more suspense. Art still good, I just start caring less.

I'm not feeling it anymore. I love the first 5 issues still

Big end battle but I could not care at all.

6.0
 Werewolf by Night: Red Band (2024) #2 Oct 15, 2024
6.5
 Arkham Horror (2024): The Terror at the End of Time #2 Oct 15, 2024
6.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #18 Feb 16, 2023
6.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #19 Feb 16, 2023
6.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #20 Feb 16, 2023
6.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #21 Feb 16, 2023
6.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #22 Feb 16, 2023
6.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #28 Feb 16, 2023
6.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #45 May 21, 2023
6.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #46 May 21, 2023

Pretty good story beat this monthly format is damaging the enjoyment overall. The story feel randomly truncated without giving any pay off.

It's interesting. A super simple ghost in the shell mixed with Sabrina the witch. The art is really good, the story is quite basic and been done plenty of time in Manga, in 2000AD and all over europe.

It's getting better. Some plot twist.

Too cheesy and contrive as a issue.

6.5
 Poison Ivy (2022) #12 Nov 7, 2024
6.5
 Poison Ivy (2022) #13 Nov 7, 2024

Half baked issue. Beautiful art redundant fairy tale dialogues.

6.5
 Strange (2022) #6 Feb 16, 2023

Enjoyable but I should wait to read it on the Marvel unlimited app. I'm not going to keep the physical issues. Was an ok read but I would not read it again.
7.0
 Birds of Prey (2023) #9 Nov 13, 2024

Cute
7.0
 Birds of Prey (2023) #11 Nov 17, 2024
7.0
 Birds of Prey (2023) #12 Nov 17, 2024
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #5 Feb 16, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #12 Feb 16, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #13 Feb 16, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #14 Feb 16, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #15 Feb 16, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #16 Feb 16, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #23 Feb 16, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #24 Feb 16, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #25 Feb 16, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #26 Feb 16, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #32 Feb 16, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #33 Feb 16, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #34 Feb 16, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #43 May 21, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #47 May 21, 2023
7.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #48 May 21, 2023

It's ok
7.0
 Savage Dragon (1993) #2 Apr 29, 2023

Improvement overall.

Improvement.
7.0
 Werewolf by Night: Red Band (2024) #1 Oct 15, 2024
7.5
 Batgirls (2021) #6 Feb 16, 2023
7.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #2 Feb 16, 2023
7.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #29 Feb 16, 2023
7.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #35 Feb 16, 2023
7.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #44 May 21, 2023

Enjoyable space western. Better than expected.

It is interesting enough. There is an actual plot with well written dialogues. Art solid and a desire to see what's next.

Nice noire horror flick.

I'm surprised by how much pop corn fun it is. Nice slasher horror demon flick. I'm glad to have finally tried to read some spawn comics.
7.5
 Savage Dragon (1993) #1 Apr 29, 2023
7.5
 Savage Dragon (1993) #3 Apr 29, 2023
7.5
 X-Terminators (2022) #3 Mar 23, 2023
8.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #8 Feb 24, 2023
8.0
 Batgirls (2021) #7 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Birds of Prey (2023) #1 Nov 13, 2024
8.0
 Birds of Prey (2023) #2 Nov 13, 2024
8.0
 Birds of Prey (2023) #3 Nov 13, 2024
8.0
 Birds of Prey (2023) #4 Nov 13, 2024
8.0
 Birds of Prey (2023) #5 Nov 13, 2024
8.0
 Birds of Prey (2023) #6 Nov 13, 2024
8.0
 Birds of Prey (2023) #7 Nov 13, 2024
8.0
 Birds of Prey (2023) #8 Nov 13, 2024
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #1 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #3 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #4 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #8 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #9 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #10 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #11 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #27 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #30 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #31 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #36 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #37 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #38 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #39 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #40 Feb 16, 2023
8.0
 Captain Marvel (2019) #42 May 21, 2023

Black and white gruesome dark story. The art remind me of the '80 underground Caliber Press / Mirage Studio comics. Good pacing and layout. Only issue I got is with the lettering, it's too big and sometimes it obscure the pannel.

8.0
 Fantastic Four (2022) #2 Feb 16, 2023

Enjoyable slasher noir arc. Nice art

Intriguing. Well written dialogues and great atmosphere. Great 48 pages format.
8.0
 Nightwing (2016) #81 Mar 23, 2023
8.0
 Nightwing (2016) #82 Mar 23, 2023
8.0
 Nightwing (2016) #87 Mar 23, 2023
8.0
 Nightwing (2016) #88 Mar 23, 2023

Back to greatness again. Great art and intriguing promises.

Good not as great as the firs 6 issues but better than anything else DC is printing this past two years.
8.0
 Poison Ivy (2022) #14 Nov 7, 2024
8.0
 Poison Ivy (2022) #15 Nov 7, 2024
8.0
 Savage Dragon (1993) #4 Apr 29, 2023

Fun read. Nice art. We are getting some more world building and social interaction. There is some good potential.

Interesting slice of life and character building issue. We are at a tipping point.
8.0
 Strange (2022) #3 Feb 16, 2023

Promising story and great art.
8.0
 X-Terminators (2022) #1 Mar 23, 2023
8.0
 X-Terminators (2022) #2 Mar 23, 2023
8.0
 X-Terminators (2022) #4 Mar 23, 2023
8.0
 X-Terminators (2022) #5 Mar 23, 2023

Exciting beginning
8.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #2 Feb 24, 2023

Exciting still.
8.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #4 Feb 24, 2023
8.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #5 Feb 24, 2023
8.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #7 Feb 24, 2023
8.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #11 Feb 24, 2023
8.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #12 Feb 24, 2023
8.5
 Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #13 Feb 24, 2023
8.5
 Briar (2022) #1 Feb 16, 2023
8.5
 Briar (2022) #2 Feb 16, 2023
8.5
 Captain Marvel (2019) #41 Feb 16, 2023

Great art intriguing story

Extremely enjoyable. Art always good

love it.
8.5
 Nightwing (2016) #80 Mar 23, 2023

Great start.

Nice slice of life plus mystery story

A really enjoyable fun series to follow

Promising sci fi surreal story. Blade runner meets Satoshi Kon's Paprika/ Paranoia Agent.

9.0
 Black Tape (2023) #1 Feb 16, 2023
9.0
 Fantastic Four (2022) #1 Feb 16, 2023

Great fun. Great art

Solid action and good dialogues. The art is so alive and vibrant, top class.

Great fun. Top visuals. Intriguing plot.

9.0
 Nightwing (2016) #78 Mar 23, 2023
9.0
 Nightwing (2016) #79 Mar 23, 2023

Unbelievably good. The art is not amazing but it fits perfectly the mood and the story.

Beautiful art and promising story

Still a great read and nice to look at.

Swamp thing / Sandman vertigo era DC vibe

Again and better Swamp thing / Sandman vertigo era DC vibe

Great overall.
9.0
 Poison Ivy (2022) #16 Nov 7, 2024

A splendid return of Jack of Hearts! The art is great so are the dialogues
9.0
 Strange (2022) #1 Feb 16, 2023
9.0
 Strange (2022) #2 Feb 16, 2023
9.0
 Strange (2022) #4 Feb 16, 2023
9.0
 Strange (2022) #5 Feb 16, 2023

It is getting even more engaging.

Great ending. Fulfilling. I hope they are not going to ruin everything. It should just end like this.

Reviews for the Week of...

December

4th

November

27th 20th 13th 6th
More
© 2024