cincyfan's Profile

As a huge Wolverine fan I love seeing Albert and Elsie dee again I also love Larry Hama writing it. I thought this was a good book for a stroll down memory lane. I've actually recently reread Wolverine vol 2 and have always liked this pair.I will be honest I have not read any of the series and have no plans to either So I really don't know if it fits in with the overall story. I'm here just for Albert and Elsie dee

I was a bit disappointed with this but I will say I loved seeing Elsie dee and Albert again great memories from the 90's

I got to say in an event that I have absolutely loved every chapter of I think this may be my favorite book so far. I've always been a huge fan of wolverine my favorite thing about him is while he's portrayed as such a aggressive character at his core he's all about love devotion and sticking up for the ones he cares about. I absolutely loved how he was there for Gene this book is incredible and so is this event

Wow!!!! What an amazing start! This book is tremendous! This is shaping up to be a phenomenal story I can't wait for the next chapter

Brilliant story brilliant artwork and brilliant writing. This story is simply phenomenal! I have enjoyed every panel. It's such a fantastic time to be a comic book fan the depth of some of these stories and the talent of some of these artist and writers is mind-blowing. Kieron Gillen is one of the super star writers he continues to write amazing stories with tons of depth emotion and substance.

I love this event. The writing is phenomenal.

This was my favorite issue yet. That was pretty much a perfect comic in my book. I can't believe they fit that much story into one issue. This issue was Powerful, emotional,and Inspirational. The last page reveal was phenomenal as it was very powerful and the right call. It also is a huge step forward that will change the game for the mutants. Simply put the book is an absolutely brilliant one that left me blown away. I absolutely love comic books and issues and stories like this bolster and reinforce that love.

Wow!!! What an absolutely incredible event judgement day was. I thought this story was so powerful and moving. The story was complex and emotionally driven. The artwork was phenomenal throughout the entire run. I felt the tie in issue were so good they would even lift up the books they were in especially the fantastic four issues which had an absolutely beautiful storyline. The complexity and raw emotion of this book made this a epic and moving event that I will be rereading often. I have to say thank you to the entire creative team for a phenomenal story. I can't wait to see what comes next! It's a great time to be a reader of comic books!!!!

just a phenomenal book in every way!!

just amazing in every way! this and the venom book are the top books out there in my opinion Donny cates and ryan stegman = brilliance

great book! now what happens when he arrives

i have really enjoyed all three of these books they still have the dark action but with great hilarious jokes

I loved this book! very well written great art and a wonderful story

I liked how the story was presented but was not a fan of lana overall it was decent

I enjoyed this book silver banshee did some real damage but it just showed superman can't be everywhere at once

didn't really care for this one seemed a bit silly

much better writing in my opinion but man I can't wait until preus and his army of ignorant small minded bigots are gone

powerful writing great looking art

absolutely loved this! what a amazing celebration of superman that leads to the exciting and epic story bendis has in store! amazing art amazing stories!

loved just about everything about this book great continuation of the man of steel books

I for one really enjoyed this book it moved the story along wonderfully and was a great read! this and the superman title along with justice league flash and hawkman are the strongest books for dc in my opinion

another absolutely wonderful book! I can't wait to read the next one! bendis is doing a phenomenal job on these books!!

another great read there isn't much I don't like about this. the red cloud is a awesome new villian as usual I can't wait to read the next issue

another great book i can't wait to see what naomi brings and the red cloud is awesome!

wow this was a great book! the story, the art, the build up it was a excellent read!

another wonderfully written book as usual I look forward to the next one with great anticipation however I must say the art in this book took a gigantic step back

I enjoyed the story but the art is really bad unfortunately

The story was very interesting and is building up very well but the art is horrible

The story is decent but the art is really bad in my opinion

the story was decent but again the art doesn't work for me at all

I really enjoyed this book it was very well written and intriguing. I am very interested to see what comes next in this story arc! I'm still not a fan of the art however it seemed a little better. I really don't understand all the negativity smh but oh well to each their own

The story isn't bad though it wasn't on par with the last issue however once again the artwork is awful

I enjoyed reading it but the art was once again not so good unfortunately

For me the story was decent and I'm definitely interested to see what happens next however what can you say about the scribbled art. I saw a program about the history of daredevil books where John romita jr said his style is "whatever gets done on time" I guess he is a bit short on time

That was a nice ending I enjoyed it the art was very bad in my opinion though but overall a very good finale

This is a really cool concept. After hearing about this book from a podcast I listen to called comic book club i had to pick this up. I'm really intrigued by the story and look forward to issue two

I like the growth of laura in this but the whole squirrel girl story isn't the greatest but still fun. I think this was decent for a one shot

Great book very fun read

Great issue and first appearance of a legendary villain in carnage

This was great simply put it was a joy to read

there isn't much not to like about issue one. fantastic start

Fantastic writing great story

Absolutely loving this story arc it has everything I look for in a Spider-Man book

fantastic story for both spidey and mj

great conclusion to this arc nick spencer is doing a fantastic job writing spider-man

wow I really loved that issue! fantastic story and fantastic art makes for one fantastic book

fantastic conclusion! I really enjoyed the hunted story and this last book was the best in my opinion

great book I love nick spencer writing Spider-man he does a fantastic job! I also have to mention the bonus story at the end that was hilarious!!!!

fantastic writing and awesome art there isn't much not to love

Wow that was fantastic

Fantastic start

Great story great writing great artwork

Simply put this was a tremendous book!

Great story and fantastic artwork!

Fantastic writing and artwork! Huge cliffhanger I can't wait for the next issue!

Wow this is fantastic!!

I absolutely love this book! I love Nick spencer's whole run but t lately it's been fantastic! I really enjoy how he sets up stories and tells a deeper story instead of rushing things. The artwork is also fantastic and has been for the the entire spencer run

This is one of my favorite books right now this was fantastic and the artwork was terrific it was one of those books you open and such immediately say wow that looks awesome

A very good issue that sets up what is to come next. This issue did a great job really getting to the human element of many characters showing different layers of their personalities. This was terrific storytelling with great artwork

A very good issue that delves into the emotional struggles of peter and moves the story along. Both the writing and art are fantastic I love the depth of spencer's writing he is a fantastic writer

I think this a fantastic road to take Spider-Man down I'm looking forward to watching it all unfold. Although eventually he will need to and I'm sure will return to his classic suit this new suit looks really cool

This is a very exciting build up and the last page reveal made me say yes outloud lol. Great stuff like can't wait for the next issue

I was really enjoying this and then around halfway through the twist came and it went to another level. I absolutely love that they're building off of what happened in daredevil volume 2 as well it is one of my all-time favorite runs.

All kinds of great storylines in this one. This was a joy to read I'm really looking forward to the next issue and the sinister war is really sounding awesome to me

This was decent I bought it because I always get amazing Spider-Man books. I wasn't familiar with the story this ties into so it didn't do much for me personally

Fantastic setup for the sinister war! I'm really looking forward to it. I liked the artwork in this one too. There were a couple exceptional parts that really caught my eye and made me stop and really look at it. the image of Spider-Man above the city on the gargoyle head with birds around him was great I thought it really stood out

The story really starts to pick up in this one. Great issue can't wait for the next one

Kelly Thompson is quickly becoming one of my favorite writers. This book was a joy to read Ben Reilly's dialogue was fantastic. Great story and art this was a fun and funny book. Loved it!

This was absolutely tremendous! This had everything I could want in a Spider-Man book. The charecters where written with a lot of heart and emotion the action was exciting and the one liners where fun and funny. The artwork was unbelievable! After I had finished reading it I had to go back and just admire the artwork. Great book I can't wait for the next one

I really liked this creative team. Both issues were great and I'm really looking forward to the next issue. The artwork once again really stands out. Mike Dowling, Jesus aburtov and Erick arciniega do an amazing job!

This was great. This book had a lot of substance and heart. I love a book has a good amount of dialogue and moves at a gradual pace to really let you feel the emotions the charecters feel and build up the moment without being rushed or thin. This book delivered on many levels and was also a very important to the whole beyond storyline that has really been excellent so far.

It's decent but too basic and bare bones of a story for my personal taste. I hope the next issue goes back to the high level this book was at before. It's not that it's necessarily bad or anything I just like a little more to my stories. I hope others enjoyed it a little more than I did.

This issue got asm back on track after the last issue. Patrick Gleason did an amazing job both writing and drawing this issue! On a side note I liked the regular and variant cover for this issue but both me and my wife agreed the variant really stuck out. I see now that Gleason did the variant cover so I guess I can't get enough lol. Fantastic issue

I really like how zeb wells writes Spider-Man. I was really drawn into the story by the fantastic dialogue that had a lot of depth and emotions. The artwork is beautiful as well making this a fantastic all around issue

Great read! This was a very fun book as black cat brings a lot of character to the book. This and the mart Jane and black cat book made for a fantastic week of Spider-Man books

I'm loving the direction this book is heading and queen goblin is really cool

This continues to be a great story! The script is great Patrick Gleason is fantastic at writing Spider-Man. As usual with this book of late I'm really looking forward to the next issue

Wow talk about going out on a high note! I thought this issue was fantastic! It was an epic and emotional ending to the beyond storyline that sets up the next volume in a big way. Chasm looks awesome too when I finished the book I had to take a moment and take in the design of chasm. I think he looks awesome and I can't wait to see what comes next!

Since this volume started I haven't been really blown away by any of the issues. That's not to say they were bad but they were just kind of decent. That being said I love a story with depth and one that takes time to properly develop so I knew this could be really good I just needed to let it develop. I also love the gritty feel of this book. The last issue seemed to be a bit better but this one was phenomenal! What happened with tombstone was just brilliant! This book makes me think of NBA jams lol. Last issue was "he's heating up" and this one is "he's on fire!." I can't wait for the next issue.

Unfortunately this didn't work for me. It just wasn't my type of story. I felt like it had the same feel as a comic from the '60's. It was kind of a basic superhero story with little depth. Those types of stories don't do much for me however some people like them. I hope others enjoy it more than I did

Wow this was tremendous! I had been looking forward to this book since reading about it in a preview issue and it delivered. Ram v is a brilliant writer and probes that once again with a fantastic 1st chapter. The artwork was absolutely breathtaking! Christian ward really impressed me with every page of this book. I can't wait for the next issue

i really enjoyed that whole run it was a very fun read with fantastic art

I really enjoyed this book. It's a great classic tale that was written well

Disassembled is an absolutely phenomenal story! What a tremendous lead up to the masterpiece that is house of m! Phenomenal storytelling

I love Hickman's writing style. His stories always feel really epic and grand with multiple layers to them. The artwork is fantastic as well and gives the story more of an ominous feel. Fantastic first issue

Absolutely brilliant

While still brilliant I didn't find this issue quite as good as the other original sin avengers books.

Absolutely phenomenal!

i loved this book

ugh i can't stand the squadron supreme personally very nice artwork though

great book the only thing that doesn't work for me personally is i can't stand the cosmic ghost rider

excellent ending to this arc and i can't wait to see what happens next. great book!

wow that was a fantastic book! it's a must for iron man fans for sure

that was great! it really sets up what is coming well and has me excited to read it oh and moon knight is coming next awesome!!

This has been a fantastic arc! I really have no idea how it will end but I can't wait to find out!

I really enjoyed this entire arc I thought it was both well written and drawn wonderfully. I would say I was disappointed that it was over but then the last two pages set up the next arc and I love it!

Man what a great setup for the next arc I am really looking forward to what comes next! Fantastic book

Wow! Ok I loved this! The writing story and artwork were all fantastic I found myself totally emersed in the story the only negative thing about this book was that it ended. I would love it if they made a series about these original avengers I have loved all of them

I really enjoyed this and am very excited to read this arc I love the phoenix.The main cover is awesome wolverine looks great

There are parts I like but parts that don't really work for me unfortunately. I hope it picks up and gets a bit better. On a side note I was glad to see howard the duck go now if they could get rid of all the squadron supreme members that would be great I absolutely loathe those characters personally but I know that isn't going to happen

That was a big step forward from the last issue in my opinion. I loved the writing I thought the dialogue was fantastic and the artwork has been great throughout the arc. The end was huge! I hated that one of my favorite characters echo got a raw deal I think she is a fantastic character who should be used more (I'm a big fan of david Mack who created the character) I had my doubts after the last issue but I'm fully Invested once again

A few issues back in had my doubts but I have loved these last two!! I can not wait for the conclusion! Fantastic writing I absolutely love how jason Aaron has written the inner dialogue of these characters and really explored the inner workings of the phoenix force it's terrific. The artwork has been consistently fantastic as well. Bring on issue #44!!!

I wish I could give this a higher score about halfway through this when I started to realize what was about to happen based on the brilliant dialogue I got beyond excited! I actually started texting my wife saying this is amazing I think they're about to make one of my favorite characters the phoenix! then after the reveal I loved the ending with jean grey. I'm a huge David Mack fan and a huge fan of this character also the X-Men is my favorite book so all of this is beyond perfect. I can't say enough about the dialogue in this arc the writing is absolutely brilliant and the artwork is right on pace with the writing. The final book felt huge and by the end of it I had chills and was holding my hands in the air like I scored the game winning run in game 7 of the World Series Thank you to the creative team especially to Jason Aaron for taking this character to another level like this. This is and will always be one of my all-time favorite arcs!

Coming off the absolutely amazing phoenix arc that I had to read multiple times because I loved it so much especially who got the phoenix force. I thought this was another great issue. I have thoroughly enjoyed Aaron's entire run obviously some more than others but the book has been fantastic lately and one of my favorites. I won't lie I am not looking forward to the heroes reborn story coming up personally but have hope Aaron's story will change my mind I am elated with what he has been doing with echo and really hope it continues

That was great! I was fully invested in the story and had a blast reading it. Both the art and writing were great. I can't wait for the next issue!

Honestly I had this on my pull list because it's one of the books I always pick up. I didn't realize it was part of this storyline which also happened in the amazing Spider-Man annual. At first I was disappointed as I was hoping it would be another step in Jason Aaron's run that I have really enjoyed especially of late (minus the heroes reborn which I skipped because I really don't care for the squadron supreme). However I ended enjoying this story I liked the multitude charecter so I was pleasantly surprised. Admittedly I don't know all the details of this story but this was a good read and I am really interested in hopefully seeing more of multitude.

I have really enjoyed this arc so far and it continues with this issue. I found that this issue really showcased the gorilla man's internal struggles. The dialogue is fantastic and the story is very compelling. Big things are upcoming and the new winter hulk will be the wildcard

I thought this was tremendous! The narration was compelling and exciting. The progression of the story was also compelling and exciting. What happened with the hulk along with the narration layout was just fantastic. I loved this issue and am really looking forward to the next one!

Wow!!! I for one have been really enjoying Aaron's entire run on avengers but the last few storylines have been incredible! I especially love what happened with echo in the Phoenix story and was actually worried I might not like the world war she-hulk arc but ended up loving it. This book is worth every penny it is rich with massive stories that setup everything upcoming in a phenomenal way! I can't say enough about how much I loved this. It looks like the avengers book is going to be a fantastic read for the foreseeable future. Man, this was great!

After a stellar issue #50 Jason Aaron delivers again. Avengers has been a consistently fantastic book and has really been on fire lately.

Avengers continues to be great! I'm loving this story it's just so fun.

I have really enjoyed the avengers book for a really long time now and this issue kept the streak alive. I can't wait to see what's in store for the next issue

I have been loving Jason Aaron's avengers run since issue #1 it has been consistently great with very few issues I didn't care for and some moments I absolutely love (echo getting the phoenix power and joining and everything from 1000000 bc). So it comes as no surprise that even though I'm not a fan of nighthawk at all I still enjoyed this issue. Although I hope nighthawk isn't around long I agree with my girl Maya Lopez with a vote for redemption

A fun and really entertaining read. I'm looking forward to seeing where this goes

Creative and a interesting story but it didn't really do much for me unfortunately

I thoroughly enjoyed this one. I thought the writer absolutely nailed Hawkeye's dialogue and thought it was an absolute blast to read. I'd like to see him write a Hawkeye book after reading this because it was just such a fun read

Honestly though I have loved Aaron's avengers run I haven't really cared for this current arc. That being said I really enjoyed this issue! While I still am not a huge fan of this current arc this issue was the kind of issue that is good enough to elevate an entire arc. I'm looking forward to seeing where this goes

I have really liked jason Aaron's run on avengers from the start but had my reservations about the ending. However, I have to say this is turning out to be better than anticipated. While it's not phenomenal it is rather good so far. In a book that was all fighting in a over the top massive battle the dialog and exposition were fantastic. This is the kind of story that has a '90's feel but instead of the mindless fighting you would sometimes see jason Aaron's writing is giving it a layer of depth I didn't see coming.

It's a shame I'm not more into this final storyline as I've have thoroughly enjoyed the majority of Aaron's run. This was decent although it seems a bit messy. It feels like the actual story lacks depth and feels chaotic with the amount of characters involved. This is certainly better than avengers forever but I wish the amount of characters was scaled back so it could be more focused on singular moments and emotionally driven character moments. Instead it feels rather chaotic.

As someone who has really enjoyed jaskn Aaron's run on the avengers I admittedly have not liked this final story. Honestly I have continued to pick up the issues because I always have the avengers on my pull list and didn't want to be missing any issues from this volume. If it wasn't one of the books I collect I'd have probably dropped it when this arc started. However, this issue was a pleasant surprise! While the story overall still hasn't really been working for me I really enjoyed this issue. I really hope the rest of the arc will be similar to this issue because while not mind blowing this one was rather good

This volume of the avengers is coming out of the gate with two really great and well written books. I'm loving it so far

Wow! This volume of the avengers is coming out of the gates strong! This issue was the best one of the first three and has the makings of an absolutely epic story! I love it!!

I have thoroughly enjoyed Aaron's run on the avengers but the last few issues had been hit and miss for me. Honestly I wasn't sure if I'd like this final story but after reading this I have a bit more hope than I did going into it. This was an interesting beginning that makes me really think about all the possible outcomes. While I wasn't blown away by this issue it certainly makes me more eager to read the next issue

I really enjoyed Aaron's run on the avengers unfortunately this last story still fails to really work for me. However as a huge wolverine fan the reference of how mystique and wolverine met was awesome. I love that story from wolverine vol. 3

Well darn I love the avengers and really liked most of Aaron's run but this last story is just a complete miss for me. I often say I can't wait for the next chapter when reviewing books but unfortunately on this one I just can't wait for this storyline to end so I can look forward to avengers books again. As always when a book doesn't work for me I hope others enjoy this book more than I did

I was really looking forward to this one and it delivered. I love the heart and emotion of this story. I really wish this was at least a miniseries though as I'd love to learn more about them

This really feels like it was written in the '60's. It has the feel old school comics did where it's a fun story but lacks depth and emotion. I prefer the complexity and emotional stakes of modern comics but for those who miss the old school style books this would be a homerun.

This is a very fun read. It focuses on the charecter's relationships with one another while still providing some action. The writing is great as it really makes you feel like you know the charecters and their quirks by the end. On a personal note as a huge fan of Cassandra Cain I am very happy they are making this and look forward to the next issue. This is a very good start

Not bad but it's a silent issue and I'm not a big fan of those

This story kept getting better with every issue and ended on a high note with this one

Wow does that art scream '90's

This is great such a fun issue! The voices of the characters naturally came to mind it was like Adam West was reading the batman lines. Fantastic writing

This is so great I love it

This was phenomenal in my opinion! I loved every panel

The Catwoman stuff is great so is the art but the repetitive thing Batman says and the confusing back thing is not so great

This was great! The artwork was fantastic and the letter was written wonderfully. I have really enjoyed both letters they really let you get to know the person behind the mask better

I loved this one. I thought the writing was tremendous and the artwork was equally impressive

Amusing but this one didn't do a whole lot for me. It was decent

Very well written and beautiful artwork. I love the introspective discussion and seeing the human side of Batman. The discussion with Gotham girl was written beautifully and actually had a few little jokes I found amusing. This was a fantastic book

That was quite sad I really felt bad for kite man

Love it!!

Wow! What can I say about that masterpiece. Absolutely beautifully written and drawn it's a touching powerful look into Bruce and selina's life together that was Very moving and brought a tear or two to my eyes. A must own book for any Batman or Catwoman fan

Loved this! This was a incredibly fun read. This book was so enjoyable it brightened up my day

I loved the dialogue!

I thoroughly enjoyed this issue. The writing and art are both terrific

I'm a bit disappointed with what happened however I understand the thinking behind it. The way this book was put together was fantastic! I love the two perspectives and two artists idea I found it very clever and well written

The direction Tom king took this book after the wedding issue totally makes sense to me. This book was written and drawn very well

This arc was a perfect transition from issue #50. I enjoyed all of it but this issue in particular had tremendous writing

This was a very entertaining and fun look into the relationship of Bruce Wayne and Dick Grayson.

This is a fantastic issue!!! First off the art is gorgeous! The book was entertaining and funny until the shocking ending!

This one wasn't for me personally. I like a book with a lot of dialogue and this wasn't it. I would have liked the fairytale to be scrapped and had more dialogue and story telling written. I did like Batman's final few lines but this was a let down for me

the artwork is fantastic and the story is well written

great artwork the knightmare was decent but it felt a little off it didn't seem like something that Bruce would see to me

The artwork was fantastic and I think the writing was good as well. It definitely felt like a dream or "knightmare" Batman would have

I thought the knightmare arc was great and each issue was better than the last. I like the concept and execution of the last two issues a lot.

Shoot I really don't like giving negative reviews. I mean obviously I want to like it but I really don't like silent books. The only way a silent book is even decent to me is if it has fantastic art but the art in this was mediocre in my opinion. There really wasn't much of a story here either. Batman is one of my favorites I read and collect every issue of every volume they all can't be winners I understand that and unfortunately this is a complete dud to me

Darn, this is back to back issues I really haven't cared for. While this was better than the last issue it's still just pointless and odd. I haven't hated king's run like some and I actually really liked the first few knightmares books these last two are really disappointing.

That was definitely better than it has been recently again I liked some of the knightmares books but it went on entirely too long for me and two of them I didn't care for at all. This moves the story further a little and is clearly a set up for what's to come. It was decent however I'll be honest I didn't care for how effortless it was for Batman and I'll admit I don't understand what happened to amygdala and Grundy that was odd. I really don't like being negative and I've had to be on this book lately which is disappointing however it is better and it's not terrible overall just a rather weak and uninspired book I guess. However I will say the artwork was fantastic the characters were drawn shaded and colored very well so there is that

I dislike the nonlinear approach and was completely confused until around the halfway point. However I did like what the bat family said to him it answered a few lingering questions I had though I still have quite a few. Finally i'm sorry but Batman has suffered loss a ton of times before so I don get that and why is he such a irrational prick right now when he hit Tim for no reason they should've done something idk this was disappointing again

First off the writing is beautiful in this I tip my cap. I really loved how it sums everything up it explains the whole plan and it really makes me look at certain things in a different light. This book makes me want to reread the run and reconsider some perspectives. Honestly it's nice to have a recap on what in my opinion has been a rather inconsistent run that has left me with quite a few questions at times and to write it so beautifully yeah this was a very good issue

I absolutely loved everything about this! As usual with Tynion I loved the writing and this book was a joy to look at the artwork is beautiful

Tynion's Batman is great

This whole story arc has been fantastic! It continues with this one

This is one of the best books out there right now in my opinion

Wow I don't think I could've loved that more! 10/10 story, dialogue and art! The variant cover is insanely awesome too! I am so into the joker war James Tynion is such a brilliant writer I think it's going to be great

Another stellar chapter!! this continues to be the best dc book in my opinion with only daredevil ahead of it overall.

This was fantastic!!! I give it a 10 across the board!

Tremendous issue!! I couldn't have liked it more. Story 10/10 art 10/10

I loved this! I can not wait for issue 100!!!!! I absolutely love Tynion's writing he has to be one of my favorites if not my favorite writer. I also loved seeing orphan get involved as Cassandra Cain is one of my favorites. This was fantastic

This was fantastic! An almost perfect ending to great story that sets up multiple future stories. I can't think of a single thing I didn't love. The artwork was mind blowing. Story 10/10 dialog 10/10 art 10/10

This is a almost perfect set up for the future of this book and has me very excited for what's to come. The writing and dialogue are fantastic James Tynion is a brilliant writer. The artwork is also great there wasn't anything I didn't love about this one

I love this new character. This was beautifully written and drawn

For me this was almost perfect! This book once again was a treat visually and had tremendous writing. It had action suspense and comedy while still always showing the human and passionate side of the characters. James Tynion continues to write amazing books and has quickly become one of if not my favorite writers

This was fantastic! The writing was tremendous I felt the dialogue and storyline were both fantastic I love the development of ghost maker. The art wasn't as good as it has been in my opinion and that is the only reason I didn't give it a 10

Man I didn't expect that to happen but I absolutely love it! I can't wait until the next issue! Tynion has done an absolutely fantastic job with the Batman book creating new interesting and important characters some of which will be major characters in Gotham from this point forward. He writes Batman almost perfectly and takes the time to develop and give depth and substance to both the stories and characters which really brings the characters to life. Batman is one of the best books available ever since Tynion took over and I eagerly await the next issue

Tynion's new characters are great in my opinion and he has done such a fantastic job bringing them to life by telling very deep and understandable back stories. I can totally understand the point of view of the characters and how they got to their current state of mind. The art in this book may not be for everyone but for me personally I thought it was great it's a very unique style that really spoke to me. This was great

I absolutely loved this! The new scarecrow look is awesome! The story is fantastic and very well written I can't wait for the next issue. Tynion continues to be brilliant I hope he writes batman for as long as possible.

I enjoyed both stories especially the Batman one. I like the ghost maker character a lot and am excited to read more

I continue to absolutely love this run of Batman! The art and writing are nothing short of brilliant in my opinion. This is everything I'm looking for in a batman book. I wasn't sure what miracle molly was going to be about with those pants lol but after reading it I'm sold she is a phenomenal new character! I can't say enough about James tynion everything he writes just speaks to me and Jimenez and Morey do an amazing job bringing the words to life

I simply can't say enough about this entire run. Every issue is absolutely phenomenal! All the new and interesting characters all the new scenarios and perspectives all the adjustments showing all the ways batman is such a great character. I am a huge batman fan and like to read both batman and detective from every era all the way back to the beginning I have to say this current run ranks up there with some of my all-time favorites. Both the writing and the unbelievably awesome artwork makes this my favorite current book and there are a ton of amazing books out there right now but I would have to say this is the best in my opinion.

Another issue another gem. I really can't say enough about how much I have loved the Batman book since tynion took over. I love the story I love the pacing i loved the multiple layers and perspectives of the story. The artwork continues to be tremendous as well. I also really enjoy the ghostmaker stories they are doing a fantastic job of really letting us get to know the character. Of the current 22 books on my pull list batman is my favorite currently. I simply can't wait for the next one

Wow! This continues to be my favorite book. I can't say enough about how much I have loved what James tynion has done. The Batman story was incredible! I'm really into the miracle molly charecter and I really dig the unsanity collective. The artwork in the Batman story is fantastic as well. I also really enjoy learning more and more about ghostmaker the more I read of him the more I love that character as well.i would score this a 10+

Wow!! I'm going to try to convey how much I loved this as efficiently as possible. I personally am a huge batman fan I read and collect every issue of both batman and detective that I can get my hands on I am currently reading multiple errors of both books and for me personally since James tinnion has taken over the book it has been unbelievably great I've seriously just can't say enough I absolutely love how this book incorporates everything that has been happening in such a amazing way I am completely intrigued and drawn into the story it doesn't hurt that scarecrow is one of my favorite villains the writing is phenomenal and once you open the book the artwork is striking it's so great I'm not familiar with this artist but he immediately becomes one of my personal favorites this book is beautiful I mean I don't think I could be more excited about this fear state and honestly one of my biggest fears has come true when learning that tynion is leaving the book I'm just going to try to enjoy this story as much as I can while I can because this run tynion's run is going down is one of my personal favorites already I it just fits what I'm looking for in a Batman book so well it feels like an injustice to give this book a 10 out of 10 it should be 100 out of 10 this book is brilliant I absolutely love it books like this just make my passion and love for reading comic books grow. Thank you to the creative team for this gem

This continues to be my favorite book. Unbelievably great writing and artwork. I love everything about this one

This continues to be my favorite book. I am in love with tynion's batman run and so far the fear state storyline looks like he might be going out on top. I love a book that develops a story and has depth I also really like when there is a good amount of dialogue. Tynion is a master at all these things his batman books have an incredible amount of depth emotion and intrigue. The artwork is stunning as well and when you put the two things together you get an almost perfect comic book. This book just seems like it's on a higher level than almost anything else. I absolutely love reading comic books from all era's and build and read entire volumes of my favorite characters and teams. Batman is one of my favorites and for me personally this run tynion has put together has been one of my all-time favorites!

Phenomenal as always!!

Tremendous as usual! The dialogue and the depth and multiple layers of tynion's run. I'm very excited to see more of one my favorite characters Cassandra Cain as well

Once again I loved both stories. Jorge Jimenez's artwork is unbelievable

Wow! What an incredible ending to an unbelievable run on batman! Tynion's run has been one of my personal favorites on one of my favorite characters and what can you say about the artwork during his run it has been phenomenal!!! I'm very sad to see tynion leave this book and want to say thank you to the entire creative team that worked on the Batman book it has been a pure joy to read. I'm excited for the next chapter though Joshua Williamson is a brilliant writer. This book was perfect honestly. It was moving and powerful and visually stunning. The batgirls story was also fantastic and really funny at times. I'm a huge fan of Cassandra Cain so I love that they are making this book. I'm definitely going to add the batgirls book to my pull list

A very good epilogue that leaves Joshua Williamson and Mariko tamaki a lot of things to work with.I'm really looking forward to what they have in store. Finally, I have to say this issue will be one I will remember for Riccardo Federici's beautiful artwork.

Coming off an unbelievably fantastic run of batman expertly written by James tynion I was very interested to see where Joshua Williamson would take the dark knight. I was very pleased with the results as this was a very good first issue. The artwork was incredible!!! This might be one of the best looking books I've ever seen!

The Batman story was decent. I really liked the poison ivy backup story setting up the new poison ivy book that I have been really looking forward to and shall read next. omg I am so excited for the next issue when chip zdarsky takes over!!!!!

This was everything I was hoping for and then some! This book is exactly what I want to see in a batman story. The heart and emotion of the characters shine through in such a great way. The writing is perfect I my opinion matched by the unbelievably beautiful artwork. With this team working on batman this has a chance to be a phenomenal ride!

OK I have to say while I love chip zdarsky I surprisingly haven't been into his batman run so far but this is why I say have patience I know you need to let the story playout before totally judging it. So story one.. the fall to earth was written so brilliantly! The artwork was stunning! I absolutely loved his planning and problem solving as he was falling. I loved how he blacked out and then came to and the way the inner dialog was written. Then the battle with superman was epic. Finally the ending was unbelievable! I loved Tim drake's emotion I loved the plan to add compassion realizing it was a tool he need to utilize. I love his last line to Tim drake. I'm beyond curious where he ended up at the end and what superman's state is. I did not expect to be so completely blown away and absolutely adore every single panel of this batman book!!!!! Then there is the second story which I haven't been all that into. This finale reminded me of a moon knight premise (which is a great thing). One that I thought was deep, thought provoking and simply brilliant. The writing was unbelievably beautiful and deep. The artwork was also brilliant! Revealing Zur en arrh to be faceless anger was absolutely brilliant!!!! The two sides of batman and joker.... brilliant and expertly executed. I absolutely adored this issue!! My goodness it's a wonderful time to be a comic book lover! I love this stuff!!

After reading this issue I am very intrigued by this story. The writing is superb which is no surprise with a brilliant writer like chip zdarsky. I absolutely loved the way the dialog was written. I can't wait for the next issue this is really starting to get good and I have no idea what to expect but with chip zdarsky behind the wheel chances are it's gonna be great

While this isn't the type of batman story I'd typically like it is written so well that I found myself completely engrossed in it. The emotional level of many of the characters really resonated with me and I found both stories to be really interesting and entertaining.

Wow that was a big disappointment. I didn't care for that at all. I like complex and emotionally driven storytelling not fan service and TV characters layered over a paper thin story. I love chip zdarsky usually but his batman has not worked at all for me for the most part. I do hope others enjoyed this more than I did because this was a big swing and a miss for me

I have to say I'm a huge collector of batman books both batman and detective and know there are going to be different takes on the character some of which aren't going to work for me. That being said though I want to find that missing piece that makes me think oh I see this was all misdirection I haven't found it. Zdarsky is one of my favorite writers his daredevil was amazing as was Spider-Man life story but this is a complete mess it seems. I understand that is just my opinion chip zdarsky is a phenomenal writer so I have faith this will all come together but yikes. I was so excited for zdarsky to take over batman unfortunately I am having doubts now. I keep rereading the issues hoping to find that missing piece or keep hoping the next issue will connect the dots but so far this ranks up there with the azreal taking over as batman era I really don't care for or some of tom king's missteps imo. If you liked this book I'm jealous because I really want to. I get no joy out of writing negative reviews. I hope things will click down the line for me and I'll see things in a different light. I hope I come back and change my score but maybe this just isn't for me. On a positive note the art was fantastic

this has been such a great series so far Joshua Williamson is one of my favorite writers and he continues to impress

Very good issue it was well written but what do you expect from a brilliant writer like joshua williamson and the art is absolutely beautiful

Wow that was tremendous! Cassandra Cain is one of my favorites and I love her origin story but if you are going to retell it that's how you do it!! Fantastic cover as well

Loved it! I thought it was a exciting read and I loved the art

A team that features Cassandra Cain, katana and has batman on the outside that is a winner in my book! The detective comics arc that led up to this was brilliant in this continues down the same path. what an awesome first issue

Great issue! Any issue that focuses on Cassandra Cain is going to be great in my book

Fantastic start to this series! Great writing beautiful artwork

Fantastic book

Another great issue! This one has a few storylines going and all are great especially the batwing and Jim corrigan one

Tremendous book! Wow!!

What an amazing ending to a amazing series. I absolutely loved it!!

This felt like a classic batman story. I found the story itself very compelling and fun to read with a couple of funny jokes along the way. I love the amount of dialogue there is I'm a big fan of dialogue heavy books. I decided to pick this up at the last minute because I love Batman but wasn't sure about this one and after issue one I'm definitely adding issue 2 to my pull list

A fun read with very good art setting up a very unlikely team up. I really enjoyed the dialogue and the way Bruce assessed the situation, his options then coming up with a less then ideal partnership

This was absolutely phenomenal! I was blown away by this book as both the writing and artwork were brilliant! This is storytelling at it's finest with art that matches the tone perfectly. I'm a huge batman and ra's al ghul fan and was really looking forward to this issue and it was better than I ever could have guessed. Absolute brilliance!

What a fantastic origin story! Miracle molly is quickly becoming one of my favorite characters

Wow this is phenomenal!!! I loved everything about this story and wow the artwork was amazing! 10 all day

I love how this is written from the perspective of Batman from the future one who is older and a bit slower it gives this book a uniqueness. I am a big fan of both Tom Taylor and Andy kubert's so I had high hopes for this one and it delivered. I am looking forward to issue two

Wow that was fantastic! I love the way this was written. I love the pacing and the feel of it. The artwork is perfect as it matches the time of the story and is absolutely beautiful. You really get your money's worth in this one! Great first issue

Iconic tale and a must read for not only Batman fans and comic book fans but bibliophiles in general

When I heard chip zdarsky was writing a batman book I thought with the way he is writing daredevil I'll bet this is going to be a great Batman story. I was right this is a tremendous start to what is sure to be a great miniseries

Wow! This book is and has been brilliant! I have loved every panel of every issue so far. This is shaping up to be one of my favorite stories

I loved this! It was dark and gritty and has me really intrigued to see where it is going to go next

I love Kevin smith's writing style I'm fully invested in this story and am very interested in baphomet.

I love everything about this

I felt this was a almost perfect ending to a almost perfect story! I did feel bad for Jason Todd though

What a great story! Lots of heart and character moments. A fantastic addition to the beyond storyline

Now this is my kind of story!! This book is incredible I absolutely love the direction they are taking this character. The writing is brilliant and the artwork is beautiful. If you ask me black adam is a must read

Wow this is incredible! This is one of my favorite books on the shelves right now

This book continues to be stellar! Teth adam is forced to really look deeply into his past with quite a surprising twist at the end. The direction they are taking this character is very intriguing and exciting to me. The phenomenal writing, artwork and depth of the story makes this book a must read in my opinion

This series has been consistently fantastic and it continues in this issue. I love the writing in this book. I find the story to be fascinating and I really didn't want it to end. The artwork is beautiful and matches the tone of the story perfectly. The only thing I don't like honestly is the fact that this is issue 9 of 12. I really don't want this book to end.

this was my first black cat book she is a great character but I bought the book because of wolverine. this was a very good book very fun and entertaining and I love how they had wolverine as patch

I love black widow and this volume hits on everything I like about the character