If you thought Death Metal was pretty dumb, then this one knocks it out of the park with how badly it mangles up its own story. Those who are illiterate would love this, however. Tailor-made for those without critical thinking. It's funny how corporate simps like Fenix have nothing to say about the writing quality of the books, only the marketing budget.

Imagine how good this could be if Sean Gordon Murphy had nothing to do with it.

Fables went to shit after 60 issues, and this continues the trend. Perfectly made for the lowest common denominator.

Bill Willingham's brain has deteriorated so much that he's forgotten how to write. Beware of shills giving this above a 5, they likely have a parasocial relationship with Willingham. I almost feel sorry for them.

Sales for this series have been atrocious, especially for a heavily promoted Batman Black Label book. There's a good reason why.

Bill Willingham has a loud and clear message: if you have an IQ over 50, then this is not for you.

It's the worst-selling Batman Black Label book for good reason

LMAO Azzarello is a clown, a self-caricature of his former self. Tries desperately so hard to be controversial, but can't do anything other than make a boring, lifeless comic.

edgelord nonsense, corporately manufactured for the lowest common denominator

Azzarello understands Jason Todd as a character very well, and he's 100% on his analysis. Unfortunately, he fails to do anything to break the cycle of terribly written Red Hood books.

I've always said that Hush was a shallow and overrated piece of trash made solely for the lowest common denominator, the type of person who lacks the brainpower to critically dissect a poorly written mystery. Jeph Loeb is in full Ultimatum form here, a hack who depends solely on his name and corporate branding to sell. Looks like I was proven 100% right, looking at the people who are desperately shilling for this, like the pedophile apologist and his weird parasocial relationship.

What a cringefest. Murphy should take some time to learn how to write instead of name-searching himself on Twitter on the time. Just shows that being friends with Scott Snyder is more important to DC than having writing talent.

You can read the exact same thing on a fanfic site for free.

I wonder how many fanfic writers are going to sue Murphy for plagiarism?

I almost feel sorry for people who've wasted so much money on this Tumblr fic that have to trick themselves into liking it.

Bland and lifeless. Johns once again proving that he can't write Batman for shit. His dedicated fanboys might spam this with 10s and send death threats to anyone who disagrees, but bad writing is bad writing.

AHAHAHAHAHAHA! This is hilariously bad.

I can't imagine how much Stockholm Syndrome one must be suffering through to keep reading Spencer's run instead of Spider's Shadow.

Comic written for the lowest common denominator.

Tries too hard with gimmicky guest stars. Dialogue is really bad with cliched one-liners bouncing all around (even worse than Bendis). It tries to go for an emotional moment near the end, but it fails because the narrator won't shut up. Surprised that this didn't get canceled.

This was really bad. The majority of the issue was just bland exposition recapping previous issues, with some low-brow jokes scattered throughout. A very amateurly made comic.

Easily the weakest part of an otherwise strong event. Characterization is very weak here, with Jason once again whining endlessly about how he never lived up to Dick. The Roy and Joker's Daughter adventure ended up being mainly pointless. Worthless exposition continues to be haphazardly thrown around the pages.

Bland dialogue that has to explain everything to the reader, empty plot developments, Jason being a self-insert character, and bad artwork. The usual.

Basically a badly mishandled ripoff of a Grant Morrison meta joke.

It's little wonder why pre-order sales are so bad for this.

Interesting. A lot corporate sock puppet accounts have come out for this book.

Bland, dull, and uninspired with gimmicky art. Story is made for the lowest common denominator, which makes perfect sense when you look at the sock puppets giving this book 8-10s.

The reveal was really dumb. Go read Urban Legends instead.

Dull, and too desperate to parrot manga instead of doing its own thing. This is "we have manga at home" of comics. The fact that Red Hood fanboys are only talking about "feats" and "power levels" shows you the IQ level of who this panders to.

Who is this for again?

This book is so pointless. It's a boring exposition dump on half-ass pages that DC decided to call "manga-inspired" because they couldn't bother to pay a colorist. Just bad writing all around. I pity the people who have to keep convincing themselves that this is amazing.

Bland, dull, and cliched, with embarrassingly bad art. Man-Bat died for this? lol

I can see why this book is being canceled. Sales are pretty low, huh? There are more sock puppet accounts astroturfing this than there are people reading. You can tell how they all use the same writing style. Very similar to a certain account that got banned for perverted and unspeakable deeds. It's very worrying, I fear his mental health will not hold up. Hopefully, he's barred from touching any guns.

Ouch. No wonder sales are so low. Rosenberg should maybe stick to his indies, they're much better.

Barebones story that feigns complexity with overly gritty stylistic choices.

Low effort "edge" and shock value. A lot of excess and pretentiousness with nothing to show for it. In a year with no shortage of shitty Scott Lobdell and James Robinson comics, this might actually be the stupidest thing DC has published.

Oh look! Trump memes! So funny and political!

Bland and tailor-made for the lowest common denominator. Why is Johns getting to hold the JSA hostage when there are so many more competent writers again? lol the cult of johns is mad at me again

Nostalgia grab targeted at the lowest common denominator with nothing to add, other than Jeph Loeb desperately clinging to relevance. Waste of perfectly good Tim Sale art. I almost pity those who manage to trick themselves into thinking that this is anything else. Highly recommended for anyone who doesn't care about quality writing, and just wants to blindly consume corporate-made products.

Bland and cliched drivel. Every time a Johns fan harasses me for not blindly drinking the kool-aid, I'm gonna knock it down another point.

Without support of corporate brands, Geoff Johns has nothing but just shitty Fallout fanfiction.

If Geoff Johns wanted to write shitty Fallout fanfiction, he should have just signed up for AO3 instead.

A Jason-centric issue that accomplishes what it needs to, but still relies too much on flashbacks and exposition to drive the plot forward. Soy's art does the heavy lifting here. Lobdell's dialogue fluctuates between passable and groanworthy.

3 issues in, this book is what it is: a character fan service book full with awkward narration and quips that aren't quite as funny as the writer thinks they are. There's very little in the way of a plot, conflict, and tension.

Laughably awkward issue about Red Hood projecting his daddy issues all around him. The eyeroll-worthy parallel that the writer attempts to draw between Jason's resurrection and Bizarro's revival would be comical if the writer didn't expect readers to take it so seriously.

Bad dialogue, contrived plotting, unearned "emotional" moments. Standard Lobdell schlock.

Jason stabs someone with a flag, and sticks a flare up someone's butt. 90s edge taken to its cringiest extreme.

Marvel has Chip Zdarsky writing excellent Spider-Man stories and yet ASM has been trash for years.

Would have worked better had it not distracted itself with the tired "Jason Todd is violent" themes and focused on more on Batman's psyche. Also has trouble fitting in with the awful Millerverse.

Chock full of unearned touchy-feely moments that do nothing but call back to one of the worst books of the New 52.

It's not terrible, just mediocre. Rehashes a bunch of familiar elements without adding anything new. Tries too hard for cheap emotional moments, but lacks the logical progression from scene to scene. The book's plot is relegated to just after-the-fact exposition. The characterization just comes off flat, and the direction seems that this book is going to just be a poor man's Grayson. Soy's nice art is sadly wasted.

Completely toothless, especially after Priest's excellent run, but I guess 4channers need someone they can relate to.

More interesting than the event itself, and the best "Justice League" issue of Rebirth.

Spencer dropped the ball hard on this loooong time ago. He's just writing for the lowest common denominator at this point. No one gives a shit about Kindred anymore.

Put it to rest already.

Once again, does anyone give a shit about Kindred anymore? No wonder Marvel is desperate to kick Spencer off.

Imagine taking 80 issues to retcon a single story no one considered canon anyway.

yawwwwwn

Can't imagine how thin-skinned some people are.

A bland and lifeless start.

Kind of a pointless book. Just generic movie synergy without any of the charm or charisma.

Boring synergy isn't going to convince movie watchers to read this.

Not a good issue whatsoever. While the main Robin War event has been good, the Lobdell-written tie-ins have been anything but.

A dull read. It's competently put together, and makes itself accessible for new readers, but there's very little about the characters or plot to hook readers in.

The plot of this was that two grown adults bicker like children... Outside of that, there isn't much. The Red Lanterns are evil again, completely forgetting Soule's excellent run (and the best Lantern run of the New 52).

Really mediocre. Dialogue was very Bendis-y, and so inorganic. The art is okay. Feels like every other forgettable Iron Man story. Don't expect anything on par with Warren Ellis or Matt Fraction.

This book is as aggressively mediocre as it gets.

Very clumsy storytelling and dialogue, and the dual narration simply doesn't synergize well.

Dull and boring. This has just become a generic Green Lantern Corps book thanks to Jurgens.

Remember when this title had a unique angle, and wasn't about Jurgens using his pet villain?

Great art, but is stuffed with some of the worst dialogue imaginable, and forced shipping. It's unfortunate when a writer goes for fanservice at the expense of good writing.

A typical "Oliver Queen loses his fortune" story, something that's happened again and again, heavy on narration boxes. Everyone you loved from the Lemire run gets character assassinated.

A dull issue with god awful narration. There is very little logic in character attitudes, and the series continues to take a "tell, don't show" approach to the Oliver/Dinah relationship. Only propped up by Ferreyra's excellent art. Safe to say this is one of the worse Rebirth series.

This arc really stumbles its way to the end. Dialogue continues to be overexcessive, and there are major gaps in the logic that dictates how characters behave. Percy's pacing problems from his previous series continue here. All in all, Green Arrow is a just a mediocre comic with good art.

An issue of nonsensical monologuing. Easy skip

Dull and pointless, this issue more or less cements Green Arrow as one of the worst Rebirth books so far.

Good art, mediocre writing with long-winded exposition dumps.

Not worth reading without Sejic's art.

Comprises of two okay stories, neither of which are interesting enough on their own. The 13-page "main story" does barely enough to introduce everyone's quirks, but little else. A disappointment coming from the previous New Suicide Squad run.

Would be better as just an Aquaman story.

So much soap opera and mishandled subplots. The ending was solid, though.

The Daredevil preview was impressive. The Inhumans previews gave off a good snapshot of what the series will probably be about. Everything else was forgettable.

Not terrible, but not great, either. It's an improvement from Percy's previous work, which was stuffed with shallow political analogies and unintentional racism. It's still full of Tumblr buzzwords, but it's not as bad this time. Tried a bit too hard to force the Oliver-Dinah relationship. Yes, we get it, DC. They're supposed to be "destined true loves". The art is the high point.

Fun, vibrant book that puts the characters in action. Hopefully, it doesn't lose its spark with the departure of Meyers.

A step down from the previous issues, both in terms of writing and art.

Feels like it should be a significant moment, but it gets derailed by a trite love triangle. Characters are written one-dimensionally, and the main event (the transgender wedding) is treated as a footnote.

Not a bad issue, but it's a bit lacking. Like previous issues, Barbara spends most of the time reacting between extremes, and ends up feeling two-dimensional. The book also tries to make a shallow attempt to address gentrification in a hipster neighborhood full of expensive coffee shops.

Pacing of the dialogue is off, and the personality clashes are too on-the-nose. A disappointing debut.

Well-drawn, but is otherwise a very boilerplate #1 event issue. The Suicide Squad all go through their stock catchphrases with little else to their characters, and the Justice League shows up for a fight. The only really interesting aspect was Max Lord.

I pity those who are too illiterate to read this comic 🤣🤣🤣. Maybe they're projecting their own loneliness.

LMAO people are still butthurt over the Hal Jordan tweets? Ethan Van Sciver making pro-pedophile tweets: I asleep One writer says he doesn't like Hal Jordan: real shit!

So bland and mediocre, I thought that I was reading a Geoff Johns book.

The pedophiles on YouTube are really butthurt over this, huh?

Starts off strong, but suffers from some severe decompression with too much blank moments. James Bond acts more like Archer than anything else.

Very little to take away from these showcases. They're all just lead-ins for hypothetical future stories that may not even exist. Good artwork, though.

Entertaining story if you don't have a parasocial relationship with sex predator Scott Lobdell. Edit: LOL the bootlickers on this site are obsessively angry at me because the world knows they're morons. This is what happens when you don't get vaccinated, folks. Children cannot consent, Merly.

Too much camp and hamfisted dialogue.

A serviceable introduction with poor art. The moral quandaries are displayed in full, and a bit on-the-nose. Not quite as good as the previous New Suicide Squad arc.

Nice art, the villain has some potential. Still waiting for it to develop a good direction.

Book has been pulled apart by editorial meddling.

Back to treading water

This title is treading water.

Best way to describe this is aggressively mediocre

The most useless of the Superman books. Guest appearances are really shoehorned in. Greg Pak's Action Comics is much better.

Long exposition monologues that serve no purpose, awful cringe-worthy jokes, broken postures, and disjoined paneling. Who thought Scott Lobdell or Brett Booth were good ideas?

Better than the current canon.

Has some fanservice, but overall just weak and clumsy dialogue. Easily the weaker of the two Batman books.

A slow issue, but unlike other "slow" issues (see: Wonder Woman), but the plot has been utterly unremarkable. Second issue of this arc, and it's stuck with characters talking about their backgrounds to one another. And then throw in some Tim/Steph fanservice that seems to be in there just for the sake of pandering to Tim fans. Seems like Detective Comics just continues to be the "Batman book that's nowhere as good as the main Batman book".

A slightly-better-than-mediocre Bat book. There isn't much to this issue outside of a plot twist that was telegraphed well in advance, and makes very little logical sense. Clearly the weakest among the double-shipped Bat books, but not quite terrible. Best treated as a fanservice book.

Blandly written issue with very little momentum thanks to non-stop exposition

Some good stuff, some bad stuff here. Most of this issue flowed well, except for the contrived writing that leads to the cliffhanger. The only reason there's any tension to the cliffhanger is because of the rumors of a certain character being killed off. Barrows is back on art, and his work is considerably weaker than Martinez's.

In some ways it delivers, but it can't help but hit some really tired cliches. The ending cliffhanger is a mess that brings to the surface the ever-present problem with Big 2 comics: that their individual stories are often getting derailed by the "big picture".

Overall, it's a decent conclusion to an underwhelming crossover that tries to be too many things at once. This issue provides a big bombastic finale but it isn't quite able to find its thematic conclusion. We're better off resuming the storylines of two excellent Batbooks and a decent Detective Comics run.

A bit wordy, but a much stronger start to a new arc than previous issues.

Best issue of Detective Comics yet.

Pure mediocrity

Wait for Tomasi.

Good back-to-basics street level mystery.

Strong showings from Warren Ellis, Scott Snyder, Paul Dini, and James Tynion. Worst of the bunch is either Kevin Smith's or Geoff Johns's stories.

Killing off Man-Bat and screwing over Justice League Dark for a bland zombie book is stupid.

lol Red Hood fans actually want that pedo-bait writer Scott Lobdell back?

This was mediocre, but 10 because it pisses off the JK Rowling simp.

It's fine, whatever. I'm sure there will be a crowd that will be outraged over it.

A solid start that doesn't move the plot forward, but does give the main characters time to settle in.

Reads a lot better than what the Bensons did with Batgirl and the Birds of Prey. The plot was kind of pointless.

A rushed plot that leaves makes the whole entirely mostly forgettable, outside of the setup for the New Justice books.

A straight-forward action flick. Hitch handles widescreen panels well, but struggles with close-ups and faces.

The art was really good, but the writing feels really forced. And the whole "dark secret that Batman is hiding from everyone" plot has been done too many times.

Really good character interactions all around, better than the first issue. Flashback sequence was really good, too.

Good for entertaining Batfamily interactions.

Weaker than the last two issues. The fight scene feels cluttered and goes on for too long, and the Batfamily interactions feel disjointed. Highlight was Dick giving a lecture to the new Robins.

Rather clumsily handled. Feels like Tynion wasn't sure how to handle Tim's origin, so he scrapped together an ill-conceived background, and left Orlando to fill in the blanks.

Solid issue with some nice flashback moments, although the plot continues to be contrived and uninteresting. Characterization was strong though. Even Jason Todd is written as a tolerable person, something that his own series is missing.

A weak and mediocre issue that spends too much time developing a subplot that ends up being meaningless, and shallow banter between two one-dimensional characters. Eternal seems to have fallen back into filler mode.

A surprisingly sound character-driven issue that sees Jean-Paul Valley turn over a new leaf, and Jason truly deal with his own death. The latter hasn't seen anything like that in his own series, so it's nice to see this, given that DC has essentially distanced itself away from everything that made pre-N52 Red Hood work.

Fun political satire.

Lots of fun, full of entertaining cameos. Exactly what you'd expect out of a crossover like this.

Interesting idea, though it feels like it hits some too familiar beats.

Mostly mediocre issue that just shows Superman being a jerk. Doesn't bring in any new development for the character.

Powerful issue that goes deep into what makes Hal Jordan tick, explores his drive and his flaws, and ultimately reconstructs him as a truly likeable hero in spite of everything.

Just meanders without doing anything. Losing the fun that the Future State issues had.

Heavily fragmented story that moves at a clunky pace, and doesn't really hook the reader in until the end. JRJR's art is a poor fit here.

Less disjointed than the first issue. A pulpy fun mess is what it is.

Manapul's artwork steals the show here. The script is mainly a setup for the one-shots, but the art is just gorgeous.

A weak issue overall. This event started off strong, but is dragging its feet. Plot twists are haphazardly thrown around with no substance, and most of the characters are just standing around doing nothing.

A dull and overly drawn-out conclusion that has to reiterate every little thing on the page, so that readers don't get confused.

A good, fun lead-in to Titans.

Mainly just an Aquaman 101 issue. Decent, but a bit wordy.

It's sad that this is ending so soon, but there are some really great plot developments in this issue, and it looks like it's heading towards proper closure.

It's a very predictable and "safe" Catwoman story. The art's well-done, and the writing doesn't overextend itself. Nothing bad about it, it just doesn't live up to what came before.

lol the anti-vaxxer is butthurt again

A good intro with an explosive start.

Crossover's been okay. Decent enough, nothing special.

Strong start for an event, with a healthy amount of worldbuilding.

A strong start that looks the establish the core dynamic between the characters while diving deep into their history. Very promising #1 issue.

Strongest start to a Batgirl book post-Flashpoint so far.

Mostly fun story that's somewhat held down by an oddly forced romantic subplot.

More fun than any actual Injustice book.

Book of the week. Excellent character-driven issue that continues to explore Nightwing's psyche.

Explosive finale with a few interesting developments. Still very character-rich.

Maintains a consistent tone from the previous crossover issue.

Rushed storyline that is more of a setup than a full arc. Still better written than Percy's Green Arrow, though.

Writing is fine for a status quo setup that the writer won't be bothering with.

Expect little more than predictable cliches and dry exposition. Nepotism is killing DC.

Scott Lobdell fans are LIVID lmao Edit: decided to raise it half a point just to trigger them some more

What are the Twitter incels outraged over this time? Something about this being offensive to rich people?

LOL the guy with a hardon for pedo-bait writer Scott Lobdell is blocking everyone who has a reasonable opinion. Just as bad as the anti-vaxxer.

Wow, the pedophile with the alts is really offended over "Happy Holidays", huh? What a thin-skinned snowflake.

LOL of course the guy (and his alts) who blocks people for saying "molesting children is wrong" is triggered.

Everything is pretty solid here except the coloring. Don't know what nepotism hire DC made here, but the shit I took last night was a better coloring job.

This issue is going to get negative review bombed by those with parasocial relationships with pedophile YouTubers (The Quartering, Yellowflash, etc). Wow, DoorMan and Mingthemerciless are really eager to defend pedophilia to the death. I wonder why.

The series has gotten stronger, though this was mainly setting up Robin War.

Who was the idiot who looked at Brett Booth's art and thought, "this is acceptable for a professional artist"? Nepotism is not good, folks. lol Brett Booth's friends getting salty

Dallied around a bit too much. Feels more like a setup issue for things to come.

Clunky issue, with too much exposition, and poorly paced plotting.

Very strong issue that moves multiple plots forward. Gordon gets some very nice moments, and the other storylines begin to come together nicely. There's an interesting cliffhanger there as well.

A rather introspective and self-aware issue that questions the value of fleeting tranquility, before racing towards an exciting climax. While this story arc has had a few lulls, there's no doubt that Snyder has managed execute a strong and character-driven story arc out of a status quo that had some shaking their heads.

It's a very emotionally heavy issue. The glimpses of future (or Elseworld) Batmans play nicely with the present-day story, and Snyder unexpectedly brings in a Chekov's gun to complete the arc for some meaningful closure.

Chip Zdarsky deserves better. Lol that weirdo Red Hood fanboy is seeeeething

lol Red Hood fans are SALTY AS HELL over at CBR. They want their Mary Sue back. edit: lol my stalker is back

I expect I'll get death threats again but's sad and pathetic that mentally-deranged morons are slandering Chip Zdarsky for writing Red Hood as a human character with flaws instead of whatever Mary Sue crap he was before.

LMAO Chip Zdarsky writes Red Hood as an actual character instead of a Mary Sue, and it's made that one mentally ill Red Hood fan super salty.

And of course, terminally online Red Hood fans and their alts are slandering Zdarsky for daring to write a good story instead of a Mary Sue fanfic.

lol the Twitter incels are ass-blasted over a comic they didn't even read Edit: Even funnier, the folks with the parasocial relationship with Jason Todd are once again slandering the best writer he's ever had.

Good setup, but very decompressed.

Decent collection of stories, more good than bad.

It's an inventory issue, but it's an issue that nicely captures what this whole book is about. The character interactions are handled well, and Fawkes conveys a firm understanding of who Damian is, and why he's trying to be. The artwork captures the frantic action of the story well enough.

A strong Rebirth issue that is packed with both action and heart, and plants the seeds for a first arc.

Eh. Could be better.

Shows a lot of promise and understanding of Superman. People can put their pitchforks down.

There's a setup to an overarching mystery, and this issue takes its time, while dropping hints everywhere. It's a book to follow for the long haul.

Powerful, tense, and full of action. Feels very much like Batman to the core, while still fresh at the same time. An issue that seems to have gone over quite a few people's heads.

Deals with the emotional impact from the previous issue, while setting up the greater plot. Lots of intrigue, and little nods to classic Batman stories.

Provides a great deal of backstory and character depth to the Gothams, while still moving the plot brusquely along with minimal handholding. Easily among the best Rebirth books.

Strong and emotional conclusion to the first arc, although its cliffhanger get is awkwardly integrated.

An entertaining start to a crossover, even if it's not as good as the regular book.

Very smart, well-drawn issue that serves as both a character study and an examination of how the legal system works with Batman.

Excellent self-reflective issue. People need to learn about how jury trials work.

Kind of pathetic that people are making alt accounts to review bomb this.

This run has been so middling enough that I can't imagine how the terminally online could actually get worked up over this. Or why that "professional" reviewer has to go attack everyone who disagrees with him.

It's sad that Red Hood fanboys are still harassing and trying to cancel Chip Zdarsky over Urban Legends. I know some of them got banned from this site for unspeakable and perverted things.

LMAO the idiot who harassed me and then blocked me is randomly screeching about Tim being black in a TV show. Poor guy has me living in his head rent free apparently. This is what happens when you let yourself get brainwashed by idiot Youtubers.

It's sad that mentally ill Red Hood fans are review bombing this with their sock puppets.

Is that brain-damaged Red Hood fan still review-bombing every Bat book with his alts?

A fulfilling comic with a ton of story packed into 20 pages, and plenty of surprises. Art is very clean, and despite having so many panels, the storytelling does its job very well.

Does a solid enough job looking at Damian's insecurities, and giving some fun but meaningful interactions between Damian and Selina. Was a bit more wordy than it probably needed to be.

lol the guy who simps for Scott Lobdell and his pedobait is crying about people having different opinions. This is what being an anti-vaxxer does to you, kids.

Good stories from King, Snyder, and Orlando. Dini's story was a letdown.